The character evolution of Rhysand within Sarah J. Maas’s A Court of Thorns and Roses series has sparked significant debate among fans. Central to this discussion is the perception that Rhysand’s traumatic experiences, particularly those suffered Under the Mountain, are not as thoroughly explored as the traumas faced by the Archeron sisters. This disparity has led to various theories suggesting that Rhysand, despite his benevolent persona as the architect of Velaris and his imposing presence as the ruler of the Court of Nightmares, may harbor a darker nature beneath the surface.
Unpacking the “Evil Rhysand”Theory in A Court of Thorns & Roses
Compelling Elements of the “Evil Rhysand”Theory
Among the various “Evil Rhysand”theories discussed on platforms like Reddit, a common assertion is that Rhysand may not be as benevolent as he seems. While many fans admire his charisma and unwavering loyalty to Feyre, these theories argue that his sweetness is merely a façade masking a shrewd manipulator who wields power to orchestrate events in his favor. Thus, Rhysand’s supposed altruism could serve hidden motives.
Moreover, another prevailing theory suggests Rhysand might have an ulterior motive linked to his deep-rooted connections with the Night Court’s ancient history, possibly even aspiring to a more absolute authority. This interpretation raises questions about his cautious responses regarding his ambitions for the title of High King, particularly noted in A Court of Silver Flames. The subtlety of his backstory fuels speculation about the true nature of his intentions.
Some fans also speculate that the trauma Rhysand has endured has shaped his psyche, potentially leading to a latent darkness or an impulse for vengeance. This could manifest in acts of control, a readiness to sacrifice allies, or a tendency towards aggression. While these interpretations remain speculative, they enrich the narrative, prompting readers to reevaluate their views on Rhysand.
The Possibility of “Evil Rhysand”in the Original ACOTAR Trilogy
The Opportunity for a Plot Twist Has Passed
While introducing a villainous turn for Rhysand could enrich the plot of A Court of Thorns and Roses, Maas has already created a satisfying conclusion for Feyre and Rhys’s relationship following numerous challenges. If a darker arc were to be integrated, it would have necessitated careful groundwork laid throughout the original trilogy. Notably, despite Rhysand’s morally ambiguous behavior, he demonstrates a clear journey of redemption from the beginning of the series through to A Court of Mist and Fury, which is often hailed as a standout installment.
Reflecting on the series trajectory, Feyre emerges as an understanding High Lady amidst the tumultuous dynamics of her relationships. Her journey from being ensnared in Tamlin’s controlling kindness to achieving liberation could have set the stage for a more sinister narrative if mishandled. However, the series consistently portrays her in a positive light, making it improbable that her romance with Rhysand would culminate in an exploitative twist.
The Timing for a Rhysand Revelation Has Passed
Rhys and Feyre’s Journey Together
Introducing an unexpected twist regarding Rhysand’s character at this stage would likely undermine reader satisfaction. While conversations around issues like withheld information from Feyre and the opulence of the Night Court are notable, the foundation of Rhys and Feyre’s relationship is well-received by fans. The emotional investments made through their shared adversities enhance the appeal of this pairing.
Moreover, with their child now part of the narrative, a revelation of Rhysand’s treachery would severely complicate the emotional stakes. Such a turn would not only put into question the integrity of established relationships but also risk alienating readers who have followed their evolution.
Interestingly, Maas seems to be pivoting focus towards the characters within the Inner Circle, incorporating perspectives from Feyre’s sisters, Nesta and Elain, while simultaneously building up larger conflicts with other courts and the overarching threats facing Prythian. An abrupt pivot that instills doubt in well-established characters would detract from the carefully crafted narrative.
Future Possibilities for “Evil Rhysand”
The Role of Magical Artifacts in ACOTAR
For Rhysand to adopt an evil persona in upcoming books, it would likely need to stem from an external threat influencing his decisions. The ACOTAR series commonly explores the theme of power, especially regarding dangerous artifacts like Briallyn’s crown, which presents a substantial threat within A Court of Silver Flames. Such artifacts can wield immense power, and while characters like Cassian manage to resist such temptations, the potential for corruption remains ever-present.
In A Court of Silver Flames, Rhysand’s vulnerabilities emerge as he struggles with the dangers surrounding Feyre’s pregnancy. This struggle not only reveals his fierce protectiveness but also hints at a possible deviation from his character integrity under extreme circumstances. As the series progresses, it will be intriguing to observe how Rhysand’s familial commitments may influence his responses to external threats.
Source: Reddit
|
Book |
Release Date |
|---|---|
|
A Court of Thorns and Roses |
2015 |
|
A Court of Mist and Fury |
2016 |
|
A Court of Wings and Ruin |
2017 |
|
A Court of Frost and Starlight (novella) |
2018 |
|
A Court of Silver Flames |
2021 |
|
A Court of Thorns and Roses Book #6 |
TBC |
Leave a Reply