‘Sonic the Hedgehog 3’ Misrepresents Military Critique in the Game

Sonic the Hedgehog 3 embodies a family-friendly ethos, aligning with the expectations of its target audience. However, when venturing beyond the world of Pixar, American media occasionally underestimates viewers, oversimplifying complex themes and narratives. This is particularly evident in Sonic 3, which grapples with its portrayal of the military in a half-hearted manner, leaving viewers puzzled about its stance.

A Closer Look at Sonic 3’s Narrative Roots

Historically, most of Paramount’s Sonic films have not been direct adaptations of specific Sonic games. Although the original Sonic games are cherished for various reasons, storytelling depth is often not one of them. In contrast, Sonic 3 is intricately connected to Sonic Adventure 2: Battle, a title that marks the debut of the character Shadow in the franchise. While the film does not replicate the game’s storyline verbatim, it does maintain key plot elements, including Shadow’s origins and the villainous Eggman’s ambitions surrounding the Eclipse Cannon. Interestingly, in the game, the threat was only to a part of the moon, indicating the subtle shifts in narrative severity from game to film.

Understanding G.U.N.: A Complex Representation

In the Sonic universe, the Guardian Units of Nations, abbreviated as G.U.N., serves as the primary military entity. It functions similarly to an international force while representing the national military for a fictional country known as the United Federation. This nation is closely modeled after the United States, and it’s quite evident that the President of the United Federation resides in a structure reminiscent of the White House, thus making G.U.N. an equivalent to the American military.

This context sheds light on Sonic 3’s ambiguous relationship with G.U.N. While the film acknowledges the group has made dubious decisions, it seems hesitant to criticize these actions or the individuals behind them. Characters like the general overseeing Project Shadow—a series of experiments linked to the character Shadow the Hedgehog—are depicted as honorable figures, complicating any viewer attempts to label them purely as antagonists.

Even as the plot unfolds, the generals facing off against Sonic and Eggman are set in a confrontational light, yet they aren’t wholly condemned. The film presents a sentiment of distrust towards G.U.N., especially after Sonic discovers Project Shadow, yet this notion hangs unresolved, leaving audiences in a state of ambiguity.

Contrasting Themes with Sonic Adventure 2

The indecision prevalent in Sonic 3 becomes even more pronounced when juxtaposed with its predecessor, Sonic Adventure 2. In this game, Gerald Robotnik’s motivations for developing Project Shadow stem from the United Federation’s desire for advanced weaponry. Initially uninvolved, G.U.N. audaciously steps in, resulting in a violent takeover that culminates in the tragic death of Maria.

Shadow’s narrative has been interpreted across various Sonic adaptations. Typically, the account reveals that Maria is shot by a G.U.N. soldier during her escape with Shadow, linking her demise to the organization’s actions.

In numerous stories, G.U.N.’s soldier inadvertently causes Maria’s death—often portrayed as a tragic outcome of fear-based reflexes. In contrast, Sonic 3 alters this event by introducing a nervous soldier who accidentally triggers a power source explosion, thereby indirectly causing Maria’s end. This choice of narrative minimizes G.U.N.’s direct culpability.

A Cautionary Approach to Sensitive Themes

The evident reluctance of Sonic 3 to present the military and its actions in a critical light raises intriguing questions. By softening the portrayal of G.U.N.’s failures, the film shies away from making any definitive statement that could be perceived as “woke.” This strategic decision appears to circumvent backlash from segments of the American audience. It begs the question: can a mainstream film aimed at children evade deeper ethical scrutiny of a fictional representation of military forces? As societal discourse shifts towards more conservative values, this question grows increasingly relevant.

Nonetheless, Sonic 3 manages to maintain its family-friendly classification, perhaps at the cost of a more profound engagement with its source material.

Source & Images