The True Story of In The Heart Of The Sea: How Fear of an Ironic Threat Led to the Essex Crew’s Brutal Deaths

In the Heart of the Sea provides a gripping portrayal of the ill-fated 1820 voyage of the whaling ship Essex, but it omits some critical details that could have significantly changed the fate of its crew. Directed by Ron Howard, this 2015 historical adventure drama is adapted from Nathaniel Philbrick’s non-fiction work from 2000, titled *In the Heart of the Sea: The Tragedy of the Whaleship Essex*. Philbrick’s narrative explores the harrowing experiences of the Essex crew following their ship’s catastrophic sinking, yet crucial elements are left unexplored in the film.

The Essex set sail from Nantucket in August 1819, embarking on a demanding two-and-a-half-year whale hunting expedition. Just over a year later, tragedy struck when a whale violently attacked the vessel, resulting in significant casualties among the crew and forcing those who survived into smaller lifeboats. Stranded in the Southern Pacific Ocean, thousands of miles from the nearest shore, the crew faced the dire challenge of survival with minimal resources.

A Tragic Irony: The Essex Survivors Avoided the Marquesas & Society Islands Due to Fears of Cannibalism

The Crew Ultimately Resorting to Cannibalism

Faced with the grim reality of their situation, the Essex survivors had to develop a survival strategy. In *In the Heart of the Sea*, their decision seems straightforward, but in reality, the sailors were torn. Historical accounts, including one from The New York Times, indicate that the crew was relatively close to the Marquesas and Society Islands. However, notably, key figures like George Pollard Jr. and Owen Chase were deeply concerned about the potential threat of cannibals residing on those islands.

Due to their fears, the survivors calculated that they would be better off traveling 1,500 miles south to the uninhabited Henderson Island. Tragically, this decision led them to a grim fate, as they ultimately had to engage in cannibalism to survive—actions depicted in *In the Heart of the Sea*, but missing the poignant irony inherent in their choice.

Herman Melville’s Insight on Survival: A Missed Opportunity

Inspired by the Tragedy: Melville’s Moby Dick

Herman Melville, who drew inspiration from the Essex’s disaster for his renowned novel *Moby Dick*, posited that if the crew had put aside their fears of cannibalistic encounters and headed towards the Society Islands, their chances of survival would have drastically improved. Citing The New York Times, he suggested that a safer outcome could have been possible had they navigated towards the islands instead of their eventual path. Nevertheless, as history illustrates, the ramifications of their decisions remain a haunting mystery.

Source: The New York Times

Source & Images

Related Articles:

15 Biggest Box Office Flops of Disney’s Animated Films

12:02January 9, 2025

How Scrubs Season 10 Can Compensate for the Absence of This Major Event Between the Last Two Seasons

11:42January 9, 2025

On Call Ending Explained: Do Harmon and Diaz Take Down East Barrio Criminals?

11:36January 9, 2025

Dexter Sequel Series Assures Fans It Will Address Major Complaints from New Blood’s Conclusion

11:23January 9, 2025