Why I Believe the Fourth Wing Theory on Venin Sage is Intriguing, Yet I Hope Onyx Storm Surprises Us

One particularly compelling theory surrounding the venin Sage from the Fourth Wing series has captured the imagination of fans, yet I remain hopeful that Onyx Storm refutes it, proving me wrong. As we approach the release of Onyx Storm, the stakes in The Empyrean Series have escalated, promising critical revelations about the venin and their true intentions. The interest shown by the venin Sage in Violet hints at a deeper narrative to explore, along with speculation regarding the potential identity of the villain. With Xaden and Jack now transformed into venin, one can only ponder what surprising conclusions lie ahead regarding the Sage’s identity.

The first glimpse of the venin Sage occurs at the end of Fourth Wing, with increased focus on the character in Iron Flame. However, his identity and motives towards Violet, along with his overarching role in The Empyrean Series, remain enigmatic as we await Onyx Storm. There’s a particularly intriguing theory that could align with the provided clues, but I have reservations about its implications.

Insights on the Venin Sage: What We Know So Far

A Powerful Interest in Violet’s Abilities

Fourth Wing and Iron Flame hardcovers surrounded by flames — Image by Milica Djordjevic

The texts of Fourth Wing and Iron Flame maintain an aura of mystery around the venin Sage while hinting at profound insights into his character that may become pivotal later in the series. Notably, his introduction is marked by his commanding presence on the battlefield, equipped with a towering staff and showcasing formidable strength. He evades assaults from both Sgaeyl and Garrick, emerging from a fierce encounter at Resson unscathed. Interestingly, the female venin that clashes with Violet implies that the Sage is drawn to her lightning-wielding abilities, a notion further validated by events in Iron Flame.

Violet’s confrontation with the female wielder suggests that the Sage takes on a mentor-like role, which is daunting given his formidable powers. While other venin appear less powerful, their drive to learn under his guidance is apparent. Violet’s encounters suggest that the venin Sage isn’t alone in his quest for her powers, as another dark wielder seemingly responds to her inquiry about him by inquiring, “Which Sage?”

Moreover, the Sage begins appearing to Violet in her dreams in the second book, paralleling his interactions with Xaden as revealed toward the conclusion of Iron Flame. His interest appears to extend beyond mere mentorship; during their nightmarish dialogues, he expresses a desire for her to join him in becoming venin and even commands his followers to spare her life. Notably, Violet perceives his disappointment during her refusals, indicating he harbors significant expectations for her alliance. This evolving connection suggests a deeper narrative thread between them.

The Sage makes a captivating revelation, stating he has been waiting “centuries” for someone with Violet’s capabilities, further implying his ancient origin. This reference could illuminate his immense strength, as demonstrated during Iron Flame’s final battle, where he overcomes Xaden and influences him to embrace his venin transformation. His declaration to Xaden, that he identifies himself as a general and not merely a Sage, raises pivotal questions about his position within the venin hierarchy. Unraveling his true identity becomes critical, with a captivating theory emerging suggesting his ties to a known character.

Could Naolin, Tairn’s Former Rider, Be the Venin Sage? A Theory Explored

Could Saving Brennan Transform Naolin?

Fan art of Violet saving Andarna and being protected by Tairn during the Threshing in Fourth Wing — Art by Rosiethorns88

The potential identities of the venin Sage are numerous, ranging from Violet’s father to General Daramor. Among them, however, a particularly intriguing theory posits that the Sage could actually be Naolin, Tairn’s previous rider. While Naolin’s connection to the Sage may not fully align with his “centuries”claim, it offers compelling narrative possibilities. Notably, it remains unexplained how the venin Sage can intrude into both Violet’s and Xaden’s minds throughout Iron Flame. It might be plausible that a connection to Tairn enables him to access the mental bond shared by Violet and Xaden.

Naolin is thought to have perished while attempting to save Brennan Sorrengail during the Tyrrish Rebellion. Maintaining Brennan’s survival may have demanded extraordinary power from Naolin, and since Brennan is presumed dead throughout Fourth Wing, coupled with a mysterious rune on his hand, this suggests the possibility that Naolin may have even resurrected him. Their bond is also believed to be profound, leading some readers to hypothesize a romantic connection. The implications of this bond raise dramatic questions about self-sacrifice; Brennan notably mentions that it “cost him everything,” yet never explicitly states it led to Naolin’s death.

This narrative thread becomes all the more fascinating considering the Sage’s interest in Xaden’s transformation for love during Iron Flame. Such a tale suggests Naolin might bear a similar history. Notably, in his interactions, he states, “It hurts, doesn’t it? Nearing burnout?” indicating he shares similar experiences. Moreover, this transition would deepen the narrative around Tairn’s concerns regarding Violet’s power, providing rationale for his reluctance to discuss his past rider. The implications of how becoming a venin affects the dragon-rider bond remain unclear, yet Sgaeyl’s responses regarding Xaden and Jack’s comments indicate significant changes could occur in such dynamics.

Implications of Naolin as the Venin Sage

Significant Consequences for Onyx Storm

The covers of Fourth Wing, Onyx Storm, Iron Flame by Rebecca Yarros against a vivid background

While the theory of Naolin as the venin Sage is persuasive, it raises serious implications for Onyx Storm and Brennan’s character journey. Should this theory hold true, it could reveal a shocking traitor narrative surrounding Brennan Sorrengail, heightening the tension within the series. Moreover, the revelation would undoubtedly influence Brennan’s character development. Defeating the Sage may result in severing his connection to the realm of the living, altering the trajectory for all involved.

Furthermore, should Naolin indeed be the venin Sage, the bond between Xaden and Sgaeyl risks becoming irreparably strained as the story unfolds in Onyx Storm and subsequent sequels. Naolin’s ultimate fate could foreshadow the potential losses faced by characters like Jack Barlowe and Xaden should they succumb to darkness. Given Tairn’s ability to bond with Violet, it would imply a permanent disconnect from Naolin. Such a fate for Xaden and Sgaeyl seems inconceivable, but based on Rebecca Yarros’ history of tragic narrative twists, it remains a possibility. As one Reddit user astutely notes, this could pave the way for significant losses, including a potential demise for Xaden’s dragon, even if he himself survives.

Concerns Regarding Naolin as the Venin Sage in Onyx Storm

The Empyrean Series Deserves to Move Beyond Death Fakeouts

Although the prospect of Naolin being the venin Sage offers an interesting narrative vein, I genuinely hope Onyx Storm refrains from affirming this theory, primarily due to the heavy implications it carries. Confessing Naolin’s identity as the Sage would essentially repeat a twist already utilized in The Empyrean Series: the death fakeout. Brennan’s supposed death is a significant plot point in Fourth Wing, later reversed in a dramatic finale that shocked readers.

Given that Onyx Storm is set to debut on January 21, 2025, it’s crucial to consider that repeating a major death fakeout would feel rather tedious. Even if Naolin’s demise is rendered ambiguous, such a plot development could dilute the series’ previous portrayals of loss amidst the brutal consequences of war. Ultimately, this could culminate in rendering Onyx Storm an even darker chapter within The Empyrean Series.

Source: Reddit

Source & Images