Why X-23 Is Not the Right Choice to Succeed Hugh Jackman’s Wolverine

Overview

Fans express concerns that X-23’s inclusion signals a potential replacement for Wolverine amidst her limited role in the recent Deadpool & Wolverine.
There are discussions about a possible recasting of Wolverine as Marvel gears up for a new X-Men reboot post-Avengers: Secret Wars.
Recasting Wolverine presents Marvel with an opportunity to rejuvenate the X-Men franchise with fresh talent and innovative storytelling.

As questions loom over Hugh Jackman’s future portrayal of Wolverine in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), fans are left speculating about the character’s next chapter. Although Jackman made his MCU debut in Deadpool & Wolverine, uncertainty remains regarding his continued involvement and whether Marvel might opt for a new face to carry on the legacy of this iconic character.

One popular contender among fans is Laura, better known as X-23, introduced in the critically acclaimed film Logan. As a clone and daughter of Wolverine, X-23 shares his remarkable powers, making her an appealing choice for a potential successor. However, many believe her to be a less-than-ideal fit for this vital role, particularly given her limited screen time.

Why Does X-23 Interest Fans as Wolverine?

Dafne Keen’s portrayal of X-23 in Logan garnered widespread acclaim, showcasing her talent as a young actress. She not only impressed audiences with her performance but also provided a nuanced layer to Jackman’s Wolverine. Keen’s ability to portray anger and vulnerability made many fans believe she could take on the mantle of Wolverine going forward. The familial relationship between Laura and Logan could have been explored further, presenting compelling storytelling opportunities for Marvel. Nevertheless, she is not the only candidate under consideration for the Wolverine role should Jackman bow out.

Her Appearance in Deadpool & Wolverine: Impacts on Future Opportunities

X-23 made a return in Deadpool & Wolverine, which included several well-received cameos. While fans were thrilled to see her introduced into the MCU with a multiverse twist, this moment also complicated her chance to assume Wolverine’s role. Positioned alongside iconic characters, X-23 seemed relegated to a supporting status, which potentially diminishes her stature in the eyes of new audiences. Instead of being framed as an essential character, her portrayal was overshadowed, making it difficult for her to be perceived as a viable replacement for Jackman in the franchise.

For those unfamiliar with Logan, this cameo may have led to misconceptions about X-23’s significance. Focus was diverted towards established characters like Gambit and Blade, inadvertently downplaying X-23’s potential. Although her appearance delighted fans of the previous film, it failed to establish her as a central figure capable of stepping into Wolverine’s shoes. Future MCU narratives featuring her might lead viewers to believe she would occupy a more minor role.

The Case for Recasting Wolverine Completely

Given Wolverine’s vibrant legacy within the Marvel franchise, the desire to maintain this character is undeniable. Nonetheless, the prospect of replacing Hugh Jackman poses a challenge, as his portrayal has become synonymous with the role and beloved by fans globally. Discussions of Jackman continuing in this role persist, yet indications suggest that Marvel is approaching a pivotal moment for recasting.

With the arrival of X-Men in the MCU on the horizon, particularly following Avengers: Secret Wars, a deliberate and fresh approach is anticipated. This pivotal reboot presents an ideal opportunity to transition to a new Wolverine, thereby fostering a novel narrative direction that differs from the former Fox adaptations. The introduction of an entirely new actor could better align with the revamped perspectives of the other X-Men characters.

Marvel is likely to seek younger actors for iconic X-Men roles, enhancing continuity across the franchise. Having Jackman return alongside younger talent might inadvertently create a disparity that draws negative attention. While X-23 could offer a youthful energy, her ties to Wolverine may cause lingering expectations for Jackman’s return, complicating narrative arcs. Therefore, it is crucial that Marvel embraces this chance for a clean break, allowing the MCU to evolve seamlessly, especially with the impending shifts expected as the multiverse saga draws to a close.

Source & Images