The Staircase True Story: Duane Deaver’s Role as a Blood Spatter Analyst and His Current Whereabouts

The Staircase, produced by Max, has emerged as one of the most riveting true-crime limited series in recent memory. This gripping narrative chronicles the harrowing events surrounding the murder of Kathleen Peterson and the subsequent trial of her husband, Michael Peterson. As one of the most notorious murder cases of the last century, it has ignited widespread speculation and dialogue on the true nature of the crime. This series draws inspiration from the acclaimed 2004 documentary by Jean-Xavier de Lestrade, also named The Staircase, which documented Michael’s trial through the eyes of filmmakers.

The show is rich with unexpected revelations about the turbulent marriage of Michael and Kathleen. Among these, the involvement of blood spatter analyst Duane Deaver stands out as a particularly captivating aspect of the case. His contributions played a significant role in both the trial and the ensuing debate over the case’s many unanswered questions.

The True Story Behind Max’s The Staircase

The Accusation Against Kathleen Peterson’s Husband

Colin Firth as Michael Peterson in The Staircase

On December 9, 2001, a tragic discovery was made when Kathleen Peterson was found lifeless at the bottom of the staircase in her home. Michael Peterson, her husband, reported the incident to authorities, asserting that Kathleen had consumed alcohol and subsequently fallen. However, the police soon turned their attention towards Michael as a suspect due to the nature of Kathleen’s injuries and the blood evidence collected at the scene.

As the trial unfolded, startling details about Michael’s life came to light, including previous infidelities and financial troubles. Perhaps the most damning evidence was the revelation that a close friend of Michael’s had met a similar end next to a staircase years before. Despite the defense’s claims that Kathleen’s death was an unfortunate accident, the jury convicted Michael of murder, leading to a life sentence.

Duane Deaver’s Critical Testimony

Expert Insight from Blood Spatter Analysis

Duane Deaver testifying in The Staircase

Duane Deaver served as a blood spatter analyst for the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation (SBI) and emerged as a pivotal witness for the prosecution during Michael Peterson’s trial. Leveraging his expertise, Deaver asserted that the blood evidence corroborated a violent attack rather than a simple fall.

In the dramatization featured in the Max series, Deaver, portrayed by Myke Holmes, experiments to recreate the scene by striking mannequins in an effort to illustrate his theory of the crime. He argued that the presence of a “circular blood pattern” suggested Kathleen had been struck with a heavy object, a testament that profoundly influenced the jury’s eventual decision.

Controversy Surrounding Deaver’s Testimony

Allegations of Misconduct

Myke Homes as Duane Deaver looking serious in The Staircase

In 2010, it was brought to light that Duane Deaver had misrepresented his qualifications in court. Deaver had claimed extensive experience and proficiency that was ultimately unveiled as misleading. This pattern of deception encompassed previous cases, including the wrongful conviction of Greg Taylor, who spent 17 years imprisoned due to Deaver’s inaccurate testimony (source: Newsweek).

Following these revelations, Michael Peterson was granted a new trial in 2011, leading to his subsequent release from prison under house arrest. He later accepted an Alford plea, allowing him to maintain his innocence while admitting that the state had sufficient evidence for a conviction. Ultimately, he was sentenced to 86 months but had already served the equivalent time.

Deaver’s Response to Termination

Deaver’s Legal Struggles and Current Position

Duane Deaver giving an interview in The Staircase

After his dismissal from the SBI, Deaver contested his termination vigorously but was not successful in regaining his previous role. Nevertheless, in 2014, he was awarded 34 months back pay when a commission determined that his sanctions should have involved demotion instead of outright termination. However, the commission upheld the decision to fire him as justified due to the perjury ruling in the Peterson case. As of 2022, Duane Deaver continues to work in the criminal justice field as the Director of Operations at an ISS facility in Texas.

Source & Images