Controversy Surrounds Rosé and Bruno Mars After Plagiarism Allegations Over “APT.”

Rosé of BLACKPINK and Bruno Mars are currently facing online backlash regarding their recent collaboration, “APT.”Critics have accused the artists of plagiarism, claiming that their song bears striking similarities to prior works, particularly an unreleased track titled “Apartment”by American artist Poppy. Although only a brief snippet of “Apartment”emerged around 2014, listeners have drawn notable parallels between its sound and that of “APT.”Additionally, Poppy’s earlier song “Altar”has been referenced for having a comparable essence.

Supporters Rally Behind Rosé

In response to these allegations, fans of Rosé have quickly banded together to defend her. They argue that she has been transparent about her involvement in the creative process for “APT,”insisting that the presence of similar chord progressions and musical elements does not equate to plagiarism. Many fans believe that the claims lack foundation and deem the comparisons exaggerated.

Poppy: A Brief Overview of Her Career

Poppy, born Moriah Rose Pereira on January 1, 1995, has built a reputation as an innovative American singer, songwriter, actress, and YouTube personality known for her eclectic music style and unique persona. Her single “Altar,”alongside Japanese artist Sawai Miku’s “Sorry, I Can’t Be a Good Girl,”has emerged as a focal point in the ongoing plagiarism discussion.

Since entering the music scene around 2015, Poppy has seamlessly blended bubblegum pop with electronic influences and maintained thematic consistency with her YouTube content. Her debut album, “Poppy.Computer”(2017), showcased her signature style, combining various elements of pop and satire.

Her rise to fame began with surreal performance-art-style videos, which captivated audiences with her robotic persona and enigmatic messages. Collaborating with Titanic Sinclair, Poppy cultivated a digital image that blurred the lines between pop stardom and artificial intelligence.

Poppy’s 2021 project, “Flux,”demonstrated her evolving sound by integrating alt-rock and grunge influences, while her 2023 “Stagger EP”delved into more introspective electronic themes. Beyond music, Poppy is also active in acting, fashion, and voice work, showcasing her versatile artistic abilities. Although “Apartment”has never been commercially released, the perceived similarities with “APT.”have intensified speculation about potential inspirations.

The Impact on Rosé’s Reputation

Poppy’s supporters have voiced concerns that “APT.”might lack originality, should the similarities be intentional. However, Rosé’s fanbase argues that such overlaps in music are a common occurrence given the vast array of material produced globally, asserting that unintentional resemblances should not automatically be labeled as plagiarism.

“I just hope and pray Poppy sues them… They do plagiarism. Fraud,”one critic remarked.

“Will they ever have something original?”another questioned.

“That’s the same song,”a third critic stated.

Conversely, supporters of Rosé assert,

“I heard this melody about 30 times now; no one stole from Poppy lol,”a fan defended.

“They don’t accept seeing an organic success,”another fan added.

“Life is too short for all this. It’s just a song; if you like it, then listen to it,”an internet user concluded.

In addition to “Altar,”another track mentioned in the criticisms is Sawai Miku’s “Sorry, I Can’t Be a Good Girl.”Observers claim that a melody in “APT.”closely mirrors a section from Miku’s song. Interestingly, when the tempos of both tracks are aligned, the resemblance becomes even clearer.

In a recent interview with Vogue, Rosé revealed that “APT.”was inspired by a traditional Korean drinking game. Initially hesitant about creating a song around such a theme, she eventually embraced the idea, resulting in a unique piece that resonated with audiences across the globe. This background lends credence to her claims of originality, suggesting that her approach was driven by personal inspiration rather than imitation.

Despite the ongoing debates, “APT.”continues to perform exceptionally well on international music charts, highlighting that both its popularity and success remain intact. The song’s achievements, combined with the vigorous defense from Rosé’s supporters, illuminate the complex landscape K-pop artists navigate in the global music market, where even slight musical similarities can lead to intense scrutiny.

Source & Images