
Throughout history and across cultures, one truth remains clear: crime thrillers captivate audiences. The allure of real-life crime stories, with their intense and chaotic nature, feeds the insatiable curiosity surrounding true crime. This genre thrives on the reality of crimes committed, providing an intriguing escape into fiction or nonfiction that distances the viewer from the fears associated with actual danger.
Video games, typically structured around player agency, often steer clear of nonfiction narratives since they rely on a predetermined story arc. Nevertheless, if your passion for true crime leans towards investigation and unraveling complex cases, there are numerous games that embody the essence of thrilling crime experiences. Below are some top titles that are perfect for fans of the criminal genre.
8. The Black One
About As Close To Real Police Work As It Gets

For gamers seeking a realistic glimpse into police investigations, L. A.Noire stands out as a cornerstone of the genre. While it may not represent the cutting-edge techniques of modern crime-solving, the game’s reliance on witness testimonies and physical evidence adds authenticity to the detective experience.
The standout feature of L. A.Noire is its innovative use of performance-captured actor faces, allowing characters to express emotions and tells during interrogations. Observing these subtle cues becomes essential as you navigate your investigative journey. Although I personally found the overarching narrative lacking, the individual cases resonate with plausible crimes and motivations, presenting a raw take on the complexities of police work.
7. The Case Of The Golden Idol
Piece Together A Narrative

For those who enjoyed playing Clue as kids, The Case of the Golden Idol will feel familiar. This game emphasizes the process of elimination as players piece together key components of a crime scene, including suspects and motives.
The core gameplay loop revolves around analyzing snapshots from various crime scenes. Players collect names, motives, and critical actions and then organize them into coherent narratives akin to a creative Mad Libs exercise. Completing each case not only sharpens deduction skills but also serves as an engaging writing exercise for aspiring storytellers.
6. Return Of The Obra Dinn
No Bigger Mystery Than Insurance Fraud

The detective work of insurance agents can be surprising, and in Return of the Obra Dinn, tracking down the truth of a missing ship takes center stage. Lacking interview opportunities due to the absent crew, players utilize a unique watch to visualize moments of death during the voyage.
While navigating the game can be challenging, successful investigation hinges on keen observation of environmental clues rather than overt direction. This requires players to think creatively and gather information meticulously beyond surface-level details.
5. Shadows Of Doubt
Approach Crime From Any Angle

The essence of detective work is the adherence to procedural norms, but Shadows of Doubt flourishes in its open-ended mystery that invites unorthodox approaches to crime-solving. This procedurally-generated game presents new scenarios with unique murders, suspects, and motives each time, keeping players on their toes.
As in real investigations, clues are not easily accessible; time is a significant factor, and suspects may attempt to mislead you. Success in this game demands a flexible mindset, leading players to adopt unconventional strategies akin to those of a detective navigating the unpredictable streets.
4. Duck Detective: The Secret Salami
Quack The Case

Not every crime story needs to center on high stakes; Duck Detective: The Secret Salami brilliantly exemplifies how even minor mysteries can be engaging. The game revolves around solving the theft of a lunch rather than a homicide, offering a lighthearted yet engrossing take on detective work.
The game’s vibrant setting encourages scrutiny of surroundings and interaction with characters to uncover valuable clues through deductive reasoning. What stands out is its accessibility, featuring hints for players who are less experienced with detective games while still allowing for straightforward solutions.
3. Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney
See You In Court

While typically tasked with defending clients rather than solving crimes, Phoenix Wright approaches each case with the determination to reveal the true culprit behind the scenes. This visual novel invites players to engage deeply with courtroom dynamics while navigating the nuances of justice.
Though it departs from traditional evidence collection practices, Ace Attorney excels in teaching players to keenly observe testimonies and detecting inconsistencies in witness statements, providing a gripping courtroom experience that thrives on attention and strategy.
2. The Forgotten City
If At First You Don’t Succeed, Run

In The Forgotten City, players find themselves in a time loop, allowing them to explore various investigative paths without the fear of permanent repercussions. This unique mechanic invites creativity, as you must interact with the citizens of a long-lost Roman city to uncover the origins of the crimes and the cause of the time loop.
Swift thinking is vital since players must proactively maintain peace among the residents to prevent crimes. This experience merges elements of detective work and citizen intervention, making it a strategic crime-solving endeavor filled with narrative depth.
1. Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments
Elementary, My Dear Watson

Sherlock Holmes, though a fictional detective, serves as a benchmark for mystery-solving narratives. In Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments, players step into Holmes’ shoes and become engrossed in a variety of captivating cases. The gameplay seamlessly integrates investigation, including inspecting crime scenes and engaging with witnesses, allowing players to weave mysteries through deductive reasoning.
Each case offers a definitive answer, but incorrect interpretations can lead to the culprit escaping justice. Players can choose to let offenders walk free or deliver them into the hands of the law—a narrative twist that illustrates the complex relationship between Holmes and the legal system.
The game provides a thought-provoking exploration of moral choices and the consequences of those decisions within a rich historical context. With all these elements combined, it is truly a standout option for crime genre enthusiasts.
Leave a Reply