Why 2023 Outshines 2024 as a Superior Year for Movies

Reflecting on the 2024 Awards Season: A Mixed Bag of Cinematic Performances

The year 2024 is drawing to a close, and as the awards season heats up, many cinephiles find themselves contemplating the frontrunners for prestigious accolades like the Golden Globes and the Oscars. However, one pressing question lingers: Are there any definitive favorites this year? Unlike the exceptional cinematic landscape of 2023, which delivered a series of blockbusters, 2024 has experienced a notable lack of standout films, leading to an air of unpredictability in the awards race.

Contrasting 2023 and 2024

Last year’s awards season was characterized by fierce competition and an abundant selection of critically acclaimed films. With so many cinematic masterpieces vying for attention, it was virtually impossible to pick a clear winner. From powerful performances to passionate fan campaigns, audiences felt a palpable excitement in engaging with diverse film narratives.

Margot Robbie as Barbie from the Barbie movie — (Warner Bros. Pictures)

In 2023, cinephiles were treated to the sensational “Barbenheimer”phenomenon, where Christopher Nolan’s Oppenheimer solidified its position as a critical and commercial juggernaut, leading many to believe that Cillian Murphy was destined for an Oscar. Concurrently, Greta Gerwig’s Barbie captivated audiences worldwide, making it hard to ignore in discussions of awards potential. Not to be overshadowed, Martin Scorsese’s epic Killers of the Flower Moon—despite its lengthy runtime—also emerged as a serious contender.

A Year of Undeniable Talent

Films such as The Holdovers and American Fiction left audiences debating which could truly claim the title of best picture, while Emma Stone’s captivating performance in Yorgos Lanthimos’ surreal Poor Things delighted viewers and critics alike, showcasing unique storytelling. The tight competition extended beyond the primary categories, complicating jury decisions for titles like Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse and The Boy and The Heron, both buzzing contenders for Best Animated Feature.

Festival favorites such as Anatomy of a Fall, Past Lives, and The Zone of Interest further enriched 2023’s tapestry of cinematic excellence. While dark horses like The Color Purple and Rustin surfaced late in the race, they contributed to an already crowded category filled with remarkable talent in acting, directing, and screenwriting.

The Current Landscape of 2024

In contrast, while 2024 began promisingly with films like Dune: Part Two, the question remains: Can this year’s offerings truly compete with the richness of last year’s lineup? Although there are some standout films generating buzz—such as The Brutalist, Gladiator II, and Wicked—the absence of clear frontrunners has left many scratching their heads when attempting to predict award winners.

Timothee Chalamet as Paul Atreides in 'Dune: Part Two' — (Warner Bros)

As films such as Emilia Pérez, Inside Out 2, and Furiosa: The Mad Max Saga gain attention, a cloud of uncertainty still looms. The popularity of these films, coupled with social media buzz, arguably overshadows their actual cinematic merit, leaving industry insiders puzzled by the award nominations. Observers question why certain crowd-pleasers received more nominations than a critically acclaimed technical marvel like Dune: Part Two.

The Question of Consensus

While it’s undeniable that 2024 has its share of noteworthy films, the year lacks the collective sparkle that marked 2023. The nominations in several awards categories appear disorganized, and nominations often feel influenced by buzz rather than film quality. This has led to critiques regarding underappreciated gems like Juror #2 and The Outrun, alongside performances from actors such as Saoirse Ronan and Josh O’Connor that many believe deserved more recognition.

Karla Sofia Gascón as Emilia Pérez and Zoe Saldaña as Rita Mora Castro face each other — (Netflix / Pathé)

The unpredictability of the current awards season further emphasizes the disparity between 2023’s cinematic achievements and the more mixed reception of 2024’s offerings. As award nominations loom closer, film enthusiasts and critics alike find themselves in unfamiliar territory, echoing a sentiment of uncertainty without clear frontrunners to latch onto.

The emphasis of the awards should be on the merit and creativity of the films rather than external influences or trends. Ultimately, while the cinematic landscape of 2024 may fall short of 2023’s brilliance, the potential for surprises remains, drawing audience excitement and paradoxically upholding the very essence of art in cinema.

Source&Images