What Scream 7 Must Avoid from the Scream 4 Plot Hole

Overview

Scream 7 needs to sidestep glaring plot holes, such as the perplexing car incident from Scream 4.
Establishing clear links to Sidney Prescott is essential to minimize viewer frustrations in Scream 7.

Plot discrepancies frequently plague the horror genre, particularly in slasher films where villains often display questionable intelligence. These human antagonists can make significant errors that, while not detrimental to the entertainment value, can frustrate dedicated fans. Since the inception of the Scream series in 1996, numerous plot holes have caught the attention of viewers, prompting concerns for future installments.

One fan highlights a notably perplexing moment from Scream 4, released in 2011, in which Sidney Prescott (portrayed by Neve Campbell) returns to Woodsboro to promote her memoir. With the anticipated release of Scream 7 slated for February 2026, there is hope that similar inconsistencies will be absent this time around.

Key Scream 4 Plot Holes to Avoid in Scream 7

Sidney Prescott and Jill Roberts looking scared in Scream 4

A recent discussion on Reddit highlighted a scene in Scream 4 where Ghostface places their mask, blood, and knife inside Sidney Prescott’s rental vehicle during a book signing event. The user expressed confusion over how characters Charlie (played by Rory Culkin) or Jill (played by Emma Roberts) managed to execute this without being seen:

“I still am confused by the scene with Sidney’s rental car. How did Charlie or Jill even have access to place all of those things in the trunk? Sid hadn’t even met up with Jill at that point in the movie.”

Another user chimed in with an equally valid point:

“They did it without anyone noticing, it was broad daylight with a bunch of people at the library. Also, even if somehow they did it without being noticed, in 2011 there were already security cameras.”

The absurdity of this plot hole is indeed striking. Given that the bookstore signing took place during the daytime, how could Ghostface go undetected? It is implausible that either Charlie or Jill could have executed this maneuver without drawing attention. Moreover, a local resident witnessing such an act could have alerted law enforcement, leading to their capture. This scene feels extraneous; there are ways for Sidney to sense Ghostface’s presence without needing this convoluted setup. For instance, she could feel their gaze amidst the crowd or worry about being followed to a nearby café.

For Scream 7 to avoid repeating past mistakes, it is crucial that the narrative establishes Ghostface operating predominantly at night rather than during daylight—unlike the aforementioned scene in Scream 4. This setting would allow for a grittier, more suspenseful atmosphere, as it complicates the process of sneaking around unnoticed. Whether the antagonist is revealed to be Sidney’s husband Mark Evans (Joel McHale) or a fresh villain, taking this approach would enhance the tension compared to previous installments.

Strategies for Scream 7 to Avoid Plot Holes

Sidney Prescott with a knife in Scream 4

The primary strategy for Scream 7 should be to provide coherent and logical justifications for all components of Sidney Prescott’s story, particularly Ghostface’s motives. With Sidney now enjoying a new life with her family, a compelling rationale must exist for why she becomes a target once again. This ties into a fascinating fan theory involving characters Stu Macher (Matthew Lillard) and Roman Bridger (Scott Foley), whose potential returns could provide an exhilarating connection back to Sidney.

Moreover, simplicity should guide the scriptwriting process. A convoluted plot may confuse viewers and dampen their enjoyment. Scream 7 should ensure that each new character maintains a connection to Sidney, promoting meaningful interactions throughout. Ideally, one of these newcomers would serve as a friend to Sidney, driving engagement while accommodating the interests of long-time fans who wish to see more of her journey.

Source & Images