Why Tracker’s Records Show Season 2’s Paranormal Case Falls Short

Attention: This article includes SPOILERS for seasons 1 and 2 of Tracker.

Exploring the Disappointment of Tracker Season 2’s “Preternatural”

The second season of Tracker ventures into an unusual paranormal storyline, particularly in episode 5 titled “Preternatural.”In this episode, protagonist Colter Shaw, portrayed by Justin Hartley, embarks on a quest to assist Jasper (Connor Price) in locating his missing sister, Emmaline (guest star Alison Thorton).However, this journey takes a fantastical twist when it is revealed that a local family has kidnapped Emmaline, believing she possesses supernatural healing abilities. The episode largely reinforces the notion that she is viewed as a witch, leaving much to be desired in terms of narrative execution.

This episode is part of a broader storytelling pattern in the current season. The return of Jensen Ackles as Rusell Shaw highlights a complex family dynamic as the brothers become embroiled in a classified Department of Defense mystery. Even as they explore the idea of alien encounters at a secretive site, the narrative consistently juxtaposes skepticism, particularly through Colter’s refusal to engage with the extraterrestrial hypothesis. Such elements contribute to the letdown felt by viewers regarding the episode’s treatment of supernatural themes.

Tracker Season 1, Episode 9: A Paranormal Premise with a Grounded Resolution

“Aurora” Hints at the Harkwood Witch

Father reunites with daughter in Tracker episode 'Aurora'

In contrast, season 1, episode 9, titled “Aurora, ”presents a storyline that retains its grounding despite supernatural hints. In this episode, Colter investigates the disappearance of teenage friends Lana Russo (Paolina van Kleef) and Jamie, who vanish under mysterious circumstances while exploring the legend of the Harkwood Witch. While the narrative suggests elements of witchcraft, the resolution is firmly rooted in realism as Colter uncovers a disturbing truth involving a serial killer’s sister, Maeve Price (Bronwen Smith).

The episode maintains the allure of the paranormal while providing reasonable explanations for the events that unfold. This deliberate approach reinforces the series’ ability to entertain the supernatural without losing its foundational realism. Colter’s methods are grounded in logic, emphasizing that even the seemingly inexplicable can often be understood through rational investigation.

Tracker Season 2: Leaving Witchcraft Mysteries Unresolved

Colter Teases a Bewitching Conclusion

Watch on YouTube

In a notable departure, season 2 seems to validate Emmaline’s status as a witch, as the conclusion remains ambiguous. While the storyline continues to follow a teenage girl with supposed supernatural ties, the trajectory diverges from the show’s traditional premises. Colter leaves the audience pondering whether Emmaline’s abilities are genuine or speculative. Unlike the definite conclusions offered in “Aurora, ” this ambiguity risks alienating fans who appreciate the series for its grounded approach.

Despite the differences in tone, Emmaline’s character as an intuitive healer further complicates the narrative. Her ability to perform miraculous medical feats, such as reversing cancer, adds layers to her portrayal, though it strays from the realism that defines Tracker. This evolving narrative begs the question of whether the show can maintain its essence amidst increasingly supernatural themes.

Maintaining Realism in Tracker’s Storylines

Tracker Is Most Engaging When Rooted in Reality

Colter Shaw Searching For Emmaline In Tracker Season 2, Episode 5

Tracker thrives when it stays firmly anchored in reality. Colter Shaw’s character is defined by his analytical approach to problem-solving, making him relatable and grounded among the often bizarre scenarios he encounters. His knack for logical reasoning has been the show’s strength, paving the way for straightforward conclusions in an otherwise chaotic world. By straying from this proven formula in “Preternatural, ”the show risks losing touch with its core audience.

As season 2 progresses, it remains to be seen whether Tracker will revert to its grounded storytelling model or continue to drift into speculative territory. The series must reconcile its supernatural elements with its established identity to satisfy its dedicated fan base.

For the latest in entertainment news and updates, consider subscribing to ScreenRant’s Network TV newsletter. Stay informed with insights from your favorite series, delivered directly to your inbox.

Source & Images