Video game spinoffs often evoke mixed reactions, with many franchises attempting to introduce their beloved characters into entirely new gameplay formats, leading to varied success rates. Some titles completely lose their way, fading into obscurity, while others, despite being quality games, attract unwarranted negativity.
This article highlights some of the most underrated spinoffs that have either been unfairly criticized, overlooked, or generally unappreciated, showcasing games well worth your time. To maintain focus, this list features one game from each franchise; hence, franchises like Pokémon and Mario will only be represented by a single title that stands out as particularly underrated.
10 Mega Man Zero
What I’m Fighting For
While not entirely unknown, the Mega Man Zero series has somewhat slipped into obscurity, particularly due to the overshadowing presence of the larger Mega Man franchise in the 2000s. Despite that, these games are remarkable for their engaging gameplay, which allows players to control the character Zero through innovative leveling systems and a distinct melee-focused combat system, setting them apart from traditional Mega Man titles.
Among these, the first installment deserves special mention for retaining that essential leveling mechanic, which offered players a unique way to express their playstyle and improve their characters.
9 Mario’s Picross
Paint By Numbers
Mario’s Picross is a prime example of an undervalued franchise that excels in design yet never receives the acclaim it deserves, particularly when compared to titans like Tetris. This Game Boy exclusive remains largely overlooked despite its engaging gameplay that revolves around logic puzzles where Mario serves as a mascot rather than a focal point.
After investing countless hours in Picross, I can confidently state that this game endures as a classic, still enjoyable decades after its release.
8 Kingdom Hearts: Melody of Memory
Necessary For The Lore
The Kingdom Hearts series is notorious for its spinoffs being critical to understanding the overarching narrative. Melody of Memory stands out as a unique rhythm-based game that allows players to guide beloved characters through musical battles, providing not only entertainment but also essential lore leading into Kingdom Hearts 4.
Despite its solid mechanics and impressive soundtrack, this title hasn’t received the attention it deserves, remaining beneath the radar amidst fan discussions.
7 Shovel Knight Pocket Dungeon
A Puzzling Roguelite
Shovel Knight Pocket Dungeon combines puzzle mechanics, roguelite elements, and adventure gameplay into an engaging experience. Players engage in combat by matching enemy types to execute powerful attacks, all while managing their health points strategically.
The upbeat soundtrack composed by Jake Kaufman adds an energetic dimension to the gameplay, making it hard to set down. Unfortunately, despite receiving reasonable critical acclaim, some fans mistakenly viewed it as a lesser mobile game, undermining its actual quality.
6 Metroid Prime Pinball
Funny, but Not Bad
The concept of a pinball game set in the Metroid universe seems absurd, yet Metroid Prime Pinball successfully brings this idea to life. This game has often been overlooked because of its unconventional nature but proves to be one of the most entertaining pinball experiences available.
The game features engaging pinball physics, cleverly designed set pieces, and even includes the seldom-used DS Rumble Pak. Its distinctive atmosphere blends seamlessly with the series’ aesthetics, complemented by an outstanding soundtrack that enhances gameplay.
5 Dragon Quest Heroes: Rocket Slime
Let The Slime Rain
Rocket Slime offers an enchanting and imaginative take on the Dragon Quest series, featuring playful mechanics centered around exploration and interactive combat. Players navigate various environments, using their slime abilities to overcome obstacles and engage enemies in a whimsical manner.
The game’s engaging narrative and charming pixel art contribute to its appeal, yet it has largely remained under the radar since its exclusive launch on the DS, despite receiving favorable reviews from enthusiasts.
4 The Legend of Zelda: Cadence of Hyrule
Under The Radar
Nintendo’s decision to permit indie developers to innovate with their flagship franchises resulted in titles like Cadence of Hyrule. This rhythm-based roguelike is a captivating blend of music and gameplay elements from the Legend of Zelda series and Crypt of the Necrodancer.
Despite its commendable mechanics and fantastic soundtrack, the game has faded from conversation, which is perplexing considering its quality and the breadth of fun it provides, even for players without rhythm game experience.
3 Pokémon Rumble
Brawling Through Obscurity
Despite holding a Metascore of just 59, Pokémon Rumble is an entertaining brawler that lets players guide their favorite Pokémon through various gauntlets. Unlike typical beat ’em ups, it incorporates evolving mechanics that allow for stat changes and strategic customization.
This particular game, specifically from the WiiWare era, stands out positively, yet it has been overshadowed by the Pokémon franchise’s larger releases.
2 Sonic and the Black Knight
Dare To Fight
The Sonic franchise has long been rife with criticism, particularly during the late 2000s following the infamous Sonic 06. Among the spinoffs born during this tumultuous period, Sonic and the Black Knight caught significant backlash, often unfairly compared to its predecessor.
This game immerses players in a world inspired by the tales of King Arthur, enabling them to hack and slash through enemies, further enhanced by engaging upgrades and an appealing storyline.
1 Persona 4: Dancing All Night
Set It Free and Dance
As a final entry, Persona 4: Dancing All Night stands alone as an exceptional rhythm game—arguably the best in its category within the Persona series. It allows fans to reconnect with their beloved Persona 4 characters through a compelling storyline and enjoyable gameplay mechanics.
A vibrant soundtrack, rich character interactions, and quality production value make this spinoff feel like a natural extension of its source material. Unfortunately, obtaining this title today can be a hassle, as it requires either a Vita or investment in a collection of related games, making access difficult for new players.
Leave a Reply