Unraveling Confusion: Key Inconsistencies in the Creature Commandos Season Finale

Overview

Nina’s skills were exaggerated, resulting in viewer disillusionment.
The public’s fear of Nina appears misplaced in a world filled with other formidable characters.
Noticeable inconsistencies exist regarding Doctor Phosphorus’s abilities and the ambiguous storyline involving Princess Illana.

Creature Commandos concluded with its season finale titled “A Very Funny Monster,” aiming to cap off the first DCU project with a memorable impact. This episode delivered an intensely emotional backstory and a sorrowful farewell to one of its most beloved characters. However, despite the acclaim surrounding Creature Commandos, the R-rated animated series is not without its missteps, much like many other productions in the genre.

The finale particularly exposed several glaring plot holes, inconsistencies, and left numerous questions unanswered. While some of these issues may be resolved in the eagerly awaited second season of the monster-centric “Task Force M,”the apparent disconnect in the story merits further examination.

Nina Mazursky’s Exaggerated Abilities

Was There a Research Oversight on Nina Mazursky?

In the premiere episode of Creature Commandos, titled “The Collywobbles,” Amanda Waller describes Nina Mazursky as a formidable underwater asset and remarks on her exceptional intelligence, calling her “the smartest and most reasonable of the group.” These claims piqued viewer interest and set high expectations for Nina, especially given her later sidelining, which seemed to pave the way for a potential heroic emergence. Unfortunately, when audiences finally delve into Episode 7, it becomes clear that Nina is not the multi-talented figure Waller described; rather, she is simply a strong swimmer without the promised mental and physical prowess.

This discrepancy might stem from a research oversight by Waller’s team. Similar misjudgments were noted in James Gunn’s 2021 reboot, The Suicide Squad, where Weasel’s ability to swim was overlooked entirely. However, it’s equally possible that the writers failed to maintain consistent character development.

Nina Mazursky’s Influence on Star City

Are Meta-Humans Really Commonplace in This Setting?

Nina’s character receives notable depth in Episode 7, unveiling an exceptionally tragic origin story. Born in the fictional Star City with a unique respiratory issue that left her lungs exterior, she was forced to rely on a cumbersome device to breathe—an invention from her father that restricted her existence to aquatic environments. Prior to her capture, she had transformed into a figure of urban legend and fear within Star City. This is puzzling in a universe populated with heroes like Superman and Hawk Girl, raising questions about why the public reacts with such fear towards Nina.

Compounding the confusion, in Episode 1, Waller implies that the Creature Commandos are kept under wraps, known only to those with top-level security clearance. Yet throughout the series, multiple ordinary citizens are seen interacting with or observing the Commandos long before their arrest—such as Doctor Phosphorus being openly present in a public venue. Consequently, the narrative’s assertion of public ignorance feels inconsistent and implausible.

The Erratic Physics of Doctor Phosphorus

Is He Truly Radioactive?

Doctor Phosphorus exhibits a perplexing duality, as he expresses frustration over the lack of affection he receives, noting that any physical contact would result in burns. Waller earlier humorously suggests that even being in proximity to him carries severe risks. However, the show seems to selectively enforce these rules, as Phosphorus regularly interacts physically with both allies and mere bystanders, ignoring the supposed dangers of his radioactive nature.

In one sequence, Phosphorus physically assaults Rick Flag Sr., who emerges with minimal injuries, raising questions about the consistency of the character’s power. This inconsistency becomes glaringly apparent when examining his lethality, which varies significantly in different scenarios, suggesting that his powers are manipulated to suit the plot rather than following a cohesive set of rules.

The Inexplicable Overlook of Princess Illana’s Assassination

How Did the Pokolistani Guards Miss the Gunshot That Ended Princess Illana?

Creature Commandos Princess Rostovic just before her assassination

One of the most glaring instances of convenience in Creature Commandos is the lack of response to Princess Illana’s assassination. Given her status as a target, one would expect guards to be vigilant; however, she appears to be completely unprotected. Following the assassination, The Bride exits the castle unchallenged, despite making a loud exit and inflicting harm on a dignitary.

It raises the question: if the noise from The Bride’s actions outside the castle could draw attention, then how could a similar sound from within the castle go completely unnoticed? The continued absence of guard responsiveness throughout this incident feels evidently contrived and begs for an explanation.

Who Is Princess Illana Rostovic, Really?

The Series Lacks Exploration of Her Motivations and Backstory

From her first appearance in the series, where she attempts to seduce Rick Flag Sr., it’s evident that Princess Illana Rostovic hides layers beneath her surface persona. Circe’s foreboding vision amplifies this mystery, leading audiences to expect a significant revelation regarding Illana’s true motivations. However, by the finale, it becomes clear that Illana suffers the worst fate in Creature Commandos.

Despite ominous hints about her potential threat to humanity, viewers are left with scant information regarding her motivations. The situation is made worse by her abrupt and violent demise, deemed unjust as she is predominantly portrayed as an innocent character. Moreover, her alliance with Clayface remains unexplained, leaving viewers speculating the origins of this partnership without a satisfactory answer.

Source&Images