Why This David Tennant Doctor Who Episode Had Classic Potential But Was Let Down By The Villain

David Tennant’s portrayal of the Tenth Doctor stands as a defining period in the history of Doctor Who. His interpretation resonates with fans, yet not every episode from this era hit the mark. Many of Tennant’s standout performances come from episodes that, while not particularly well-executed, showcase his ability to elevate the material and captivate audiences. Despite some lackluster offerings, Tennant’s time as the Doctor is memorable and beloved.

Uniquely, Tennant is the only actor to reprise the role of the Doctor twice during the modern era. His return for the show’s 50th-anniversary special under Steven Moffat and later for the 60th-anniversary celebrations with Russell T Davies highlights his critical acclaim and enduring popularity. Although these brief returns reignited the magic of his original portrayal, they also served to overshadow some of the less successful moments in his initial run. While Tennant certainly delivered exceptional episodes, he also faced challenges with scripts that stretched to meet expectations.

An Examination of “The Unicorn & The Wasp”

The Difficulty of Mixing Tropes Effectively

Another image from The Unicorn & The Wasp

During its fourth season, Doctor Who introduced yet another historical figure into the timeline with the character of Agatha Christie, portrayed by Fenella Woolgar in the episode “The Unicorn & The Wasp.”Writer Gareth Roberts sought to weave a narrative that aligned with Christie’s iconic detective genre, resulting in a Poirot-style drama. However, the endeavor to layer in various Doctor Who tropes may have been overly ambitious.

The episode attempted to inject meta-commentary about Christie’s tales, but the added narrative of her enigmatic disappearance felt unnecessary and convoluted.

Unrealized Potential of “The Unicorn & The Wasp”

Ambition That Ultimately Hindered the Narrative

David Tennant as the Tenth Doctor looking conflicted

Combining elements of a detective narrative with historical fiction, “The Unicorn & The Wasp”introduces a unique antagonist: a human/Vespiform hybrid portrayed by Tom Goodman-Hill. On paper, this twist seems intriguing; however, the execution falters as the villain’s portrayal devolves into the realm of the absurd with the CGI wasp element. An alternative approach could have depicted Goodman-Hill’s character as merely a humanoid alien, with “The Wasp” serving as his alias—paralleling the episode’s human antagonist, the Unicorn.

Envisioning an episode where the Doctor collaborates with Agatha Christie to apprehend an alien killer provides an exciting narrative framework. Moreover, constructing a plot solely focused on a science-fiction rationale for Christie’s famous disappearance could enhance viewer engagement. Regrettably, the episode’s overreaching ambition detracted from its overall coherence, leaving it unable to fulfill the promise of either genre amidst a confusing blend of styles.

Source & Images