Contrary to what some may believe, Assassin’s Creed Shadows has achieved considerable success for Ubisoft, quickly becoming one of the series’ most popular offerings at its debut. While my personal experience with the game was mixed, as noted in my colleague Ethan Krieger’s review, I still found much to enjoy in this latest installment.
However, I won’t dwell on the aspects I found lacking today. Instead, I’m excited to present ten alternative games to Assassin’s Creed Shadows that are perfect for players looking for a break from their adventures in feudal Japan as Naoe and Yasuke. These titles share several similar elements with Shadows, and some have executed them even better. Join me as we explore each of these exciting options.
10. Immortals Fenyx Rising
An Underappreciated Gem
Immortals Fenyx Rising is a delightful surprise that often exceeds the quality of Ubisoft’s flagship titles. Developed by the same team behind Assassin’s Creed Odyssey, this game features an open-world design reminiscent of Breath of the Wild that encourages thorough exploration to uncover puzzles and hidden secrets.
However, it places some players at risk of burnout due to its expansive map and cartoonish graphics. Despite these factors, I recommend giving Fenyx Rising a chance, especially as its narrative and humor evoke a Pixar-like charm.
9. Trek to Yomi
Channel Your Inner Akira Kurosawa
Trek to Yomi stands out as a unique side-scrolling action-adventure title set in a similar feudal Japan backdrop as Assassin’s Creed Shadows. The cinematic storytelling here is exceptional, though the gameplay can feel somewhat clunky and repetitive.
If you’re a fan of Akira Kurosawa’s iconic samurai films, you’ll be captivated by the game’s striking black-and-white visuals. In fact, I noticed that the cinematic elements, especially during cutscenes, bear a strong resemblance to those found in Shadows, making it a perfect companion title to explore.
8. Dishonored
Stealth or Lethal Distinction, Call It
Dishonored is celebrated as a cult classic in the stealth genre. Created by Arkane Studios, it brilliantly allows players to choose between lethal and non-lethal approaches, much like the stealth mechanics at the core of the Assassin’s Creed franchise.
What I particularly appreciate is the freedom within the stealth gameplay and the intricate level designs that make for a rich gaming experience. For newcomers to the series, I recommend starting with the Definitive Edition of the first game, which lays a solid foundation for the sequels.
7. Aragami-2
For People Who Love Naoe’s Stealth
Transitioning to another exceptional stealth title, Aragami 2 shares similarities with Assassin’s Creed Shadows, particularly in its focus on stealth gameplay. While both Aragami games have their pros and cons, they stand out in the genre.
The titular character, Naoe, embodies a stealth style reminiscent of shinobi tactics. Unlike the first game, Aragami 2 incorporates more action gameplay, which may appeal to a broader audience, although some fans prefer the stealth-heavy approach of its predecessor.
What’s particularly notable about Aragami 2 is its cooperative multiplayer, allowing up to three players to tackle missions together, enhancing the enjoyment of the gameplay experience.
6. Red Dead Redemption 2
An Immaculate Open-World Design
Red Dead Redemption 2 expertly conveys the immersive feeling of exploring a vast open world, highlighted by engaging storytelling and environmental intricacies. In AC Shadows, I noticed a similarly dynamic world, complete with a rich weather system and organic NPC interactions.
While Shadows does not quite achieve the multifaceted world-building found in RDR2, both titles encourage players to delve into their environments and discover hidden secrets rather than rushing to fast travel.
Despite some debates around discovery in both games, Red Dead Redemption 2 is undeniably a valuable addition to any gaming collection, particularly for players who appreciate superior open-world design.
5. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
Question Markers Galore
The Witcher 3 is widely considered one of the greatest open-world RPGs ever created, featuring a robust narrative and immersive exploration. Both it and Assassin’s Creed Shadows share a common trait: an abundance of question markers scattered throughout the map, beckoning players to uncover secrets and side missions.
While I believe CD Projekt Red has harnessed this exploration mechanic more effectively, Ubisoft’s efforts should not be overlooked, as players can indeed find enjoyment—even if redundancy sometimes sets in with certain collectibles.
Furthermore, both games include dialogue choices that affect the story’s outcomes, enriching the overall experience. If you haven’t yet played The Witcher 3, it’s an essential title to explore alongside Shadows.
4. Rise of the Ronin
It’s Not As Bad As They Say
Rise of the Ronin deserves a mention for its compelling gameplay set against the backdrop of feudal Japan. Even with the mixed reviews it received at launch, many players will find depth and enjoyment beneath the surface.
If you appreciated the pacing and combat in Shadows, you’ll likely enjoy Ronin’s fighting mechanics, which are bolstered by Team Ninja’s renowned expertise with the Nioh series. However, keep in mind that the game’s world design could be seen as somewhat bland, and the graphics have received criticism for being outdated.
Nevertheless, Rise of the Ronin features challenging combat dynamics, a streamlined progression system, and an engaging character creation tool, making it a worthy contender for those who found merit in Shadows despite its flaws.
3. Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
Hesitation is Defeat
The Soulsborne franchise has garnered a dedicated following, and Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice remains a standout title that I believe deserves a sequel. Its combat is one of the finest, punishing yet rewarding, teaching players to adapt and improve through its demanding boss fights.
The shared feudal Japan setting establishes a natural connection between Sekiro and Shadows, catering to players in search of a greater challenge in combat. While stealth isn’t the main focus in Sekiro, it plays an important role, making it an excellent follow-up for those looking for a more intense experience.
2. Like a Dragon: They were!
Ryoma Sakamoto’s Bizarre Adventures
Like a Dragon: Ishin! from RGG Studios continues to impress with its captivating storytelling and exhilarating combat. Set during the tumultuous Bakumatsu era, players step into the shoes of Sakamoto Ryoma.
This spin-off of the Yakuza series stands out as a self-contained adventure, allowing players to enjoy the game without needing prior knowledge of the franchise. Its well-crafted narrative and engaging side quests ensure players remain immersed in the game world.
With numerous mini-games, karaoke sessions, and side stories to explore, Ishin offers a unique experience that rivals the mainline Yakuza titles while simultaneously enhancing the overall enjoyment of the game.
1. Ghost of Tsushima
The Originator
It may seem predictable to select Ghost of Tsushima as the top recommendation, yet it stands as the most comparable title to Assassin’s Creed Shadows. Both games take place in Japan and feature expansive worlds teeming with map markers and combat that may vary in appeal.
In numerous ways, I find Tsushima to excel over Shadows, not merely in gameplay but in its accurate historical portrayal. If you appreciate the stealthy nuances of Naoe and the brute strength of Yasuke, Jin Sakai’s dual combat styles—stealth and direct confrontation—will surely resonate with you.
Ultimately, both games have their unique merits as well as setbacks that may deter some players, which is entirely understandable. If you’ve completed Shadows but haven’t yet explored Tsushima, I whole-heartedly recommend diving into Ghost of Tsushima as it has laid the groundwork for many of the experiences found in Shadows.
Leave a Reply