Throughout my gaming journey, I’ve often criticized silent protagonists, yet paradoxically, three of my all-time favorite JRPGs feature them prominently. This contradiction emphasizes a broader discussion about the effectiveness of silent characters in storytelling.
Historically, silent protagonists have been more common, but that doesn’t always serve the narrative well. For me, the concept of self-inserting into a character who lacks voice feels strained, especially when they have their own defined traits and backgrounds that I cannot influence. Nevertheless, there are exceptional JRPGs where silence contributes positively to the character’s charisma, often exhibited through their expressions, behavior, or even stylistic choices.
In this article, we’ll delve into some of the most impressive silent protagonists in JRPGs, emphasizing their roles within their respective narratives rather than the games they inhabit. Let’s dive in!
8 Hero
Dragon Quest VIII
The Dragon Quest series is notorious for its silent protagonists, often leading to storytelling that feels lacking, as seen in Dragon Quest XI. Amidst chaos, our hero often appears stoic and unmoved. However, my preference for Dragon Quest VIII’s hero stems from his depth as a character. He starts as a humble soldier, thwarted by a curse, and embarks on a quest driven by a desire to aid others.
What sets this hero apart is his ability to communicate through body language and facial expressions during cutscenes. Even though he doesn’t speak, his character design evokes nostalgia and warmth, reminiscent of beloved figures like Goku. His moments of heightened battle intensity, like transforming into a ‘Super Saiyan, ’ further enrich his persona, despite some features being altered in the Nintendo 3DS version.
7 Ludger
Tales of Xillia 2
One unexpected twist in the Tales of series was the decision to feature a silent protagonist in Ludger. Traditionally known for vibrant dialogues and character interactions, this game’s choice was surprising. However, this silence serves a purpose as it allows players to shape Ludger’s responses, subtly influencing his personality throughout the story.
While he may not have the complexity of more vocal characters like Velvet or Yuri, Ludger’s combination of strength and subtlety keeps him engaging. His character is compelling enough to earn a ranking here, proving that silent roles can flourish even in dialogue-heavy series.
6 Dan/Yuki Kanan
Digimon Story: Time Stranger
Surprising the critics again, Digimon Story: Time Stranger introduces us to another silent protagonist, whom we can choose between Dan Kanan or Yuki Kanan. The chosen character remains silent while their counterpart guides them through voiced dialogue. Unlike many traditional silent protagonists, the choices offered here allow the player to engage humorously, despite the lack of impactful narrative outcomes.
This innovative approach means our silent protagonist plays an active role in a well-defined plot, positioning them above many typical silent protagonists. Rather than mere bystanders, they possess the tools and skills necessary to navigate time and make meaningful choices.
5 Rudy Roughknight
Wild Arms
In Wild Arms, Rudy’s silence serves a narrative function, highlighting his inner struggle for belonging in a world filled with vocal companions. This character embodies the archetype of a reluctant hero who processes experiences profoundly, ultimately showing exponential gains in skills related to destruction and combat without losing his moral compass.
His transformative moment of cutting off his arm symbolizes significant character growth and foreshadows an unexpected twist regarding his origin, revealing he is not merely human, but a Holmcross. This revelation ties together his talents and lends deeper meaning to his journey, often resonating with players long after the game ends.
4 Serge
Chrono Cross
Although I cherish Chrono Trigger, I have always viewed its protagonist, Crono, as a less compelling character. His passivity contrasts sharply with Serge from Chrono Cross, whose silence is pivotal to the game’s intricate plot. Serge not only represents a central plotline but embodies an engaging persona with distinct visual appeal and personal stakes that elevate his role in the story.
His silence becomes a narrative strength, particularly as the distinct dual-world dynamic hinges on his existence and choices, significantly affecting other characters who respond deeply to his journey. Thus, Serge stands out as a strong and relatable silent protagonist.
3 Ryu
Breath of Fire III
Breath of Fire III holds a special place in my heart as it significantly shaped my preferences in gaming. Ryu stands out as a prime example of a well-developed silent protagonist. His character evolves remarkably throughout the game, reflecting his growth both emotionally and narratively through non-verbal cues.
The contrasting phases of his character—from a vulnerable child to a mature hero—demonstrate how silence can be effectively employed to illustrate personal development. The game culminates in a meaningful choice that affects the ending, further emphasizing Ryu’s journey while remaining true to the silent protagonist trope.
2 Joker
Persona 5
The character known as Joker, or Ren Amamiya, breaks the mold of the silent protagonist in Persona 5. While he may only have a handful of highlighted lines, his communications are intentional and stylish, reflecting the game’s overarching themes of rebellion and identity. His tendency to speak less adds to his mystique, allowing actions to define his character.
The Social Link system empowers player choices, giving context and meaning to his reactions and decisions, making it unnecessary for him to have a predefined personality. This clever design enhances player investment and assures that Joker remains a compelling figure throughout the game, contributing to Persona 5 Royal’s status as one of the highest-rated JRPGs.
1 You, Warrior of Light
Final Fantasy XIV
As an MMORPG, Final Fantasy XIV counts as a significant JRPG title, and I’ve repeatedly advocated that its protagonist is perhaps the best in the franchise. The character you create serves as an avatar of the player, allowing self-insertion and facilitating a unique immersive experience.
The linear nature of the story compensates for this silence, as players develop genuine emotional connections with other characters. Moments shared in Eorzea, whether in joyous or sorrowful circumstances, allow the Warrior of Light to resonate intensely with players, immersing them in a rich narrative landscape.
Ultimately, Final Fantasy XIV’s protagonist distinguishes itself as a silent figure that articulates the player’s experience profoundly, proving that silence can offer players a significant voice in storytelling.
Leave a Reply