Horror games possess a distinctive design philosophy, uniquely crafted to tap into primal fears and evoke profound emotional responses. Creating genuine terror can be an elusive art, leading to a mixed bag of outcomes in the gaming world.
As a result, the landscape of horror games is dotted with both masterpieces and flops. Notably, some titles branded as ‘bad’ horror games may have been unjustly categorized. If you’ve already played through the renowned horror classics and are seeking something different, this list highlights several underrated titles that deserve a second look. While they may not reach the heights of quintessential games like Silent Hill 2, they certainly offer valuable experiences.
In this guide, we will spotlight games receiving scores of 75% or lower on aggregate review sites such as Metacritic and OpenCritic, all categorized under ‘Horror’ as a primary genre tag.
10 Murdered: Soul Suspect
Solve Your Murder
Murdered: Soul Suspect may come off as an unusual entry, especially considering its frequent meme status due to quirky AI bugs. While these glitches can detract from the overall immersion, the game offers a compelling murder mystery experience.
The unique premise of a ghost investigating their own murder sets an intriguing tone, though the game leans more towards ‘paranormal noir’ than traditional horror. While its deductive gameplay might feel simplistic, the rich story and atmospheric setting more than compensate for these shortcomings. It’s certainly worthy of more appreciation than its initial reception suggests.
9 Kholat
But Does Sean Bean Die?
For fans of the walking simulator genre, Kholat presents a unique experience that may have struggled to gain praise from critics. Many considered it lacking in traditional gameplay elements, but its intention was never to rely on jump scares or frantic action.
The game excels in creating a haunting atmosphere, immersing players in an isolating environment where a sense of lurking danger prevails. While combat is absent, players can engage with Sean Bean’s voice and enjoy a narratively gripping experience that captivates from beginning to end.
8 GOLD
Horror for Cowards
GYLT embraces its identity as ‘horror for cowards, ’ offering a light-hearted yet engaging alternative to traditional horror games. Tailored for a broad audience, it combines cartoonish elements with the typical survival horror motifs of stealth, puzzle-solving, and exploration.
At the heart of GYLT is a poignant narrative surrounding the issue of high school bullying. The innovative use of a flashlight as a weapon adds depth while maintaining a family-friendly atmosphere. Although it may fall short with its boss encounters, GYLT represents a delightful gateway into the horror genre.
7 The Park
An Emotional Rollercoaster
The Park has garnered a cult following, largely thanks to its unique premise and captivating storytelling, despite mixed reviews from critics. Set in an eerie abandoned theme park, the narrative revolves around a mother’s descent into madness, bringing a chilling depth to the atmosphere.
While the game lacks standard horror elements such as combat and puzzles, it compensates with a rich ambiance and strikingly memorable moments. The ambiguous storytelling provokes thought and reflection, leaving players questioning reality, making it a haunting experience that lingers long after completion.
6 The Town of Light
If You Don’t Go Mad, You’ll Go Mad
Another walking simulator, The Town of Light offers a poignant exploration of mental health through the lens of psychological horror. Players inhabit the mind of a former psychiatric patient, uncovering harrowing memories tied to a formidable setting.
While some may find the exploration repetitive and the puzzles uninspired, the game provides a powerful narrative experience that resonates deeply with those interested in the themes of psychological horror.
5 Maid of Sker
Don’t Make a Sound!
In horror gaming, sound design can be a pivotal element, and Maid of Sker elevates this aspect through its immersive experience in a chilling hotel setting. Players must navigate with precision, managing sound to influence enemy behavior and survive encounters.
4 Children of Silentown
Retro Meets Modern
Fans of classic point-and-click adventures will find Children of Silentown to be a delightful homage to the genre. In a village where making noise attracts deadly monsters, players embark on a quest to uncover the mystery behind missing children.
The game plays out through exploration and item collection, capturing the nostalgic essence of 90s gaming while infusing modern polish and a chilling atmosphere, making it a hidden gem worth experiencing.
3 The Evil Within
Crafted by horror veteran Shinji Mikami, The Evil Within has been polarizing due to its unconventional storytelling and gameplay issues. Yet, it stands out as a rich tapestry of horror elements and striking visuals.
With memorable boss encounters and a captivating blend of survival horror mechanics, it’s a game that draws on familiar tropes while remaining distinctly unique. While it may evoke strong opinions, this title has a cult following that appreciates its unconventional approach to the horror genre.
2 Mundaun
Monochrome Monsters Await
The distinctive pencil-drawn monochrome aesthetic of Mundaun sets it apart, culminating in an experience that embraces quirky storytelling through folklore. Though it may not resonate with everyone, those who engage will find a wealth of unique puzzles and slow-burn horror.
The game emphasizes exploration and puzzle-solving, challenging players to navigate its disorienting world while delivering an unsettling atmosphere that rewards those willing to invest time in the narrative.
1 Resident Evil 6
The Ultimate Guilty Pleasure
Controversially, Resident Evil 6 often ranks lowest among franchise entries, yet its charm lies in its embrace of cheesy B-movie tropes and over-the-top action. If players adjust their expectations accordingly, they can find enjoyment in the frantic action and cooperative gameplay.
While the game’s narrative coherence may falter, the joy found in its gameplay and the shared experience with friends transforms it into a fun, if not critically acclaimed, endeavor.
Leave a Reply ▼