The Strange Absence of This Character in Dexter: Original Sin Requires Explanation

Overview

The notable absence of Tom Matthews in Dexter: Original Sin has left fans scratching their heads, particularly given his critical connections to key figures in the original series.
Some theorize that Matthews’ character may still make an appearance as the prequel unfolds, potentially resolving unanswered questions from the original narrative.
There is speculation suggesting that the character’s absence is a narrative strategy designed to enhance suspense, which may lead to intriguing links with Harry Morgan in upcoming episodes.

Dexter: Original Sin has emerged as a major success on Paramount+ with Showtime, yet as we approach the final episodes, fans are increasingly perplexed by the lack of a beloved character—Tom Matthews.
Having played a pivotal role in the original series, Matthews is notably missing from this prequel series, leaving many wondering about the implications of his absence.

Tom Matthews was a central figure for Dexter and Debra Morgan, serving as a source of vital information about their late father, Harry.
It is curious, then, that with characters like Aaron Spencer and Bobby Watt appearing as Harry’s close friends, Matthews has yet to grace the screen in Original Sin.

The Puzzle of Matthews’ Absence

Dexter: Original Sin
Starring	Patrick Gibson, Christian Slater, Molly Brown, James Martinez, Christina Milian, Alex Shimizu, Reno Wilson, Patrick Dempsey, Joe Pantoliano, Sarah Michelle Gellar, Matthew William, with the voice of Michael C. Hall
Created by	Clyde Phillips
Directed By	Michael Lehmann

A popular fan theory proposes that Matthews harbors knowledge about Dexter’s “dark passenger.”
His interactions in the original series, such as his pushback against Maria LaGuerta’s theory that Dexter might be the Bay Harbor Butcher, underscore this notion.
Despite excitement over casting announcements for Dexter’s prequel, the absence of an actor playing Matthews has left many fans bewildered.
Interestingly, Matthew William has been cast in a recurring role as a Miami Metro police officer, showing a notable resemblance to a younger Geoff Pierson, the original Matthews actor.
Yet, his portrayal remains unconfirmed.

The Inevitable Introduction of Matthews

In Original Sin, Patrick Dempsey portrays Aaron Spencer, a character that Matthews may eventually usurp.
There is mounting speculation that Matthews will emerge later, potentially taking over Spencer’s duties following a significant plot twist.
This could happen as Spencer, alongside Bobby Watt, is currently positioned as a close associate of Harry Morgan, filling the void left by Matthews.

Despite Matthew’s lack of appearance thus far, many fans believe there remains ample opportunity for his introduction.
Dempsey’s contract reportedly covers only one season of Original Sin, which leaves room for the narrative to evolve—perhaps with Dempsey’s character facing significant peril as the storyline progresses.

Alternatively, there’s speculation that Matthews may not be as tightly linked with Harry Morgan as previously thought.
Given his political ambitions, one could postulate that he might have been involved in Harry’s tragic demise.
Matthews’ earlier misinformation regarding the circumstances of Harry’s death raises more questions: Could it be that Harry’s alleged suicide was misrepresented?
As viewers delve deeper into this prequel, they might uncover the multifaceted dynamics of these characters, leading to potential shocking revelations in future seasons.

Source & Images