What If Nightwing Never Joined Batman? DC’s Dark Plans for the Hero Revealed

Attention: This article includes SPOILERS for Nightwing #122.

The latest installment of DC’s Nightwing (#122) unveils a gripping alternate narrative of Dick Grayson’s life as Batman’s original Robin. Currently, Blüdhaven is engulfed in turmoil due to a violent gang war, fueled by the controversial Spheric Solutions—a company supplying law enforcement with high-powered weaponry under the guise of restoring order. Nightwing, along with Barbara Gordon, unearths shocking evidence connecting the company’s CEO to both the chaos in their city and a notorious Gotham villain from Grayson’s past.

In this exciting issue, crafted by Dan Watters and illustrated by Dexter Soy, Nightwing reflects on his backstory with Batman and their harrowing encounter with the Cirque du Sin, a sinister circus that targeted the wealthy not for theft, but for brutal murder. It’s during this chilling episode that Robin meets Colombina, a harlequin clown, whom Nightwing suspects to be Oliva Pearce, Spheric’s CEO in the present. Despite their shared appearance of youth, Colombina reveals that the Cirque du Sin not only embraced her but also sought to entice Robin into their fold:

Cirque du Sin Wanted Robin in Nightwing #122

Had Batman not stepped in, it’s plausible to believe that Dick Grayson might have been wooed into the dark embrace of the Cirque du Sin, shaping him into a far different figure within the DC Universe.

DC Reveals the Cirque du Sin’s Interest in Robin

A Sinister Circus of Criminality

Speculating on the trajectory of Dick Grayson’s life is captivating, particularly considering the tragic circumstances that transformed him into Nightwing. Growing up performing alongside his parents in Haly’s Circus, Grayson faced a pivotal moment after their untimely deaths. The narrative suggests that in a more sinister scenario, an embittered Dick might have found solace in the Cirque du Sin, mirroring Colombina’s fate had he not been adopted by Bruce Wayne.

As this Nightwing saga unfolds, readers eagerly anticipate the next move from the Cirque du Sin. Notably, Olivia Pearce, aka Colombina, continues to perpetrate unrest in Blüdhaven, igniting skirmishes on both sides under the sinister influence of the mysterious Zanni— a counterpart from the traditional Italian theater, Commedia dell’arte. Despite these revelations, Nightwing’s uncertainty about Pearce’s true identity complicates matters.

The Impact of Batman’s Decision on DC History

A Darker Path Awaits Nightwing

Whether it’s the Cirque du Sin, the Court of Owls, or other villains lurking in the shadows, Batman’s decision to take Dick Grayson under his wing stands as a pivotal moment in DC’s storyline, leading not only to the emergence of one of its finest heroes but potentially averting the birth of a dark antagonist. The return of Nightwing and the inevitable clash with the Cirque du Sin promises an engaging exploration of temptation and resistance. Could this be an attempt to redefine Nightwing’s allegiance?

Nightwing #122 is currently available for purchase at your local comic store.

Source & Images