Shifting Gears, the latest sitcom featuring Tim Allen, centers around a storyline that bears resemblance to another popular show’s return to the small screen. The series stars Allen as Matt and Kat Dennings as his estranged daughter, Riley, using their generational differences as a primary source of tension. This concept of navigating familial relationships across generations, especially through unavoidable cohabitation, has previously been explored in ongoing sitcoms.
Despite some notable distinctions, Shifting Gears shares thematic similarities with Lopez vs. Lopez, featuring comedian George Lopez. While Lopez has completed three successful seasons, the fate of Shifting Gears for a second season remains uncertain, leaving Tim Allen’s sitcom at risk of not establishing its distinctive voice. Fortunately, the show introduces a fresh angle that differentiates itself from its counterpart.
Similar Premises: Tim Allen’s Shifting Gears Mirrors Lopez vs. Lopez (But in Reverse)
Both Center on a Father-Daughter Dynamic in Adulthood
Much like Allen, George Lopez made his mark in the sitcom world with the eponymous George Lopez, a staple from the 2000s. Now, with Lopez vs. Lopez, he brings his real-life daughter into the mix, exploring the nuanced dynamics of their relationship as they navigate the challenges that come with moving in together. Lopez’s character relocates to his daughter’s place after facing financial hardship, highlighting a clash of views within their close-knit bond.
In contrast, Shifting Gears flips the narrative: Riley moves back in with her father, Matt, after a challenging divorce. This situation is further complicated as Riley also brings her two children, Carter (Maxwell Simkins) and Georgia (Barrett Margolis), leading to a rich tapestry of generational interactions and comedic potential across three distinct generations.
The Divisiveness of Tim Allen’s Shifting Gears
Targeting a Specific Audience
As the show unfolds, Shifting Gears has stirred debate, mainly due to Tim Allen’s dual role as both star and executive producer. Critics argue that the sitcom feels more like an extension of Allen’s previous successes like Home Improvement and Last Man Standing, with some perceiving Matt as merely a reincarnation of older characters instead of a fresh persona. Screen Rant aptly points out that the show “lives and dies with Allen,”despite its potential for wider appeal.
Crucially, it’s essential to keep in mind that only a couple of episodes have aired so far. While Shifting Gears currently grapples with originality concerns, the story has time to evolve—if the creators choose to diversify their approach. ABC’s new series must carve out a distinct identity beyond just appealing to Tim Allen’s fanbase. Without additional layers and complexities presented in future episodes, Shifting Gears risks becoming overshadowed by Lopez vs. Lopez rather than flourishing as its own entity.
Shifting Gears airs Wednesdays at 8 PM ET on ABC.
Leave a Reply ▼