Unforgivable Plot Holes in Captain America: Brave New World

Overview

A poorly executed brainwashing scheme in Captain America: Brave New World generates confusion among audiences.
The film overlooks critical developments from Secret Invasion, leaving pivotal elements unaddressed.
The unusually rapid spread of negative news raises concerns about the narrative quality and detracts from the overall story.

Captain America: Brave New World burst onto the big screen, heralding a new era for Sam Wilson following his earlier adventures in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU).However, as fans dive deeper into the film, they unveil several narrative elements that fall short of expectations. While some plot threads are expertly woven into the broader MCU fabric, others are executed poorly, leaving audiences puzzled by the logic behind vital plot decisions. These flaws in Captain America: Brave New World significantly detract from the overall storytelling experience.

For dedicated fans, the film’s handling of key storylines can undermine the enjoyment of what is meant to be a thrilling cinematic journey. Anticipation was high for this installment, and the glaring plot inconsistencies make it difficult to fully engage with the action on-screen. Such issues might explain why the film has garnered a lukewarm reception from critics and audiences alike.

Captain America: Brave New World’s Brainwashing Was Poorly Carried Out

The unveiling of The Leader’s scheme initially appeared to promise a clever yet dangerous plot. The concept of brainwashing heroic characters through sinister techniques was compelling. However, as the narrative progressed, the mechanics of this brainwashing and its implementation became increasingly murky.

A major flaw lies in the film’s failure to explain pivotal details: how The Leader accessed his victims for brainwashing and the underlying workings of his plan. If he could manipulate a vast number of people, why was it that he did not target Captain America or President Ross directly?

The filmmakers made only a cursory attempt to rationalize how The Leader could achieve such widespread influence with a brief mention from Ross about his ability to “hack into files.”Given the importance of this plot element, one would expect a more thorough exploration rather than a hastened dismissal by the writers.

Captain America: Brave New World Completely Ignored Secret Invasion’s Big Reveal

President Ritson speaking directly to the camera in Secret Invasion episode 6

When Secret Invasion premiered on Disney+, it seemed poised to drastically alter the MCU landscape. Yet, similar to Brave New World, it faced criticism and backlash from fans. Notably, the key events from that series warranted at least a mention in the new film.

Wouldn’t there be measures in place to identify Skrulls during a time of escalating distrust among governments? Moreover, the transition of Ross into a leadership role previously occupied by a Skrull raises fundamental questions. The revelation of an alien infiltration in such a significant context deserves acknowledgment and discussion within the film.

Bad News Travels Oddly Fast In Captain America: Brave New World

The narrative in Captain America: Brave New World features two scenes where news spreads at an unusually rapid pace. The first instance occurs when The Leader’s mind-controlled henchmen target Isaiah Bradley. Almost instantly, Joaquin receives information about the situation at the Raft, which raises questions about the source of that intelligence, especially since both he and Sam have been sidelined by President Ross. Who alerted Joaquin, and how did that information reach him before the President was even aware of the situation?

The absurdity of the news cycle is further highlighted when The Leader voluntarily surrenders to the authorities, and the media promptly has access to details of his manifesto that implicates President Ross. The staging of this event makes it seem as if Ross is holding a press conference while Stearns is being arrested, leading to absurd timelines.

It is troubling that journalists are able to question Ross about accusations from a supposed “criminal mastermind”in real-time, suggesting that plot convenience outweighs logical progression. The rapid dissemination of information contributes to a narrative flaw that critics have pointed out, indicating a lack of thoroughness and attention from the writers in a film expected to uphold the rich legacy of the MCU.

Source & Images