Violet’s Pregnancy After Onyx Storm: Comprehensive Fourth Wing Theory Analysis (Evidence, Challenges & Implications)

The latest addition to Rebecca Yarros’ Empyrean series, Onyx Storm, has captivated readers with numerous surprising developments. Among these, one prominent theory emerging from the narrative is the possibility that Violet might be pregnant. This speculation is fueled by various physical clues and the intriguing notion of Xaden’s desire for an heir.

However, Yarros is known for her adeptness in weaving intricate red herrings throughout her plots. For instance, readers were engaged in theories regarding Violet’s second signet, with the ultimate revelation taking them by surprise. As the wait for the next book stretches over two years—a well-deserved hiatus for the author—fans are likely to unearth hidden details and subtle clues throughout the text.

When Might Violet Have Conceived in Onyx Storm?

Potential Conception During Their Journey

There is a compelling possibility that Violet could have conceived while she, Xaden, and the quest squad explored the isles. They confirmed their use of a fertility suppressant in details teased in Fourth Wing, yet the effectiveness of this tincture remains ambiguous. If infused with magic, it may not yield the same effects on the isles. The couple seized the moment, aware that Xaden’s urges to drain were suspended in their unique environment.

This scenario raises intriguing questions: What if the fertility suppressant is ineffective here? Moreover, they may lack consistent access to their usual supply. Violet’s menstrual cycle, often a focal point in discussions around pregnancy, is notably absent in the book, leaving room for speculation.

Examining Violet’s Symptoms in Onyx Storm

Noteworthy Symptoms Observed by Her Dragon

As the narrative progresses, various symptoms that Violet experiences appear indicative of pregnancy. She repeatedly states, “I’m going to be sick, ” a phrase that may suggest more beneath the surface. Notably, her episodes of nausea draw concern from both Tairn and Xaden as they notice her dizziness.

Furthermore, during a near-fainting incident in Aretia, Andarna innocently inquires about her illness, raising an eyebrow to Violet’s condition, which is unusual given their bond. For someone attuned to Violet’s health, Andarna’s confusion implies that something more may be occurring. Other signals, such as a notably bitter lavender lemonade, could also point towards a potential pregnancy. While Tairn and Xaden may simply be attentive, Andarna’s inquiry stands out.

The Need for an Heir as Highlighted in Onyx Storm

The Potential for a Riorson-Sorrengail Heir

In the role of Duke of Tyrrendor, Xaden bears the responsibility of being Aretia’s heir. A pivotal discussion in chapter 13 brings the necessity of producing an heir into focus, as Sawyer remarks:

“Legacies usually make for stronger riders, and with as much power as you two wield? Melgren will probably escort you both to a temple of your choosing the second you’re commissioned.”

Although Violet expresses her primary concern for survival until graduation, similar to discussions surrounding marriage earlier in the series, the narrative implies that the timing for starting a family may never be perfect, given the constant risks they face.

The end of Onyx Storm sees a newly-wedded Xaden and Violet, marked by a ring on Violet’s finger and a note indicating the throne’s transfer. Given the dangers associated with her becoming Duchess, bearing an heir would further solidify her reign’s stability and safety, especially as threats to Xaden’s life loom.

The Irids’ Insights on Offspring

The Irids Believe Evolved Offspring Could Save the Venin

In discussions between Andarna and her family—the irids—comments arise regarding the venin and human interactions. The taller male irid speculates that “perhaps their offspring can evolve, ”suggesting that there is potential for the venin to have descendants. This brings forth the question of whether a hybrid child between Xaden and Violet could come into existence.

However, the irid’s musings take place within an apocalyptic framework—the sentiment suggesting that change will only arise when the venin face their dire consequences. Should they manage to improve themselves through their future offspring, perhaps future venin could retain some characteristics without succumbing to their draining instincts.

Parallels with Twilight Support Pregnancy Speculation

Familiar Dynamics Resembling the Early Chapters of Twilight

While some readers may feel fatigued by the pregnancy trope, such a development aligns with elements established throughout the series. The initial chapters of Onyx Storm draw familiar comparisons to Stephenie Meyer’s Twilight, casting Xaden’s venin state in a light reminiscent of Edward Cullen’s struggles. Like Edward, Xaden must continually resist the urge to drain from his one true love.

A potential hybrid child could echo the tension surrounding Bella and Edward’s offspring in Breaking Dawn, where vampire births are exceedingly rare yet undeniably perilous for the mother. Such a twist could add considerable dramatic stakes to Violet’s journey ahead.

Critique of the Pregnancy Theory

Exploring the Gaps in the Pregnancy Argument

Counterarguments to the pregnancy theory highlight its potential premature timing within the broader story arc. While Violet’s age of 22 remains relatively youthful, riders are known to marry and bear children early due to their shortened life expectancy. The ongoing struggle against the venin amplifies the stakes—especially given Violet’s status as the most formidable wielder in a generation. The complications arising from a hybrid pregnancy could be immensely disruptive to the narrative at this critical juncture.

Additionally, it is plausible the fertility suppressant consists of common herbs, preserving its efficacy even amid a lack of magic on the isles. Violet’s adeptness in herbalism, as evidenced in previous events, suggests that she could harness local resources effectively. Rather than pregnancy symptoms, many findings attributed to this state could equally correlate with Violet’s Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, sheer fatigue from their journey, or excessive training.

Implications of Violet’s Possible Pregnancy for the Next Book

Violet’s Challenges Would Multiply

Should Violet be pregnant, her experience in the upcoming fourth book would ultimately transform. Xaden would likely be absent for extended periods, placing Violet in the position of navigating pregnancy alone. Balancing the role of Tyrrendor’s heir—alongside managing the physical and emotional toll of being pregnant—while trying to defeat the venin and heal Xaden would pose monumental challenges, further intensifying her struggles.

Yarros has been known to lay groundwork for significant plot twists (albeit unconsciously), which could apply here as well. Nevertheless, while a pregnancy may not fit the immediate narrative needs, it does not preclude the possibility of Xaden and Violet conceiving down the road. The hints surrounding the need for an heir have been pronounced, yet it may be more fitting to explore these themes later in the series, allowing for other vital threads—including the exploration of Xaden and Violet’s complex parental pasts—to develop without haste.

Source & Images