Understanding the Emotional Conclusion of Dear Zachary

Content Warning: This article addresses sensitive topics, including child murder and suicide.

Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father, directed by Kurt Kuenne, transcends typical investigative documentaries by weaving a deeply personal and heart-wrenching narrative. Premiering in 2008, the film captures Kuenne’s journey following the untimely death of his close friend, Andrew Bagby, in 2001. As Kuenne delves into the circumstances surrounding Andrew’s murder, attention turns to his ex-girlfriend, Shirley Turner, a primary suspect, which escalates into additional tragedy when she announces her pregnancy with Andrew’s child, Zachary. The events that unfold irrevocably alter the lives of everyone connected to this heartbreaking story.

The emotional gravitas of Dear Zachary lingers long after its initial viewing, illustrating the profound impact of trauma on loved ones. Unlike many true crime documentaries that often rely on sensationalism, Kuenne’s poignant narrative and heartfelt voiceover elevate the documentary, leaving viewers grappling with the enduring effects of personal loss. Moreover, the film culminates in inconclusive tragedy, serving as a broader critique of the legal frameworks in both Canada and the United States.

What Happens In Dear Zachary’s Ending

A Dedicated Movement Emerges to Prevent Future Tragedies

In the documentary’s harrowing finale, Andrew’s parents, David and Kathleen Bagby, embark on a relentless pursuit of justice following Andrew’s brutal murder. Convinced that Shirley is responsible, they face further anguish when she is granted custody of her son, Zachary, leading to a tragic murder-suicide. These final scenes depict a haunting open-endedness, suggesting that the trauma inflicted by Shirley’s actions will haunt Andrew’s loved ones indefinitely. In their quest for justice, David and Kathleen remain committed, advocating for significant reforms in Canadian bail laws.

The aftermath of this case also brought to light failures within the Newfoundland justice system, as officials acknowledged their ineffectiveness in handling Shirley’s situation. In 2006, the Ministry of Justice admitted to inadequacies in its approach, highlighting that a more comprehensive evaluation of Shirley’s background could have potentially changed the devastating outcome for Zachary. Thus, Dear Zachary serves not only as a tribute to Andrew but also as a clarion call for legal reform.

What Actions Did Andrew’s Parents Take?

Grief and Resilience Propel David and Kathleen Forward

Cover of Dance With the Devil by David Bagby

The heartache following Andrew’s death drove David and Kathleen into profound sorrow, with thoughts of suicide plaguing them as they coped with their immense loss. Yet, even amidst their grief, they emerged as staunch advocates for legal reform. David Bagby penned a memoir entitled Dance with the Devil, which garnered significant attention and became a bestseller in Canada, further amplifying their story.

The closing moments of the documentary exhibit David and Kathleen’s enduring sadness, underscoring that healing from such a tragedy may never be fully realized. Kuenne’s dedication of the film to these parents honors their relentless struggle for justice and acknowledgment of their suffering.

Could Zachary’s Death Have Been Prevented?

Reflecting on Mistakes Made in Dear Zachary

This poignant narrative raises critical questions regarding police and judicial protocols in handling domestic violence and custodial rights. The documentary allows for reflection, particularly on how law enforcement and health professionals could have intervened differently to thwart the tragedy that unfolded.

Where Did Dear Zachary’s Earnings Go?

Encouraging Audience Action Through Tragedy

While the narrative is filled with sorrow, the concluding notes of Dear Zachary offer a glimmer of hope. The filmmakers implore viewers to engage in activism by contacting Canadian Parliament to advocate for bail reform in memory of Andrew and Zachary. Furthermore, all proceeds from the documentary are directed towards charitable initiatives, such as the Dr. Andrew Bagby and Son Zachary Andrew Memorial Bursary at Memorial University of Newfoundland, showcasing Kuenne’s commitment to a cause deeply rooted in friendship rather than profit.

How Dear Zachary Influenced Canadian Legislation

The Documentary’s Post-Release Impact on Legislation

Although Dear Zachary concludes on a somber note, its influence is evident in the legislative changes that followed its release. The documentary sparked sufficient momentum that, in 2009, Canadian MP Scott Andrews introduced Bill C-464, known as “Zachary’s Bill, ” aimed at enhancing protections for children involved in custody hearings. This bill was subsequently enacted in 2010, reflecting the significant legislative impact of Kuenne’s work.

Understanding the Letter Format of Dear Zachary

How the Format Evolved with Tragic Outcomes

The title itself hints at a profound narrative style, transforming Dear Zachary into an emotional letter. Initially addressing Andrew to explore his life, Kuenne’s perspective shifts dramatically following the shocking developments regarding Zachary’s custody. By the documentary’s conclusion, it stands as a heartfelt letter Kuenne might have shared with Zachary had circumstances allowed.

Public Reception of the Ending of Dear Zachary

A Gripping Experience: Documentary or Thriller?

David and Kathleen Bagby sitting with images of Andrew and Zachary in Dear Zachary

Documentaries often face criticism for lacking emotional depth; however, Dear Zachary counters this narrative, drawing comparisons to a thrilling cinematic experience. Critics acclaimed Kuenne’s direction, which uses dramatic storytelling techniques to engage viewers emotionally through its every twist and turn.

The New York Sun boldly referred to it as “one of the most mind-blowing true-crime movies in recent memory, ” recognizing its ability to captivate audiences with unexpected developments. The publication noted:

…has so many unexpected developments that it plays like a first-rate thriller….and the film is so unsettling that it will stay with viewers for a long time.

Furthermore, Variety commended the documentary’s editing style for its ability to evoke emotional responses:

The way Kuenne presents the material, with an aggressive style that lingers less than a second on most shots, it’s impossible not to feel emotionally exhausted.

This journey resonates deeply with viewers, prompting Kuenne to create a follow-up documentary, detailing the process of enacting change in Canadian law. Though brief, it offers insights behind the scenes of how the original film shaped legislative action and is available for viewing on Kuenne’s YouTube channel.

Exploring the True Significance of Dear Zachary’s Conclusion

A Tribute Rather Than Just An Investigation

Andrew Bagby’s legacy remains indelible, malleable enough to shape future conversations about justice and loss. The closing of Dear Zachary conveys unresolved sorrow; with Shirley Turner evading accountability through suicide, both Andrew and Zachary’s lives are irrevocably lost. Nonetheless, David and Kathleen Bagby persist in advocating for their memories, ensuring that their influence endures.

While the film culminates in a poignant reminder of loss, Kuenne’s intimate interviews illustrate the profound impact Andrew had on his loved ones, ensuring his legacy remains vibrant through Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father.

Source & Images