Uncovering the Hidden Love Story in Red Dead Redemption 2

Uncovering the Hidden Love Story in Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2 is widely acclaimed for its intricate narrative and multifaceted characters. However, there exists a subtler romantic subplot that has often been overlooked. While the poignant love story between Arthur Morgan and Mary Linton takes center stage, there are compelling indications that Abigail Roberts (who would later marry John Marston) held a significant emotional space in Arthur’s heart as well. This potential connection goes beyond just a journal entry; insights from interviews with the game developers shed light on their initial motivations.

The clues supporting this possible romance arise not only from discussions with the developers but also from Arthur Morgan’s voice actor. Players can find residual elements of what might have originally been part of the narrative, as the effort to record new dialogue and animations may not have justified the resources. This oversight leaves ample evidence throughout the game for players to uncover. This nuanced relationship, while not at the forefront of the main plot, suggests that Arthur’s emotional landscape is far richer than it appears. The intricate details regarding this lost content deepen the intrigue surrounding the characters’ relationships in Red Dead Redemption.

Abigail’s Comments at Camp Indicate a Cut Love Interest

Untapped Dialogue Suggests Deeper Connections

Dutch, Arthur, Hosea and Abigail in Red Dead Redemption 2
Abigail Marston
Fancast of Rebecca Hall as Abigail Roberts

Throughout her time at camp, Abigail’s interactions suggest she was envisioned as more than just a companion to Arthur in Red Dead Redemption 2. The way she looks at him hints at a deeper connection, evidenced by her lines such as “Aren’t you over that yet?” and “Don’t look at me that way.” These statements imply unresolved feelings between the two, indicating a complexity to their relationship.

In a revealing Vulture interview with Dan Houser, co-founder of Rockstar and lead writer, it was disclosed that Arthur was initially designed to have a “secondary love interest.”While many fans might speculate about other characters, it has been confirmed by Roger Clark, the voice actor for Arthur, that scenes focused on building tension between Arthur and Abigail were intended but ultimately cut from the game. In a MomoCon panel, he reiterated that both he and the actress portraying Abigail, Cali Elizabeth Moore, were instructed to convey a sense of “forlorn longing,” suggesting a bond that transcended mere friendship.

Despite these cut scenes, Abigail’s reactions during her interactions with Arthur indicate a deeper emotional complexity than with other gang members. Her guarded yet charged responses, often dismissed as lighthearted camp banter, imply that she was meant to play a pivotal role in Arthur’s emotional journey. This subtle dynamic enhances the richness of the narrative, even if it remains mostly ambiguous.

John’s Absence and Arthur’s Reflections on Abigail

The Impact of an Engagement on Their Lives

All gang hideout locations in RDR2
Arthur fishing in RDR2
Arthur with the Downes family

The tension between Arthur and Abigail is further complicated by John Marston’s absence from the gang for an extended period. This gap creates an opportunity for Arthur’s feelings to develop. The journal entries that Arthur pens, particularly the line, “Perhaps I should have married her. I think part of me has always thought that,” following a fishing trip with Abigail, reveal his internal struggle and hint at what he envisions for their future together in John’s absence.

This adds a layer to Arthur’s jealousy regarding John’s relationship with Abigail, as mentioned by Roger Clark during a second panel discussing these dynamics. Arthur is envious of the stable life that John appears to reclaim, suggesting that he views the gang as a surrogate family. Clark discusses how Abigail seemingly rediscovers her affection for John upon his return, which may have been a significant factor preventing Arthur from pursuing a romantic relationship with her. However, as these elements were cut from the final version, they do not hold canonical status.

Jack’s Relationship with His Father and Arthur’s Sacrifices

Choices Reflecting Growth and Responsibility

John and Abigail in RDR2
John and Abigail posing for a photo
John and Abigail in the epilogue of RDR2

Arthur’s profound feelings for Abigail are tempered by a strong understanding of the importance of family and personal duty. His actions during the game’s climax illustrate his desire for Jack to have a stable family environment. It is evident the narrative suggests Abigail believes Jack would flourish with John as his father, leading to a decision that ultimately showcases Arthur’s selflessness. Despite his personal desires, Arthur recognizes that Jack’s well-being could best be served with John present in his life, heightening the inner conflict stemming from Arthur’s earlier resentment towards John for abandoning his family.

Looking forward, if Red Dead Redemption 3 were to unfold as a prequel, there exists a significant opportunity for developers to delve deeper into the potential relationship dynamics between Abigail and Arthur.

While a great deal of this subplot was omitted, many players are left wondering what insights might have emerged if more context had been provided to Abigail’s character. Further exploration into her perspective could have illuminated the developers’ original vision. However, the absence of this storyline adds to the complex tapestry of character relationships in Red Dead Redemption 2, allowing for thoughtful speculation as players piece together the nuances of the narrative.

Sources: Vulture, MomoCon/YouTube, Convention Coverage/YouTube

Source&Images

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *