The genre of isekai has seen a remarkable surge in popularity across manga and anime, particularly over the past ten years. This trend was significantly bolstered by hit series like Sword Art Online, which sparked a new wave of narratives featuring protagonists transported to alternate realms characterized by RPG mechanics. While the isekai formula can sometimes feel repetitive, several standout titles have emerged, offering viewers an engaging experience steeped in wish fulfillment.
So, what are the best isekai game anime? Despite the close association of the isekai theme with RPGs, only a limited number of shows explicitly depict scenarios set within games. Many others take place within fantasy realms that draw inspiration from gaming conventions. In this article, we’ll delve into those select series that transport their characters directly into video games.
Updated December 15, 2024 by Mark Sammut: As we wrap up the Fall 2024 anime season, a new isekai series set within a game has been added to our lineup, with Winter 2025 poised to introduce another promising addition.
This ranking evaluates not only the quality of the series but also how prominently the gaming elements feature within the narrative. Let’s explore what Winter 2025 has in store.
Will Winter 2025 Include Any Isekai Anime Set in Games?
Winter 2025 is fast approaching, and with it comes a range of isekai anime—many will likely include video game-like mechanics, although only one directly embodies this premise.
- From Bureaucrat to Villainess: Dad’s Been Reincarnated! – This unique twist on the villainess trope centers on Kenzaburou, a middle-aged father who finds himself in an otome game world as Grace Auvergne, lacking familiarity with the game’s intricacies. His journey revolves around leveraging his life experience to navigate challenges while acting as a guardian to the characters around him, making his character development integral to the series.
Now, let’s take a look at the currently airing isekai anime that delve into game-like worlds…
18 The New Gate
MyAnimeList: 6.41
The New Gate stands out as one of the more forgettable entries in the Spring 2024 season of isekai anime. The narrative begins with promise, depicting protagonist Shinya as he liberates trapped players by defeating the final boss—only to find himself thrust 500 years into the future, the last of the once-great heroes. The appeal of witnessing how NPCs mythologize the former players adds depth, yet much of the subsequent storyline lacks engagement as it develops into a slow-paced existence that doesn’t quite deliver on the initial intrigue.
17 Skeleton Knight In Another World
MyAnimeList: 7.17
Skeleton Knight in Another World follows Arc, a character who transforms into a skeletal avatar in a land rife with discrimination. Though the initial premise is engaging, the series shines due to the compelling interactions among its main characters, particularly Arc and his companions. However, its inconsistent tone poses challenges; balancing mature themes with lighter moments can often feel disjointed.
16 In The Land Of Leadale
MyAnimeList: 6.95
In The Land of Leadale features a protagonist, Cayna, who embraces a life of tranquility after being reincarnated in the very MMORPG she once loved. Unlike many isekai narratives, her story isn’t driven by grand quests but rather focuses on crafting a peaceful existence, making it a relaxing watch for audiences seeking a gentler pace.
15 Demon Lord, Retry!
MyAnimeList: 6.56
Demon Lord, Retry! embraces its absurdity, featuring an all-powerful protagonist navigated through a world where he constantly draws admiration from his surroundings. Despite its lack of depth, it revels in the tropes of power fantasies, delivering a lighthearted experience devoid of serious narrative weight—perfect for those looking for uncomplicated enjoyment.
14 I’ll Become a Villainess That Will Go Down in History
MyAnimeList: 7.13
While I’ll Become a Villainess That Will Go Down in History introduces a familiar concept, it retains potential as it follows the protagonist Alicia in her attempts to assume the role of villainess to benefit the game’s true heroine. Although it utilizes a narrative framework that has been widely explored, Alicia’s journey showcases her character development while navigating another narrative-heavy landscape.
13 Quality Assurance in Another World
MyAnimeList: 6.25
The anime Quality Assurance in Another World provides a quirky narrative twist by centering on quality testers who become stuck in an unfinished video game. The protagonist, Haga, remains dedicated to his work rather than indulging in mayhem, setting the stage for an interesting dynamic as he navigates a chaotic world while mentoring a young NPC named Nikola.
12 I’m The Villainess, So I’m Taming The Final Boss
MyAnimeList: 7.22
I’m The Villainess, So I’m Taming the Final Boss combines romance and comedy as protagonist Aileen strives to win over the Demon King Claude, following her realization of being the villainess from an otome game. The chemistry between Aileen and Claude enriches the series, although it loses momentum as Aileen experiences the sequel to the original game.
