The Reason Samwise Gamgee Journeyed to the Undying Lands Post The Lord of the Rings

In the aftermath of The Lord of the Rings, Samwise Gamgee embarks on a poignant journey to the Undying Lands alongside his dear friend Frodo. This moment, particularly memorable from the film The Return of the King, has resonated deeply with fans, leaving an emotional imprint through its heartfelt farewell scene. While both the literary and cinematic portrayals evoke profound sadness, J. R.R. Tolkien’s novels offer deeper insights that enrich this bittersweet conclusion: Sam’s eventual departure from Middle-earth to join Frodo across the sea.

The Undying Lands, also known as Valinor, lie across the ocean from Middle-earth. Despite the implications of its name, the inhabitants of this realm are not granted immortality. The term refers to its exclusive residency of immortal beings, suggesting a land of eternal perfection, in stark contrast to Middle-earth, which continuously evolves through the cycles of life. Although it may seem unconventional for a mortal like Frodo to be received in this esteemed realm, his status as a Ring-bearer, burdened by the trauma of possessing the One Ring, grants him this rare opportunity.

The Significance of Samwise Gamgee’s Journey to the Undying Lands

Sam as a Ring-Bearer: A Technicality

Samwise Gamgee in The Fellowship of the Ring

While Samwise Gamgee may not have borne the One Ring for as extended a period as Frodo or Bilbo, he did indeed possess it temporarily following Shelob’s attack on Frodo. This critical moment occurs at the conclusion of The Two Towers and carries over into The Return of the King, though cinematic adaptations by Peter Jackson merge these events into the final installment. Sam’s brief tenure as a Ring-bearer qualifies him for the same privilege that Frodo receives, despite Frodo still being alive during that timeframe.

Ultimately, after the saga concludes, Sam returns to the Shire, settling down with Rosie Cotton. Tolkien’s Appendices in The Return of the King shed light on what follows. They reveal that Sam eventually sails to the Grey Havens to reunite with Frodo after the passing of his beloved Rosie in the year 61 of the Fourth Age. The story’s recounting through the lens of his daughter, Elanor, leaves some ambiguity about whether Sam and Frodo truly managed to reunite in Valinor.

It is important to note that the Red Book serves as a significant artifact within Tolkien’s universe, chronicling the tales of The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings as penned by Bilbo and Frodo.

Sam’s Journey: Life in the Shire Before the Undying Lands

Sam’s Healing Journey vs. Frodo’s Need for Valinor

Samwise Gamgee's Wedding to Rosie Cotton

Despite the eventual shared fate of Sam and Frodo in Valinor, their paths diverged significantly in the aftermath of the War of the Ring. Frodo, burdened by the scars of his experiences as a Ring-bearer, felt compelled to leave Middle-earth for healing. In stark contrast, Sam returned to the Shire where he established a fulfilling life, marrying Rosie, raising children, and serving as Mayor for many years before embarking on his journey to reunite with Frodo.

While the Undying Lands welcomed Sam due to his status as a Ring-bearer, he did not require its healing powers in the same manner Frodo did. Instead, he found solace and a sense of closure in the familiar comforts of home, before ultimately answering the call to join his friend across the sea.

Source & Images