‘You Will Never Be Her’: Fans Compare Gal Gadot’s Evil Queen in ‘Snow White’ to Iconic Previous Versions

The Battle of the Evil Queens: Gadot vs. Parrilla

With the release of the trailer for Disney’s live-action adaptation of Snow White, directed by Marc Webb, fans have taken to social media to discuss their thoughts on Rachel Zegler’s portrayal of Snow White and Gal Gadot’s portrayal of the Evil Queen. Initial reviews appear to be mixed, yet a consensus seems to emerge: many believe that a more impactful Evil Queen has graced the screen before.

Gadot’s Interpretation: A Lacking Emotion

One of the primary critiques of Gal Gadot’s performance is her inability to effectively convey emotions. Although her character’s costume closely mirrors that of the animated Evil Queen, the restrictive nature of her makeup—specifically, the tautness beneath the black headpiece—seems to hinder her expressive range. While she comes across as cold and calculating, critics argue that she fails to deliver the captivating menace expected of such an iconic villain.

Watch the trailer here

Comparative Reminiscing: Lana Parrilla’s Regina Mills

This has led fans to draw comparisons with Lana Parrilla’s portrayal of the Evil Queen Regina in ABC’s Once Upon A Time, a character who has become a fan favorite. Parrilla’s rendition brings an unparalleled depth to the role, offering not just an evil demeanor but also a character defined by compelling fashion choices and impressive dialogue.

Evil Queen offers an apple to Snow White — (ABC)

In Once Upon A Time, Parrilla’s Regina showcases an array of elaborate hairstyles and bold looks that are not only visually stunning but contribute significantly to her villainous charm. Through bejeweled corsets, sharp silhouettes, and ageless accessories, she emerges as a fashion icon, expertly weaving her character’s aesthetic into her role.

Emotional Complexity and Charisma

However, it is not just Regina’s looks that resonate with audiences; it’s her dramatic flair and expressive performance that truly set her apart. Parrilla expertly captures the dichotomy of her character, balancing malevolence with a sassy charm. Viewers can enjoy her captivating dialogue even as she utters the darkest of curses, making her one of the most memorable villains in television history.

Check out her iconic moments here

Fan Reactions: A Call for Parrilla’s Return

Social media has exploded with support for Parrilla’s Evil Queen, with numerous fans declaring that nothing will ever surpass her interpretation. Many are echoing sentiments that Disney should have considered bringing her back for the live-action film.

regina mills is the only evil queen i acknowledge https://t.co/pHlkdXgJ7j

— ria ☆ (@riabees) December 5, 2024

We know Gal Gadot is amazing but… there will never be another Evil Queen as badass as Regina Mills, portrait by the greatest Lana Parrilla @LanaParrilla @OnceABC #ReginaMills #EvilQueen https://t.co/ChJ05NV0z8

– ONCERES? (@OncersSpain) December 5, 2024

Reflections on Live-Action Remakes

As Disney continues its trend of remaking classic animated films into live action—often laden with CGI and visual effects—the challenge of casting remains critical. While these retellings may seek to address past shortcomings, the importance of seamless casting cannot be overstated. Fans are left pondering if Gadot’s performance can rival the established reign of Parrilla’s Evil Queen.

Conclusion: The Queen-Off Begins

As the anticipation builds for the film’s release, viewers are left to wonder if Gal Gadot’s portrayal will carve out a place in their hearts, or if Parrilla’s legendary take will forever remain unrivaled. Only time will reveal the outcome of this royal face-off!

Source & Images