The Game Awards serve as a fantastic conclusion to the gaming year, recognizing those titles that truly deserve acknowledgment while honoring the tireless efforts of developers behind the scenes. However, these prestigious accolades primarily spotlight major AAA games, with lesser focus on independent titles, which often remain in the shadows—unless an indie title remarkably asserts itself in the Game of the Year (GOTY) discussions.
In light of this, we’ve decided to reflect on past ceremonies and evaluate the games that have been nominated for the Best Independent Game Award. With the benefit of hindsight, we’ll explore which of these titles stand out as the truly deserving candidates throughout history.
10 Spirit Dangers
Learn To Let Go
Despite the presence of technically superior contenders, Spiritfarer secures its nomination through its enchanting Ghibli-inspired art and immersive, cozy gameplay. This unique narrative about guiding souls to the afterlife not only tugs at the heartstrings but also creates a gameplay loop that is free from stress and failure.
Sailing through the game’s world, players will enjoy forging connections with its charming characters while confronting the poignant moments of saying goodbye. This emotional depth is what makes Spiritfarer a memorable and essential experience.
9 Sea of Stars
Triggers Your Nostalgia
While countless indie and AAA JRPGs have attempted to recapture the magic of 1990s classics like Final Fantasy and Chrono Trigger, Sabotage Studios succeeded with Sea of Stars. This engaging adventure merges nostalgic mechanics with modern features, resulting in a fresh and captivating experience.
Vibrant visuals and an upbeat soundtrack complement accessible yet challenging gameplay. The lovable character Garl is a standout, embodying the sentimentality that players yearn for. Although The Messenger, another strong title from Sabotage, could easily earn a spot, Sea of Stars takes a slight edge.
8 Inscryption
A Deadly Deckbuilder
An ardent fan of deck-building games, I can confidently assert that Daniel Mullins’ Inscryption stands out as a genre-defying hybrid of psychological horror and card strategy. The game hooks players from the beginning, but it rewards those willing to delve deeper into its intricately crafted narrative.
With exceptional gameplay variety and an addictive deck-building experience, Inscryption is a haunting journey that all indie enthusiasts should experience. Kaycee’s Mod offers an additional way for players to enjoy the addictive deck-building aspects without the overarching narrative complexities.
7 Celeste
A Mountain To Climb
In a gaming landscape overflowing with 2D platformers, Celeste rises above the rest with its meticulous design and heartfelt narrative focused on mental health. This well-crafted game not only offers players a challenge but also fosters an active speedrunning community for those seeking the ultimate test of skill.
6 Return of the Obra Dinn
Get Your Sea Legs
Lucas Pope’s Return of the Obra Dinn impressively mixes detective work with a deeply engaging narrative. Players step into the role of an insurance investigator tasked with uncovering the fate of a lost ship’s crew, using a unique timepiece to explore pivotal moments from the past.
This puzzle-solving experience encourages critical thinking and offers rich rewards for players willing to engage deeply with its layered story. The more effort one puts in, the more fulfilling the payoff becomes.
5 Cuphead
Deceptively Cute
Cuphead masterfully juxtaposes adorable visuals and brutally tough gameplay, deceiving players with its charming aesthetics. While equipped with various tools to battle foes, players must face incredibly challenging bosses reminiscent of classic platforming eras.
This cooperative game experience allows players to share the delicious chaos with a friend, making it a perfect choice for those adventurous enough to face its demanding challenges together.
4 Stardew Valley
The Cozy Game Champ
No exploration of classic indie games would be complete without mentioning the beloved Stardew Valley, a farming simulator that has transitioned beyond its indie label. Drawing inspiration from Harvest Moon, this title continues to thrive, significantly enhanced by free updates since its original launch.
With its mix of familiarity and new mechanics, Stardew Valley has set a gold standard in its genre, significantly impacting indie game development. The creator, Eric Barone, is destined to be remembered as a cornerstone of the indie landscape until he reveals his next endeavor, The Haunted Chocolatier.
3 Outer Wilds
A Wild Ride
Outer Wilds astounds players with its imaginative exploration of a richly crafted solar system, complete with realistic physics and a captivating time-loop mechanic. Although Mobius Games faced challenges at launch, it ultimately delivered an immersive experience widely praised for its engaging puzzles and folk-inspired soundtrack.
Though the gameplay may require patience, the rewards for those who invest time are astonishing. The unspooling mystery invites deeper exploration and rewards curiosity in vibrant ways.
2 Hades
It’s Not A Phase, Dad!
The impact of Hades on the roguelike genre is hard to overstate; it transformed a niche style into a beloved format. This thrilling underworld journey introduces fresh plot points with each run, making even death feel like a new beginning.
The varied, addictive gameplay, gorgeous art style, and rich mythological themes contribute to an experience that is both refreshing and enduring. With the upcoming sequel, Hades 2, anticipation is high for it to build upon the solid groundwork laid by its predecessor.
1 Disco Elysium
Cop Of The Pops
While all nominees showcase excellence, Disco Elysium stands in a league of its own, delivering a transformative indie gaming experience. Set within the intricate world of Revachol, this CRPG centers around a gripping murder mystery abundant in lore and detail, encouraging multiple playthroughs for a full understanding.
Exceptional writing combines dark humor with political commentary and surreal moments, crafting a narrative that is as engaging as it is thought-provoking. With a distinctive visual style akin to classic art and a non-combat gameplay approach, Disco Elysium offers remarkable replayability through its complex branching paths.
In my view, it represents the pinnacle of indie gaming achievement, setting a high standard that future titles will strive to meet.
Leave a Reply