Why Below Deck Sailing Yacht Season 5 Is Struggling: The Impact of Gary King’s Controversial Behavior

Analysis of Below Deck Sailing Yacht Season 5: A Disappointing Voyage

The fifth season of Below Deck Sailing Yacht is approaching its finale, and it’s safe to say that this season has not met expectations. The troubles began not just from the onset of filming but also from the pre-season controversies surrounding Gary King’s behavior. As the season unfolded, viewers have grappled with the fallout from Gary’s earlier allegations of sexual misconduct, casting a long shadow over the show’s dynamics.

As allegations surfaced—concerning inappropriate conduct towards a Below Deck makeup artist—Gary adamantly denied any wrongdoing. Despite the serious nature of these claims, it quickly became apparent that he faced no substantial repercussions during the season. Producers attempted to edit around Gary’s controversial presence but still showcased him prominently, leaving audiences divided; some found it difficult to enjoy the show while grappling with his involvement.

Dramatic Tensions between Danni and Diana

Struggles with Authority and Team Cohesion

Danni Warren looking stressed on Below Deck Sailing Yacht — Image by Cesar García

The relationship between Chief Stew Daisy Kelliher and her stews, Danni Warren and Diana Cruz, was a source of ongoing tension this season. Despite being relatively new to the Below Deck franchise of reality television, both Danni and Diana struggled significantly under Daisy’s leadership. Daisy, who joined the team after a solid run on Below Deck Down Under, found herself overwhelmed by the resistance offered by her subordinates.

From the outset, it became apparent that managing Danni and Diana would pose a considerable challenge for Daisy. Contrary to her expectations of having a supportive and skilled team, she faced frequent pushback. The stews not only disregarded her directives but also openly challenged her authority, leading to a chaotic atmosphere onboard.

Lack of Chemistry Among the Cast

Disconnected Interactions and Minimal Rapport

Throughout Below Deck Sailing Yacht season 5, the cast has displayed a noticeable lack of chemistry, distinguishing this season from its predecessors. While the crew has occasionally banded together to ensure the charter guests enjoy their time aboard the Parsifal III, their interpersonal dynamics have been strained and often uncooperative.

Various factors could explain this lack of cohesion. The established hierarchy aboard the yacht created added tension, leading the cast to form sub-groups rather than unite as a single team. This fragmentation resulted in missed opportunities for collaboration during challenging moments, inhibiting meaningful communication.

Underwhelming Drama and Routine Episodes

Where’s the Fire?

Daisy Kelliher working and giving an interview — Image By César García

Despite a few intriguing moments, it’s hard to proclaim that this season has been rife with gripping drama. Episodes have been characterized by a lack of intensity, with the crew largely managing their responsibilities without major conflicts. While Daisy faced challenges with her stews, the hidden tensions between her and Gary hinted at deeper, unresolved issues—yet these narratives often felt unexplored or bland.

With Gary’s conflicts—particularly with Emma Crouch, who was dismissed mid-season—viewers witnessed some dramatic stretches. However, overall, the drama mainly centered around professional mishaps rather than personal entanglements. Consequently, as the season progressed, the tension dulled, and episodes became repetitive and uninspired.

Captain Glenn’s Leadership Style Under Scrutiny

Is His Authority Becoming Counterproductive?

Captain Glenn Shephard, the leader of the Parsifal III, has steered the narrative towards his inclination to assert dominance this season. While the captain’s role undoubtedly involves maintaining authority, his more conspicuous attempts to exert control appear overwhelming. Rather than effectively addressing the troubling dynamics among the crew, his leadership style has increasingly reflected personal ego rather than genuine leadership.

Captain Glenn seems focused on projecting authority rather than resolving real issues, such as Gary’s inappropriate behavior or the ongoing strife within the stews’ relationships. Instead, he’s offered vague warnings and directed criticisms towards Daisy, raising questions about his efficacy as a leader this season.

As fans eagerly await the conclusion of Below Deck Sailing Yacht season 5, it remains to be seen if the final episodes can salvage the season’s reputation. Tune in Mondays at 9 p.m. EST on Bravo to catch the last of this tumultuous journey.

Source: Below Deck/Instagram

Source & Images