Overview
- Poor writing, unimpressive visuals, and the absence of Spider-Man contributed to the downfall of Sony’s Spider-Man Universe.
- The Penguin successfully leveraged its lack of a central superhero to tell compelling stories.
- Sony should take inspiration from The Penguin’s approach for future Spider-Man spin-off projects.
The recent release of Kraven the Hunter has marked a dismal beginning at the box office for Sony’s Marvel films, raising concerns about the viability of the Spider-Man Universe (SSU). In contrast, Matt Reeves’ The Batman Universe is thriving in pop culture, prompting speculation on whether Sony should have adopted a similar framework.
Sony has held the rights to the Spider-Man character for many years, leading to a significant partnership with Marvel Studios that allowed Spider-Man to be part of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) portrayed by Tom Holland. However, while Spider-Man was featured in the MCU, Sony sought to develop a Spider-Man-adjacent universe, creating films based on the villainous characters from Spider-Man’s comic history. This venture commenced in 2018 with Venom, followed by Venom: Let There Be Carnage (2021) and the upcoming Venom: The Last Dance (2024), as well as origin stories for other villains like Morbius (2023) and Madame Web (2024).
Analyzing the Failure of Sony’s Spider-Man Universe
Despite enlisting high-profile actors and popular characters, Sony’s Spider-Man Universe has struggled to match the success of the MCU or DC Universe. Although the Venom films showed some financial success, they could not achieve the critical acclaim that accompanied the Spider-Man films. The SSU has been criticized for subpar writing, clunky dialogue, and inadequate special effects, all while operating with production budgets exceeding $75 million.
The effort to mimic the superhero cinematic universe by portraying comic book villains as protagonists fell flat without Spider-Man as a unifying figure.
Audiences have played a crucial role in the decline of the SSU, compounded by inherent challenges from the outset. Each lead character in the SSU is rooted in their antagonism towards Spider-Man, with their narratives intertwined with the webslinger. The absence of Spider-Man rendered it difficult for viewers to connect with these characters. Sony’s attempt to recast well-known villains as heroes proved ineffective in establishing audience empathy.
What The Penguin Did Right
In contrast to the troubles faced by the SSU, DC’s The Penguin series successfully crafted an engaging narrative despite the absence of a central superhero. This HBO series, spun off from Matt Reeves’ The Batman (2022), explores Colin Farrell’s Penguin’s ascent to power without including Robert Pattinson’s Batman character. This approach has created a rich narrative for Oswald Cobb that positions him as a formidable character for future installments.
Embracing Villainy in The Penguin
The Penguin does not shy away from the darker aspects of its lead character. Oz is portrayed as selfish and manipulative while maintaining a plausible backstory. In stark contrast, the SSU’s villains often lack depth, failing to resonate with audiences as relatable figures. By tapping into the complexities of villainy, The Penguin has showcased how well-explored characters can captivate audiences. Additionally, the series maintained a distinct style and tone, feeling like a natural extension of Reeves’ vision from The Batman.
Lessons for Sony’s Spider-Man Universe
In retrospect, it is evident that Sony could have approached its Spider-Man Universe differently. A primary issue was the lack of a unified vision. Efforts to assemble a Sinister Six-type group felt disjointed due to insufficient links between films. In contrast, Matt Reeves has provided a cohesive framework that guides the projects within The Batman universe.
Moreover, Sony could have benefited from developing solo films for characters that were established in earlier releases. The Penguin demonstrates that audience familiarity, as seen with Oswald’s character in The Batman, translates to greater investment in follow-up narratives. If characters like Kraven or Morbius had been introduced in previous films, their solo stories might have garnered more viewer interest.
While Kraven the Hunter appears to signal a downturn for Sony’s Spider-Man ventures, the studio remains committed to exploring further adaptations, including the upcoming Spider-Noir TV series. Shifting focus towards television may provide Sony with new strategies for harnessing the Spider-Man franchise’s potential. Learning from The Penguin’s success could significantly benefit any future projects based on Spider-Man.
Leave a Reply