‘A Complete Unknown’ Review: Timothée Chalamet Delivers a Stellar Performance as Bob Dylan in James Mangold’s Film

Creating a biographical film about a prominent musician can be a daunting task, as many end up feeling inauthentic—often influenced too much by hindsight. However, in A Complete Unknown, director James Mangold skillfully presents a rich and intricate portrait of the legendary artist Bob Dylan.

Exploring Dylan’s Journey

The narrative follows a young Dylan, portrayed by Timothée Chalamet, from his arrival in New York City through his electrifying performance at the Newport Folk Festival. This film not only chronicles Dylan’s rise to prominence but also showcases an impressive cast of characters who played pivotal roles in his artistic journey. For instance, Edward Norton takes on the role of Pete Seeger, who encounters a budding Dylan shortly after the songwriter’s visit to the ailing Woody Guthrie (Scoot McNairy) in the hospital.

Unlike many biopics that typically feature iconic performances of famous songs, the strength of A Complete Unknown lies in the emotional resonance of Dylan’s music. It is evident that he was not necessarily the best vocalist, yet his profound lyrics captivated audiences worldwide, transforming him into an international sensation.

Emotional Investment and Supporting Characters

As I engaged with the film, I found myself emotionally invested in the reactions of those hearing Dylan’s songs for the first time. This mirrors the powerful sensation I experienced upon first listening to Dylan’s poignant lyrics. The film’s true triumph originates from its supporting cast, who enrich Dylan’s narrative and emphasize that while he was a flawed individual, his genius was undeniable.

Joan Baez, portrayed by Monica Barbaro, emerges as a significant figure in promoting folk music to a broader audience, fully aware of the transformative potential of Dylan’s words. Meanwhile, Boyd Holbrook’s Johnny Cash expresses enthusiasm for Dylan’s refusal to conform to expectations, highlighting the artist’s complexity and nonconformity.

A Balancing Act of Impersonation and Interpretation

Portraying a figure as iconic as Bob Dylan presents the risk of slipping into mere imitation. This challenge is exemplified by films like I’m Not There, where multiple actors depict different stages of Dylan’s life. Chalamet, however, expertly captures the essence of Dylan, balancing his idealism and commitment to social change with an awareness of Dylan’s self-centered nature.

While Dylan’s reputation as a genius is well-deserved, his demeanor could be challenging for those around him. The film is set during a tumultuous time in Dylan’s career—his transition from folk music roots to rock ‘n’ roll, culminating in the legendary hit “Like a Rolling Stone.” Chalamet’s performance vividly illustrates the multifaceted nature of Dylan, effectively showcasing both his artistic brilliance and the complexities of his personality.

Defying Expectations and Personal Relationships

Bob Dylan walking down the street — (Searchlight Pictures)

A notable aspect of Dylan’s persona is his refusal to perform the songs that his audience clamors for—a theme beautifully explored in his relationship with Baez. Barbaro’s depiction is both vibrant and magnetic, reflecting Baez’s struggle to temper Dylan’s rebellious spirit.

The film begins with Dylan in a romantic relationship with Sylvie Russo (Elle Fanning), leading to the creation of the iconic album cover for The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan. However, his connection with Baez ultimately shapes his artistic trajectory. Their dynamic reveals not only their shared pursuit of musical evolution but also Baez’s understanding of audience engagement, as she advocates for performing hits like “Blowin’ in the Wind” —a request that Dylan resists.

Through the lens of their relationship, the film highlights the complex interaction between personal desire and artistic integrity, underscoring how Dylan’s commitment to authenticity often strained his relationships.

A Profound Examination of a Musical Legend

Dylan’s music is everlasting, and his famous quote, “All I can be is me, whoever that is,” embodies his refusal to conform to labels. Mangold’s film poignantly captures the essence of Dylan’s character, offering rare insight into the early days of his career.

The transformation from smaller venues like The Gaslight to the grand stages of the Newport Folk Festival pulls viewers into Dylan’s world, resonating with the unique experience of rediscovering his songs as if for the first time. This immersive storytelling fosters a deep connection for longtime fans and newcomers alike.

In conclusion, A Complete Unknown is a compelling exploration of Bob Dylan’s life and artistry that balances admiration with candidness, providing audiences with a rich, multifaceted portrayal of a true musical icon.

Source & Images