X-Men ’97 Creator Criticizes Marvel for Altering Season 1 Episode

Overview

Episode 4 of X-Men ’97 faced criticism for its pacing and overall depth.
Showrunner Beau DeMayo expressed his frustration over Marvel’s interference with creative decisions.
Disputes regarding creative control in X-Men ’97 raise alarms about the series’ trajectory.

X-Men ’97: A Mixed Bag for Fans

X-Men ’97 has made a strong impression on its audience, celebrated for its nostalgic appeal and captivating plots. Despite this success, not all episodes have been received equally well, with one specific installment drawing significant backlash from fans.

Episode 4 Controversy

The latest stir revolves around Episode 4, titled “Motendo / Lifedeath – Part 1,” which many viewers found to be a disjointed entry in an otherwise well-received series. This episode’s challenges have been amplified by comments from former showrunner Beau DeMayo, who took to social media to express his disappointment regarding the episode’s final cut.

Behind the Scenes: Creative Struggles

Beau DeMayo, the creative mind behind the ambitious revival, articulated his concerns on X (formerly Twitter). He stated that the episode felt “off”due to drastic changes implemented by the show’s co-executive producer, who opposed the original narrative direction. DeMayo had aimed to explore the intricate dynamics of Storm and Forge’s relationship; however, the producer’s modifications diluted this storyline, resulting in a less cohesive narrative.

It’s time to talk about why #xmen97 episode 4 is the way that it is https://t.co/iHRDRpMVQ0 — Beau DeMayo (@BeauDemayo) January 18, 2025

Unraveling Poor Execution

DeMayo revealed that key elements of the episode were pruned, leaving notable plot points, such as the iconic initial scene featuring Forge supporting a vulnerable Storm, tragically omitted. This cut significantly altered the intended buildup toward Storm’s encounter with the formidable Adversary. Fans noted that the episode devolved into a hastily constructed story, with the focus shifting to a standalone adventure for Jubilee that seemed out of place. As a result, the romantic tension between Storm and Forge came across as forced, lacking the necessary context to resonate with the audience.

Production Challenges and Casting Choices

In addition to narrative troubles, DeMayo disclosed obstacles during the casting process. He initially approached well-known actor Gil Birmingham for the role of Forge, but Birmingham had reservations due to previous experiences with Marvel Studios. A past experience—where his character was unceremoniously cut from a Marvel film—left him reluctant to return. Nevertheless, DeMayo managed to persuade Birmingham to sign on by promising a well-developed character arc spanning multiple seasons, effectively restoring the actor’s faith in the project.

The Future of X-Men ’97

Despite the initial success of X-Men ’97, confusion around character arcs and plot lines persists, especially following cuts made during editing. Following allegations of misconduct that led to his termination in March 2024, including accusations of sexual harassment—claims DeMayo has publicly denied—the future of the series remains uncertain. Questions linger about whether Forge and Storm will receive the nuanced storytelling they deserve in upcoming seasons.

X-Men ’97 is currently streaming on Disney+.

Source: Beau DeMayo/ X

Source & Images