Understanding the Ninth Doctor’s Behavior in Doctor Who: Why He Acts Like He Just Regenerated in Season 1’s Premiere

The timeline of the Ninth Doctor in Doctor Who initially posed several challenges regarding continuity, but subsequent revelations have clarified these inconsistencies. The series made its highly anticipated return in 2005 with the episode “Rose, ”introducing Christopher Eccleston as the latest incarnation of the Doctor. Upon initial observation, it seemed that the Doctor had just undergone regeneration at that moment. In an amusing exchange with himself in Rose’s London flat, the Ninth Doctor looked into a mirror and quipped, “Ah, could’ve been worse. Look at me ears!”

The Doctor’s self-assessment immediately following a regeneration is a well-established trope within the franchise. Nine’s surprise at his own appearance suggested that his current form was newly acquired. However, the commemoration of Doctor Who’s 50th anniversary in 2013 unveiled critical connections, confirming that Paul McGann’s Eighth Doctor had transformed into John Hurt’s War Doctor, who subsequently regenerated into Eccleston’s Ninth Doctor post-Time War. What remained ambiguous, however, was the timeline—whether “Rose”occurred just after the War Doctor’s regeneration or following a more extended period.

The Ninth Doctor’s Previous Adventures Before “Rose”

Familiarity Before a Fresh Start

The War Doctor Regenerates Into The Ninth Doctor in Doctor Who.

During the introductory episode, when Rose Tyler converses with Clive, he shows her photographs of the Doctor at various historical events, including the Titanic disaster, the eruption of Krakatoa, and the assassination of JFK. Each image featured Eccleston’s likeness, implying that the Ninth Doctor had embarked on numerous adventures prior to “Rose”, even before the series’ modern iterations began.

Clive’s presentation was intended to suggest that this incarnation was not entirely new. One possible interpretation is that the Ninth Doctor made brief appearances at significant historical milestones immediately following the War Doctor’s regeneration and ultimately made his way to London in 2005. However, it is clear that the visuals Clive shared with Rose were merely snippets of an extensive timeline—there must have been many more undiscovered escapades across different planets or unrecorded events that Clive could not have possibly captured.

Russell T Davies later elaborated on this in Doctor Who Magazine, asserting that Clive’s research was explicitly designed to demonstrate that the Ninth Doctor was not an entirely fresh incarnation. Davies also referred to Nine’s confident demeanor as further corroborative evidence.

Understanding the Ninth Doctor’s Reaction to His Reflection

Surprise Is Relative for Time Lords

Christopher Eccleston as the Ninth Doctor looking in a mirror in Doctor Who.

Despite the preceding context, it remains puzzling why Eccleston’s character assessed his image in a mirror during “Rose.”The line “could’ve been worse”echoes what subsequent Doctors have remarked in their first moments post-regeneration, giving the impression that this was a novel experience for Nine. In contrast, it seems highly unlikely that Peter Capaldi’s Twelfth Doctor, several seasons in, would suddenly express a surprise regarding his eyebrows.

Doctor	Cause of Regeneration
First Doctor (William Hartnell)	Old age
Second Doctor (Patrick Troughton)	Time Lord punishment
Third Doctor (Jon Pertwee)	Radiation poisoning
Fourth Doctor (Tom Baker)	Fall from height
Fifth Doctor (Peter Davison)	Poisoning
Sixth Doctor (Colin Baker)	The Rani
Seventh Doctor (Sylvester McCoy)	Surgery
Eighth Doctor (Paul McGann)	Ship crash
War Doctor (John Hurt)	Old age
Ninth Doctor (Christopher Eccleston)	Absorbing TARDIS energy
Tenth Doctor (David Tennant)	Radiation
Eleventh Doctor (Matt Smith)	Old age
Twelfth Doctor (Peter Capaldi)	Cybermen
Thirteenth Doctor (Jodie Whittaker)	Qurunx Beam
Fourteenth Doctor (David Tennant)	The Toymaker

Ultimately, as part of Doctor Who’s 50th-anniversary events, the ambiguity surrounding the Ninth Doctor’s timeline was resolved, albeit not through an on-screen narrative. The logical conclusion drawn is that while the Ninth Doctor did exist for a period prior to “Rose, ”he consciously chose to refrain from viewing himself throughout that time. Therefore, “Rose”marks the very first instance that Nine truly encountered his own face.

Did Rose Tyler Facilitate the Doctor’s Healing After the Time War?

The Doctor’s Emotional Recovery Journey

The revelations provided by Moffat effectively clarified any confusion regarding the Ninth Doctor’s timeline. This clarity raises an intriguing question: why, after his tumultuous experiences post-Time War, does the Ninth Doctor appear to joke about his image in “Rose”? The Doctor shows no signs of fear or hesitation when facing his own reflection, suggesting a substantial emotional healing process that might have been spurred by his relationship with Rose.

If Rose indeed played a pivotal role in helping the Doctor recover from the trauma of the Time War, it would add layers of significance to their relationship dynamically woven throughout Doctor Who.

Although Rose and the Doctor were still early in their journey together, their immediate chemistry was palpable. Even during their initial encounters, the Doctor visibly admired Rose’s intellect and bravery, complimenting her keen deduction skills. It is evident that Nine began to foster the vital Doctor-companion bond he had long shunned post-Gallifrey’s fall. Perhaps it was this rekindled sense of companionship ignited by Rose that allowed the Doctor the strength to confront his own image after a long period.

YouTube Link

Eventually, Rose would evolve into one of the most significant companions in Doctor Who, with their relationship blossoming into romance following Nine’s transition into Ten. Rose’s impact on the Doctor’s emotional state during their early encounters only deepens the value of their bond, particularly explaining why the Doctor chose to love her after years of maintaining strictly platonic connections with companions.

Sources: Doctor Who Magazine

Source & Images