X-Men ’97 Showrunner Accuses Marvel Studios of ‘Race-Swapping White Villains’

Overview

Debates surrounding race-swapping in films reflect shifting attitudes on diversity and representation in storytelling.
Beau DeMayo, an ex-showrunner for Marvel, publicly criticized the studio’s decision to recast white villains with black actors.
DeMayo asserts his dismissal from Marvel was linked to his social media post celebrating Pride, not to allegations of misconduct.

The recent discourse around race-swapping in cinematic adaptations has reignited discussions on the balance between diversity and fidelity to source material. This controversial approach, which involves casting actors of different races than those depicted in the original works, is viewed by some as a necessary step towards inclusivity while others argue it detracts from the original narratives.

DeMayo Critiques Marvel’s Race-Swapping Decisions

Beau DeMayo, the former showrunner of X-Men ’97, took to the platform X (previously Twitter) to express his disapproval of Marvel’s choice to cast black actors as traditionally white villains. In a tweet, he urged, “Hey @MarvelStudios, please stop race-swapping white villains to black people. It reads ‘funny,’”listing notable characters like Kang and Norman Osborn.

His remarks have ignited a wide range of reactions online, with supporters of DeMayo’s stance echoing his concerns. Yet, this also prompted critiques from others who pointed out the discrepancies in casting where characters like Sunspot, originally black in the comics, are voiced by a Brazilian actor. DeMayo attributed this decision to “Marvel directive,”highlighting a desire for Latino representation among the team.

Hey @MarvelStudios, please stop race-swapping white villains to black people. It reads “funny.”Kang. High Evolutionary. Norman Osborn. Electro. Mordo. — Beau DeMayo (@BeauDemayo) December 30, 2024

Following his termination in 2024, speculations regarding the reasons behind DeMayo’s firing made headlines. Initially linked to allegations of sexual misconduct, Marvel’s official statement clarified that DeMayo’s termination resulted from the outcomes of an internal investigation, citing “egregious”findings.

Above is #XMen fan-art I posted on Instagram for Gay Pride in June. On June 13, #Marvel sent a letter notifying me they’d stripped my Season 2 credits due to the post. — Beau DeMayo (@BeauDemayo) August 16, 2024

DeMayo has publicly stated that his firing was not connected to any allegations of misconduct, but rather a consequence of sharing a fan art post during Pride Month. He claimed that Marvel informed him they would revoke his credits from X-Men ’97 Season 2 following his Gay Pride celebration post.

The conversation surrounding race-swapping in media continues to evolve, influencing demographics and narratives within the industry. As studios like Marvel navigate these complex waters, the question remains: can they satisfy the call for greater diversity while respecting established character legacies?

X-Men ’97 is currently available for streaming on Disney Plus.

Source: Beau DeMayo/X

Source & Images