Fact-Check: Did Lyle Menendez Molest Erik in Real Life? Exploring the Allegations Against The Menendez Brothers

The recently launched documentary titled *The Menendez Brothers*, which premiered on Netflix on October 7, 2024, meticulously fact-checks numerous inaccuracies propagated in Ryan Murphy’s series *Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story*. This insightful documentary provides a precise account of the siblings’ narrative, focusing specifically on the legal proceedings that resulted in their conviction for the murder of their parents.

In addition to addressing these various falsehoods, the documentary highlights a burgeoning discussion across social media platforms. This dialogue questions the nature of the relationship between Lyle and Erik Menendez, particularly regarding allegations of abuse. Such claims stem from *Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story*, which controversially portrayed the brothers as having an incestuous relationship.

It is factual that Lyle Menendez did abuse Erik as children; however, experts suggest that this behavior should be viewed within the broader context of the trauma they experienced.

Fact-Checking the Allegations of Abuse Against Lyle Menendez

During the original trials, Lyle Menendez confessed to having harmed Erik at the tender age of eight. He disclosed that he took his younger brother to the woods and used a toothbrush to penetrate him. This troubling incident, however, was contextualized as a reaction to the severe trauma inflicted upon them by their father.

It was reported that the brothers’ father inflicted similar acts of sexual abuse upon them, and the culmination of this trauma ultimately led to their retaliatory actions against both him and their mother. Author Robert Rand, who has extensively researched the brothers’ lives and authored *The Menendez Murders: The Shocking Untold Story of the Menendez Family and the Killings that Stunned the Nation*, supports this theory.

Rand contended that Lyle’s actions toward Erik were more a reflection of their family’s sexual trauma rather than indicative of a mutual relationship. In an interview with *The Hollywood Reporter*, Rand stated:

“There were rumors during the trial suggesting a peculiar relationship between Erik and Lyle. However, based on Lyle’s testimony, I believe their only contact occurred when Lyle, at the age of eight, took Erik into the woods and interacted with him using a toothbrush, mimicking actions their father had performed on him. Therefore, I would not classify that life as a sexual relationship; instead, it’s a direct response to their trauma.”

Criticism of Ryan Murphy’s *Monsters* Series

Since its debut, Ryan Murphy’s *Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story* has faced backlash for its sensationalized and incestuous portrayal of the Menendez brothers. Viewers have vocally criticized Murphy for misrepresenting their story, prompting Erik Menendez to express his dissatisfaction through his wife, stating:

“I believed we had progressed beyond the damaging lies and distorted character representations of Lyle, which were exaggerated and founded on egregious inaccuracies presented throughout the show. I can only conclude that such misrepresentations were intentional. With a heavy heart, I must contend that Ryan Murphy cannot be so uninformed and misleading about the facts of our lives without malicious intent.”

This distortion of the truth in the series sparked the creation of *The Menendez Brothers* documentary, which authentically portrays the trial from the perspectives of those genuinely involved.

The latest documentary is now available for streaming on Netflix.

Source