Why I Adore Tombstone, Yet One Aspect of the Film’s Conclusion Disturbs Me After 32 Years

Among Western films, few have left a lasting impression like Tombstone. This cinematic gem encapsulates the essence of the genre with its thrilling narrative of lawmen battling outlaws, electrifying gunfights, and the age-old quest for justice. The film’s charismatic leads, Kurt Russell as Wyatt Earp and Val Kilmer as Doc Holliday, form one of the most iconic and quotable partnerships in cinema history. Even after decades, Tombstone continues to be recognized as a quintessential Western classic.

However, despite my admiration for Tombstone, one aspect has consistently bothered me: its ending. After immersing the audience in a tale filled with treachery, despair, and bloodshed during Wyatt’s vengeance, the film concludes with a surprisingly light-hearted moment of Wyatt and Josephine dancing in the snow. While it’s heartwarming to see Wyatt find a moment of joy, the shift to such an upbeat tone feels incongruous given the dark events that preceded it. This moment strikes me as oddly out of sync with the otherwise intense narrative.

Scrutinizing Tombstone’s Ending: A Clash of Tones

The Gritty Journey and the Climax That Conflicts

Wyatt Earp undergoes a dramatic transformation from a hesitant lawman to an unstoppable force of vengeance throughout the story. This evolution is profound, yet it prompts pivotal questions regarding the moral implications of his actions—questions that the film’s conclusion neglects to address. Instead of reflecting on the weight of Wyatt’s journey, Tombstone chooses a picturesque resolution.

As the credits roll, the film glosses over the many lives Wyatt has taken and the emotional fallout from those losses. This optimistic conclusion undermines the complexity of Wyatt’s character arc and the harrowing experiences he endures. While Wyatt is undoubtedly deserving of a happy ending, the severe tonal shift diminishes the potential for a more impactful closure.

The Potential of an Ambiguous Ending

Elevating Tombstone with Nuance

Wyatt Earp (Kurt Russell) contemplating in confusion in Tombstone

Rather than tying everything up in a neat bow through Wyatt and Josephine’s cheerful interaction, the film could have left viewers with a sense of his unresolved feelings about the past. Envision a scene where Wyatt and Josephine share a quiet moment, perhaps discussing the ramifications of his vendetta, or offering an ambiguous glimpse of their future. Picture Wyatt spotting Josephine in the snowy landscape, eager to be with her but aware of the ongoing cycle of revenge that threatens their happiness. This approach would respect both the film’s themes and the depth of Wyatt’s character.

Throughout Tombstone, Wyatt grapples with his sense of duty and the moral compromises he is forced to make. He does not revel in violence but sees it as a necessary evil. An ending that acknowledges Wyatt’s internal struggle—showcasing his haunting regrets—would resonate more profoundly with audiences. Honestly, much of the romantic subplot between Wyatt and Josephine felt disconnected, pulling me out of the experience with its contrasting tone.

Tombstone: A Legacy Despite Its Flaws

The Lasting Impact of Tombstone

Despite its somewhat tidy conclusion, Tombstone boasts a rich landscape of memorable characters, sharp dialogue, and stunning action sequences that solidify its status as a modern classic. Val Kilmer’s performance as Doc Holliday is particularly unforgettable, adding depth and charisma that complements Wyatt’s stoic demeanor.

The brilliance of this film lies in its ability to merge classic Western elements with profound character explorations. From the heightened tension of the O.K. Corral to the emotional fallout of the vendetta, Tombstone delivers a wealth of unforgettable moments. Even secondary characters, such as Sam Elliott’s Virgil and Bill Paxton’s Morgan, make significant impacts, showcasing the film’s attention to detail and commitment to its roots within the genre.

While the film may stumble at its conclusion, it does not detract from its overall resonance. Wyatt’s compelling narrative—rich with themes of loyalty, justice, and redemption—still captivates viewers. And for many, the surprisingly optimistic ending might just provide a necessary respite from the darker tones preceding it. Ultimately, Tombstone may not achieve perfection, but its unforgettable journey ensures it remains beloved by fans of the genre.

Source & Images