The Traitors US Season 3: A Disappointment Compared to Season 2’s Buzz and Excitement

WARNING: This article contains spoilers for the first three episodes of The Traitors US season 3!

The Traitors US Season 3: Can It Live Up to the Hype?

The Traitors season 3 has made its much-anticipated return to Peacock, following the outstanding success of its previous installment, which secured its place as the platform’s highest-rated reality show. With Alan Cumming at the helm, the latest season promises a mix of strategic gameplay and entertaining moments, showcasing a diverse array of reality stars. Yet, with the monumental achievement of season 2 still fresh in viewers’ minds, there are high expectations for how this season will unfold.

A Shift in Casting Dynamics

Familiar Faces, Less Intrigue

The first season effectively balanced an eclectic mix of reality stars and everyday contestants. The second season embraced a celebrity-only format, distancing itself from its UK counterpart, which often features non-celebrities. While this strategy paid off for the show, season 3’s cast has sparked disappointment among viewers. Many fans feel that the current crop lacks the compelling diversity of past seasons, leading to a sense of stagnation.

Notably, some players, such as Tom Sandoval from Vanderpump Rules, entered the game with preexisting animosity from the audience. However, he has yet to establish himself as a memorable antagonist. In contrast, season 2 thrilled viewers with a broader array of celebrity personalities, including boxer Deontay Wilder and former UK politician John Bercow, who brought uniqueness and intrigue to the competition.

Gameplay Dynamics: A Marked Decrease

Last Season’s Gameplay Was Superior

Tom looking shady with Alan Cumming from The Traitors — Custom image by César García

In season 2, players exhibited a higher level of risk-taking, a stark contrast to the current season’s more cautious approach. Early episodes revealed a hesitant cast unwilling to make bold moves, such as targeting Boston Rob Mariano when presented with the opportunity. This reluctance to engage competitively was surprisingly disappointing for many viewers hoping for intense gameplay.

A noticeable divide has emerged among the cast members regarding competition experience. Season 3 appears notably populated by participants lacking the necessary pedigree from reality competition shows. This lack of competitive spirit becomes all the more apparent when compared to the diverse backgrounds of season 2’s players, suggesting that introducing more seasoned competitors could enhance the level of strategic play.

A Glimmer of Hope for Season 3

Room for Growth

While the initial episodes of season 3 left something to be desired, the gameplay pace began to accelerate with the arrival of experienced players like Boston Rob, Wes Bergmann, and Derrick Levasseur. Their presence injected fresh energy into the competition, transforming the dynamics moving forward. These seasoned contestants, coming from shows like Survivor and The Challenge, are expected to bring a new level of excitement to the series.

As the series progresses, there’s hope that current players will adapt their style and enhance their approach to the game. While the charm of watching less experienced reality stars falter can be amusing, it does not replace the excitement that comes from well-executed strategic gameplay, which has been somewhat lacking this season. Fans anticipate that the contestants will soon embrace their competitive instincts, elevating the series overall.

The Traitors US releases new episodes every Thursday on Peacock.

Source & Images