11 Ixion Saga DT
MyAnimeList: 7.14
Ixion Saga DT leans heavily into comedy, following MMORPG veteran Kon Hokaze as he discovers himself in a fantasy realm. With a tone that embraces absurdity, the series might not appeal to all audiences, but its humorous moments can offer delightful entertainment for viewers seeking a non-serious take on the isekai genre.
10 Villainess Level 99: I May Be the Hidden Boss but I’m Not the Demon Lord
MyAnimeList: 7.13
Taking a fresh approach within the overpopulated villainess subgenre, Villainess Level 99… features Yumiella Dolkness, a character who is essentially a secret boss. This narrative shift allows her to stand out amid the clichés, as she seeks to navigate her new life while initially attempting to remain inconspicuous—a goal that naturally proves challenging.
9 And And Bear
MyAnimeList: 7.23 (Season 1)
Kuma Kuma Kuma Bear follows Yuna, a young girl who enters her beloved MMORPG equipped with absurdly powerful gear, making conflicts feel trivial. The focus on the friendships Yuna cultivates throughout her journey, complemented by amusing character interactions, elevates the series despite its lack of unique world-building elements.
8 My Next Life As A Villainess: All Routes Lead To Doom!
MyAnimeList: 7.46 (Season 1)
Recognized among the earliest adaptations of the villainess otome trend, My Next Life As A Villainess captures its essence remarkably well. The storyline finds protagonist Katarina Claes aware of her impending doom as a villain in an otome game, inspiring her to rewrite her fate. Full of humor and creativity, the first season particularly showcases her desperate efforts to secure a brighter outcome for herself.
7 How Not To Summon A Demon Lord
MyAnimeList: 6.85
In the realm of typical isekai narratives, How Not to Summon a Demon Lord illustrates the transition of an introverted gamer into a robust hero in a whimsical world. While it may resonate with familiar motifs, its charismatic humor and engaging character dynamics elevate the series beyond mere tropes.
6 Sword Art Online (First Cour)
MyAnimeList: 7.20
No discussion of isekai anime set in gaming worlds is complete without mentioning Sword Art Online. Renowned for its captivating initial episodes and exploration of different realms, the franchise presents an array of rich narratives, even if some characterizations might not align with viewer expectations.
5 The Most Heretical Last Boss Queen: From Villainess To Savior
MyAnimeList: 7.08
Each anime season typically features a variety of isekai shows, and Summer 2023 was no exception. Among its offerings, The Most Heretical Last Boss Queen: From Villainess to Savior sets itself apart within the villainess narrative genre. Here, the female protagonist grapples with her past as a remorseless antagonist in an otome game, motivating her to change her destiny against her villainous inclinations.
4 Trapped In A Dating Sim: The World Of Otome Games Is Tough For Mobs
MyAnimeList: 7.34
Trapped in a Dating Sim smoothly transitions from rocky beginnings to become an engaging story about Leon, a young man reborn in a dating sim with a female-dominated hierarchy. Armed with knowledge from his previous life yet threatened by the game’s expectations, the narrative thrives on witty banter and the relationships he cultivates.
3 I’m in Love With The Villainess
MyAnimeList: 7.37
I’m in Love With the Villainess delights with its unique perspective on a well-tread narrative. The story unfolds through the journey of Rae, who embraces her role as a protagonist after finding herself in her favorite otome game, where she unexpectedly aims to win over the villainess Claire, creating an endearing bond as they navigate their unusual relationship.
2 .Hack//Sign
MyAnimeList: 6.95
.Hack//Sign is often credited as a pioneer of isekai anime focused on gaming worlds, presenting a more introspective and psychological narrative. Following Tsukasa, a player stranded in an MMORPG, the series delves deeply into his inner turmoil and interpersonal relationships rather than emphasizing action, providing a contemplative experience distinct from typical isekai fare.
1 Log Horizon
MyAnimeList: 7.92 (Season 1)
Log Horizon immerses viewers in the realities of life within an MMORPG by portraying how players adapt to their new worlds and coexist with NPCs. The narrative is driven by its protagonist, Shiroe, who excels in strategy and cooperation over brute strength, highlighting community building and character development, resulting in a rich portrayal of life in a game.
Leave a Reply