Why The Boys Season 5 Should Avoid the Comics’ Shocking Ending

The upcoming season 5 of The Boys promises to be a poignant conclusion to one of Prime Video’s most acclaimed series, with strong indications that it will adhere closely to the comic’s ending. Since its debut in 2019, this gritty take on superheroes has captivated audiences worldwide, presenting an alternative reality where super-powered individuals exist alongside ordinary humanity. Unlike traditional superhero narratives, where some lead the charge in heroism, many characters in this series exhibit morally ambiguous and often heinous behaviors.

Over the course of its four seasons, Billy Butcher and his team have engaged in an intense campaign against “supes,”holding them accountable for their reckless actions while simultaneously contending with a society that idolizes them—most notably, the infamous Homelander. As the stage is set for the final season, viewers anticipate a compelling adaptation of the original comic storyline crafted by Garth Ennis.

The Boys Season 5 Is Poised to Reimagine the Comic’s Conclusion

The Series Sets the Scene for a Faithful Comic Interpretation

In the comics, Butcher’s animosity towards supes culminates in his belief that the only resolution is their total annihilation, implicating even his own team in a murderous rampage—a consequence of their own use of Compound V. However, in a dramatic twist, it’s Hughie who ultimately takes Butcher’s life, driven by a desire to protect the remaining supes after they’ve dismantled the superhero teams.

The adaptation has made notable changes; for instance, several characters have avoided exposure to Compound V, contrasting with Butcher, who now uses it as a means to combat Homelander. Furthermore, a looming disease capable of eradicating all supes has been introduced, suggesting a pivotal role in the concluding season’s narrative. Given Hughie’s more nuanced relationship with Annie and his tempered hatred toward supes, it appears he may need to intervene against Butcher, potentially leading to an ending reminiscent of the comics.

The Comic’s Conclusion Could Align Well with the Series’ Tone

A History of Dark and Gritty Conclusions

The show mirrors the comic’s tone with its heavy reliance on dark humor, a cynical view of flawed heroes, and graphic violence. However, while the series seems set to echo the comic’s path, it avoids being a direct replication. Various elements of character relationships and plot developments have diverged significantly from the source material. For instance, Homelander’s notoriety has surged, even after his brutality has been laid bare, making a direct adaptation of the comic’s conclusion problematic.

The original comics culminate in Butcher’s death and the decommissioning of the supes. However, the subsequent narrative in “Dear Becky”expands on the world following these events, posing a more challenging narrative development. This exploration showcases society’s rejection of supes, reinstating faith in humanity rather than a continuation of unchecked super-powered rule.

Rethinking The Boys Season 5’s Ending: A Distinctive Approach

Charting a Unique Course Beyond the Original Comics

The television adaptation has undoubtedly forged its own identity, transforming the narrative beyond what the comics initially offered. While both versions depict Homelander’s malevolence, the series amplifies his capacity for evil in plain sight. The team’s engagement with Compound V has shifted as well, and the plot reflects a more complex societal divide regarding Homelander’s reign, showcasing fervent supporters juxtaposed with hopeful idealists like Starlight.

Given the vibrant world created over the past four seasons, merely replicating the comic’s ending would not resonate well with viewers. Such an approach risks appearing unoriginal and failing to align with the development of future spin-offs that will explore the continuing journey of both supes and humans.

Retaining Core Elements from the Comic’s Conclusion

Drawing Inspiration Without Mimicking

As Billy navigates his self-destructive path, significant fallout is inevitable. However, the show can incorporate elements from the comic’s ending while crafting a unique resolution. Themes such as the misuse of power and the inevitable corruption of supers remain relevant—central to understanding the characters’ journeys. Ultimately, it is plausible that Hughie, despite his complicated relationship with Butcher, might be tasked with ending Butcher’s exploits for the greater good in the final confrontation.

Source & Images