
Daisy Kelliher’s recent stint on Below Deck Sailing Yacht season 5 raised eyebrows and left fans wondering if she will return for the next season. Initially introduced as a brilliant and witty Chief Stew in season 2, Daisy’s reputation took a hit in the previous seasons. A romantic entanglement with First Mate Gary King and her flirtations with former Chief Engineer Colin Macrae created a tumultuous atmosphere, especially when stepping into the dynamic of season 5.
As the season kicked off, Daisy confronted Gary about his declining behavior following her breakup with Colin. Even though he failed to offer a true apology, he provided reasons for his distance. As tension mounted, Daisy found herself drawn to Deckhand Keith Allen, all while Gary struggled with sobriety. With the conclusion of season 5, the uncertainty surrounding Daisy’s future on the show lingers.
Daisy’s Disobedience Towards Captain Glenn
Professionalism Slips Away

Once renowned for her professionalism, Daisy’s recent conduct on the show has raised questions about her character. During the penultimate charter of season 5, she openly defied Captain Glenn Shephard’s directives. While the charter guests wanted the crew to join them for a night out, Glenn insisted that only a subset of the crew could participate, emphasizing that certain members needed to remain onboard to ensure everything ran smoothly.
Despite this, Daisy disregarded Captain Glenn’s orders and opted to join the guests on shore, leaving Diana Cruz and Danni Warren frustrated. When given specific rules—limited to two drinks and a return by 2 a.m.—Chase adhered to the guidelines, while Daisy and Keith indulged, downing four drinks each, with Gary exceeding limits dramatically. Although Daisy offered an apology the following day, her blatant insubordination was a stark contrast from her typically reliable demeanor.
While Captain Glenn chose to overlook the crew’s misbehavior to some extent, his leniency may not bode well for Daisy’s future with the show. In light of her slip in standards, production and Glenn might hesitate when discussing her contract for the upcoming season.
Daisy’s Challenging Charter Season
Conflict with Fellow Crew Members

Throughout season 5, Daisy faced significant challenges that could lead her to reconsider her participation in the series. From the outset, crew members Danni and Diana openly questioned Daisy’s leadership abilities, which led to overt insubordination. Daisy’s willingness to avoid assigning tasks based on rank backfired, as tensions escalated between the stews. Both Danni and Diana resisted taking on essential duties, leading to conflict and discontent.
Despite her attempts to maintain professionalism, Daisy’s interactions with Danni and Diana turned increasingly hostile. Their lack of competence forced Daisy to confront her frustrations, resulting in an openly rebellious team dynamic. Although she may have initially enjoyed Captain Glenn’s support, her recent actions could well have altered this perception, possibly prompting her to leave the industry altogether rather than deal with such tension.
Shifting Focus to Influencer Status
Life Beyond Yachting
Daisy’s rising social media presence may provide a glimpse into her future interests, distancing her further from a yachting career. With over 437, 000 followers on Instagram, her posts garner significant engagement, providing her with a platform to express herself beyond the confines of yacht life. In a recent post, she seemed to call out Danni, asserting her stance on the workplace atmosphere they experienced.
“Honestly, how dare you make them work the job they were hired to do.”
Additionally, she demonstrated her growth by taking proactive steps in her personal life, such as freezing her eggs amidst navigating support for her sister after a traumatic accident in Thailand. With these developments, it’s clear that Daisy is prioritizing her personal growth and happiness over the demands of managing difficult coworkers.
The Future of Daisy and Gary’s Relationship
End of Daisy and Keith’s Relationship
As the season closed, the chemistry between Daisy and Gary lingered in the air. Nonetheless, Gary’s struggles with sobriety cast doubt on their potential romantic future. Daisy gravitated toward Keith for his level-headedness and maturity, yet she recently announced their split via Instagram, explaining, “Keith and I dated casually for a year after filming… we decided to go our separate ways.”
“Keith and I dated casually for a year after filming. We explored the idea of a relationship but because of a few different reasons but mainly distance we decided to go our separate ways. I know everyone is invested in my life so I wanted to share some of our memories together. We remain good friends.”
Despite parting ways, Gary and Daisy’s relationship was marked by numerous intimate moments throughout the season. If Gary can maintain his sobriety and address his personal challenges, there may still be hope for a deeper connection between him and Daisy. Should they overcome these obstacles, fans could be treated to a riveting boatmance in potential future seasons, presenting a compelling reason for Daisy to return to the series.
Below Deck Sailing Yacht is available for streaming on Peacock.
Sources: Daisy Kelliher /Instagram, Daisy Kelliher /Instagram
Leave a Reply