Why I Initially Disliked This Battlestar Galactica Character, But They Became One of the Show’s Greatest Creations

This article delves into the complex character of Saul Tigh from Battlestar Galactica, exploring themes of addiction, morality, and transformation.

Saul Tigh, depicted by the talented Michael Hogan, is initially presented as one of the more antagonistic figures in the series. His character arc is fascinating—what might seem like a straightforward depiction of a flawed man soon reveals deeper layers. While Tigh often makes poor choices, such as enforcing martial law, he eventually becomes one of the series’ most engaging and tragic characters.

Setting the Stage for Dislike

His Early Unpopularity

From the outset in the Battlestar Galactica miniseries, Saul Tigh is portrayed as a deeply flawed individual. His alcohol dependency is apparent and seemingly normalized, compounded by a fiery temper that culminates in confrontation, notably when he physically lashes out at Starbuck (Katee Sackhoff).

Throughout the pilot episode, Tigh assumes the role of the harsh enforcer, contrasting sharply with Adama’s (Edward James Olmos) more diplomatic approach. His responses, particularly towards Dee’s (Kandyse McClure) mistakes, reveal a lack of empathy that underscores his earlier characterization. Compounding his flaws, Tigh succumbs to the manipulations of his wife, Ellen (Kate Vernon), leading him to further questionable actions, such as undermining President Roslin’s (Mary McDonnell) authority by exploiting her health issues.

It is evident that, while Tigh is effective as a senior officer, he is not particularly endearing. As he candidly expresses: “If everyone is friends with the XO, he’s not doing his frakkin’ job.”This quote encapsulates his internal conflict and foreshadows the deeper struggles he will face throughout the series.

The Transformation of Saul Tigh

Defining Characteristics in Adversity

As the narrative unfolds, Saul Tigh’s layered personality reveals itself. Much like Starbuck, Tigh thrives under pressure, utilizing his tactical acumen despite lacking diplomatic finesse. His fierce loyalty to Battlestar Galactica and his enduring friendship with Adama shine through his anger and flaws.

Unlike Felix Gaeta, who succumbs to disillusionment amid their shared trials, Tigh demonstrates remarkable resilience. His journey is marked by trauma—most notably when he is forced to poison Ellen to safeguard the fleet or endure months of torture on New Caprica, ultimately resulting in the loss of his eye. These horrors only serve to deepen the viewer’s empathy for him as he grapples with grief and addiction following Ellen’s death while striving to mend his relationship with Bill Adama.

The Culmination of Tigh’s Journey

Redemption Through Identity

In season four, Tigh’s journey reaches a pivotal moment as he confronts his Cylon heritage. This challenge forces him to embrace his humanity and redefine his identity. A particularly poignant moment occurs when Tigh, battling inner turmoil, declares his commitment to his values:

“My name is Saul Tigh. I’m an officer in the Colonial Fleet. Whatever else I am, whatever else it means, that’s the man I want to be. And if I die today, that’s the man I’ll be.”

This declaration not only crystallizes his resilience but also highlights his unwavering loyalty to the fleet amidst the chaos surrounding him. Tigh’s ultimate sacrifice encapsulates his character’s evolution, showcasing him as a symbol of order and camaraderie, defying the series’ more somber themes. His conclusion on Earth, beginning anew with Ellen, is an affirmation of hope and redemption—a fitting resolution for one of the most complex characters in Battlestar Galactica.

Source & Images