Why Chris Evans Should Not Reprise His Role as Captain America in ‘Avengers: Doomsday’

Is Chris Evans Back for Avengers: Doomsday?

Marvel fans are left pondering an intriguing question: Is Chris Evans returning for Avengers: Doomsday? A recent report from Deadline suggests he might be, yet Evans himself has publicly denied these claims. In a notable interview with Anthony Mackie, where they celebrated Mackie’s debut as the new Captain America, Evans was asked if he planned to reprise his iconic role.

Evans’ Denial

Evans responded decisively, calling the Deadline report “not true.” He remarked, “This always happens. I mean, it happens every couple of years—ever since Endgame. I’ve just stopped responding to it.” He reiterated Mackie’s sentiment that his character, Steve Rogers, is “happily retired.”

The Question of Truth

The big question remains: Is Evans being truthful, or is he simply attempting to mislead fans, as Andrew Garfield did prior to Spider-Man: No Way Home? Interestingly, Hayley Atwell, who portrayed Peggy Carter, is confirmed to return in Doomsday, according to the same Deadline report. This has led many fans to hope for a reunion between Steve and Peggy, especially since many were unsatisfied with the resolution provided in Endgame.

Thoughts on Returning Characters

When the news about Evans potentially returning first broke, many observers—including myself—were skeptical. While I have great admiration for Evans as Captain America, it is crucial to recognize that the mantle has now been passed to Mackie’s Sam Wilson, the first Black Captain America. Bringing Steve Rogers back could overshadow Sam’s role, diminishing the significance of his character’s journey in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

Supporting New Heroes

My fondness for Sam Wilson has only grown since his introduction in Captain America: The Winter Soldier. With the upcoming film Captain America: Brave New World heavily promoting a new era for the franchise with a Black Captain America, it feels essential that Sam’s legacy is honored and not undermined by the return of Steve Rogers.

The Need for Change in the MCU

The Marvel Cinematic Universe risks falling into a repetitive cycle by relying on past characters instead of embracing new heroes. Characters like Shang-Chi and Kamala Khan are pivotal for shaping the future of the franchise but are often sidelined. The upcoming return of Robert Downey Jr.as Doctor Doom, instead of the beloved Tony Stark, feels like a desperate attempt to cling to the familiarity of the past.

Final Thoughts

In an ideal scenario, Evans is indeed truthful about not returning for Doomsday. However, in the ever-surprising world of Marvel, we might just find him unexpectedly reappearing in Avengers: Secret Wars down the line.

Source & Images