YouTube Creators Making Money from ‘Star Wars’ Content Don’t Actually Like the Franchise

The Star Wars fandom, particularly among some male viewers, often exhibits a tendency to criticize new additions to the franchise harshly. This phenomenon has led me to believe that many of these self-proclaimed fans may not truly appreciate the Star Wars universe. Allow me to elaborate.

A recent video by a popular YouTuber, whom I will refer to as the “censorious critic,”inspired this reflection. Titled “Skeleton Crew Died – Star Wars Killed It,” the video begins with a seemingly positive note about the show while quickly devolving into criticism regarding its lack of “wokeness”and its failure to transform the series.

The critic seems conflicted; he acknowledges that Skeleton Crew has merit, yet insists that it should neither qualify as a legitimate franchise entry nor be appreciated fully. His dismissive attitude highlights a disconnect: he struggles to respond to a lighthearted show without lacing his commentary with sarcasm. This brings me to a crucial point: many of these vocal detractors do not genuinely enjoy Star Wars.

Individuals like him, along with those who have recently espoused controversial political views, along with a host of others sharing similar backgrounds, represent what I deem to be “fake fans.”Before anyone asks to see my merchandise collection, let me clarify: fandom isn’t measured by the quantity of memorabilia one owns. If you fundamentally misunderstand the essence of what you’re consuming, then your status as a fan is questionable. Amassing Stormtrooper helmets or crafting numerous lightsabers doesn’t equate to true comprehension of the franchise’s depth.

While the video itself might appear to be innocuous, it underscores a broader issue with those who consistently target and belittle the Star Wars franchise.

Why Skeleton Crew is an Ideal Addition for True Fans

What resonated with me about Skeleton Crew is how it cleverly weaves in 1980s nostalgia through references reminiscent of films like The Goonies, all within the rich tapestry of the Star Wars universe. It felt akin to revisiting childhood days spent playing with beloved action figures. While the show is delightful and fun, its simplicity and lack of drastic lore changes are, in fact, positive attributes.

Many critics seem incapable of acknowledging that a show can be enjoyable without their need to express negativity. They claim newer shows “ruin” the franchise, when, in actuality, they broaden its appeal and celebrate Star Wars in an authentic manner. This suggests to me that these so-called grifters may not genuinely embrace the franchise at all.

It’s one thing to have enjoyed a movie at one point, but it’s another to truly grasp the narrative and world that George Lucas envisaged. It appears these critics feel threatened by the notion that their understanding was flawed, leading them to rail against any new interpretations.

To label Skeleton Crew as merely “cute”while claiming it lacked importance reveals a profound misunderstanding of the show’s purpose. It may be time for some to confront the reality that they might not be fans of this beloved property after all.

Source & Images