Why Jelly Roll Was Not the Best Choice as Artist in Residence for American Idol Season 23

American Idol is set to return for its 23rd season, and fans can look forward to some notable changes. Country music sensation Jelly Roll has been appointed as the new artist in residence. However, this decision may not resonate well with all viewers for a significant reason. Alongside Jelly Roll’s involvement, the season will also witness a significant shake-up in the judging panel.Country icon and season 4 winner Carrie Underwood will take over Katy Perry’s spot, joining forces with judges Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan.

In his role as artist in residence, Jelly Roll will provide guidance and mentorship to contestants, starting from Hollywood Week and continuing throughout the season. His prior experience as a mentor during Hawaii Week in season 22 impressed many, leading to speculation that he would be a suitable candidate for a judging role. Despite his credentials, the choice of Jelly Roll raises concerns for one primary reason.

Why American Idol Season 23 Features an Overrepresentation of Country Stars

Lionel Richie Stands Alone as the Sole Representative of Non-Country Music

This season, American Idol features two judges from the country music scene—Luke Bryan and Carrie Underwood—while Lionel Richie remains the only judge representing genres outside this sphere, namely R&B and soul. Katy Perry, a leading figure in the pop genre, has left a notable gap in the judging panel, previously ensuring a diverse musical landscape among the judges and providing a wider range of feedback for contestants.Consequently, with two-thirds of the panel now comprised of country music artists, the show risks narrowing its musical diversity.

Though Jelly Roll served admirably as a mentor in season 22, he continues the trend of focusing primarily on country music. Historically, American Idol has faced criticism for its apparent favoritism towards country contestants. Numerous past winners and finalists, including the likes of Carrie Underwood, Scotty McCreery, Laine Hardy, and Noah Thompson, have predominantly represented this genre. Some viewers have jokingly suggested that the show’s name be altered to “Country Idol, ”expressing frustration that country artists often dominate voting and progress to the Top 10, overshadowing contestants from diverse musical backgrounds.

The Case for Choosing an Artist from a Different Genre

Numerous Alternative Candidates Were Available for the Role

With Jelly Roll’s appointment, the American Idol season 23 cast emphasizes an already prevalent country music presence. The producers could have considered a wider array of artists for this role to enrich the show’s musical diversity. Artists such as Tori Kelly, Meghan Trainor, and rock legend Jon Bon Jovi, who served as mentors in the past, would have brought distinct perspectives that could greatly benefit the contestants this season.

Especially since Meghan Trainor has openly expressed interest in a judging position after campaigning to replace Katy Perry, she would have made an excellent choice as artist in residence. Her involvement could effectively introduce a pop viewpoint, aligning with the original vision of the show, which is to discover a “pop idol”across various genres.

American Idol, which was inspired by the original UK series known as Pop Idol, has always aimed at identifying talent regardless of genre. While Jelly Roll’s charisma and experience as a mentor are undeniable, the show would benefit more from a non-country artist in this pivotal role.

Don’t forget, the premiere of American Idol season 23 is scheduled for Sunday, March 9, at 8 p.m. EST on ABC.

Source & Images