Why The Bear’s Major Criticism Is Misguided: This Episode Demonstrates the Truth

Each awards season reignites the discussion regarding the genre classification of The Bear, but a standout episode from its first season offers compelling evidence that it’s primarily a comedy. Recognized by the Emmys and Golden Globes as a comedy, the series aligns with traditional network classifications, which previously divided content into lighthearted sitcoms and deeper dramas. However, in today’s streaming landscape, where episode lengths can vary significantly, this binary approach appears outdated.

As television has matured, the distinctions between drama and comedy have become increasingly ambiguous. Take Succession, for example: although it’s categorized as a drama, it seamlessly integrates sharp satire that critiques wealthy elites, highlighting the absurdities of their lives. Conversely, while The Bear is classified as a comedy, it examines intense themes surrounding a toxic work environment, featuring anxiety and generational trauma. The ongoing debates during awards season—fueled by assertions that The Bear is engaged in “category fraud”—underscore a pivotal question: can a show truly be both a comedy and a drama?

“Dogs”– A Hilarious Highlight of The Bear

Carmy & Richie’s Misadventures at a Birthday Party

Richie standing in front of an inflatable hot dog

Season 1, Episode 4, titled “Dogs,” is not only a comedic high point for The Bear, but it also ranks among the most entertaining episodes across television history. The episode sets off with a brilliantly comedic premise: the dynamic duo of Carmy and Richie is tasked with catering a children’s birthday party. The inherent comedic potential of placing these two abrasive characters in a setting filled with children generates a wealth of situational humor from the beginning.

One particularly memorable scene involves a spirited argument over whether ketchup belongs on hot dogs, escalating into a full-fledged shouting match. The episode reaches its humorous peak when Richie’s homemade Ecto cooler is inadvertently spiked with Xanax, causing all the party attendees—the kids—to pass out, leaving Cicero relieved to finally enjoy peace and quiet. This dark humor not only entertains but also showcases the episode’s brilliance, competing with classic sitcom moments from shows like Seinfeld and The I.T. Crowd.

Humor in High-Stress Situations

Even “Fishes”Showcases Comedy Amid High Stakes

Jamie Lee Curtis as Donna looking distressed in The Bear season 2 episode fishes

Despite criticisms that The Bear leans heavily into deeply stressful themes, even the show’s most intense episodes have incorporated humor effectively. The episode “Dogs,” though melancholic at its core, exemplifies this blend. It mirrors a toxic dynamic while remaining thoroughly relatable to anyone who grew up in a loud, tension-filled household.

Looking ahead, Season 4 is slated to premiere in June 2025. Meanwhile, Season 2, Episode 6, entitled “Fishes,” is notorious for heightening stress levels dramatically. Yet, even during this episode—typically a joyful setting in other shows—hilarious moments emerge from tense family interactions, offering a uniquely comedic take on what could easily devolve into despair.

The Dual Nature of The Bear

The Blend of Drama and Comedy in The Bear

Richie covered in mold and dust in The Bear

While The Bear encompasses strong dramatic threads similar to shows like Abbott Elementary or It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia, its structure delves far deeper into character development, effectively intertwining heartfelt struggles with humor. It navigates heavy themes—addressing Mikey’s tragic death, chronic family dysfunction, and workplace pressures—all while managing to elicit laughter.

Whether it’s the antics of characters locked in a fridge or the absurdity of cosplay enthusiasts being held at gunpoint, it’s clear that the show cannot simply be labelled as a drama. While its narrative depth is undeniable, the awards voters are justified in acknowledging its comedic elements, reinforcing the notion that The Bear is both a drama and a comedy.

Source & Images