TeamFourStar, the creators behind the beloved fan parody Dragon Ball Z Abridged, have cultivated a committed fanbase while inadvertently sparking newfound interest in the original series. However, this parody has also led to significant setbacks within the Dragon Ball community. A faction of fans has emerged that argues Dragon Ball Z Abridged surpasses the original work of creator Akira Toriyama and the diligent efforts of voice actors Sean Schemmel and Christopher Sabat, who played pivotal roles in localizing the series for North American audiences.
This divide has not only separated fans into camps of traditionalists and Abridged enthusiasts, but it has also strained relationships between the audience and the creators, including Funimation and the original voice actors. Rather than focus on comparison, Abridged should be appreciated as a unique extension of the franchise. Unfortunately, it has led to increased alienation among fans and created friction between them and the industry professionals who contributed to the beloved series.
Recognizing the Distinct Nature of Both Series
Distinct Genres, Tones, and Hindsight
While Dragon Ball initially started as a comedic tale, its sequel, Dragon Ball Z, evolved into a more serious action-focused series infused with humor. According to Oxford Languages, parody comes from “an imitation of the style of a particular writer, artist, or genre with deliberate exaggeration for comic effect.” This holds true for Abridged, which leans heavily on comedic elements while highlighting the serious stakes that permeate Dragon Ball Z. Although Abridged maintains a comedic emphasis, it often reflects the core themes of the original series.
The original Dragon Ball series allowed for creative improvements based on its own shortcomings, leading to iconic arcs like the Red Ribbon Army. In contrast, Dragon Ball Z Abridged comments directly on fan grievances concerning the original series while crafting its own narrative callbacks. This reliance on hindsight allows Abridged to resonate with viewers but also necessitates familiarity with the original to be fully appreciated.
Impact of Comparisons on Fan Perception
Industry Perception of the Fandom
Watch Here
My intention isn’t to chastise fans who resonate more with Dragon Ball Z Abridged than the original series; such preferences are valid. However, it’s essential to acknowledge that Abridged serves as an homage rather than a replacement for Toriyama’s work. This interplay between the two shows has altered how the community perceives the Dragon Ball narrative and its inherent value.
Moreover, this disconnect has spread to the creators, including Toei Animation and Funimation. Voice actors like Schemmel often express exasperation at the fervent preferences displayed by fans, which in turn can exacerbate tensions within the community. Such dynamics complicate the relationship between audiences and creators, revealing a landscape where passion occasionally manifests as conflict.
Finding a Path Forward Amidst Tension
Collaborative Solutions for All Involved
Both fans and companies must acknowledge the complexities of their relationships. TeamFourStar has historically walked a fine line with their parody, particularly as some later episodes veered closer to straightforward retellings of Dragon Ball Z. This not only risks confusing viewers but also detracts from the original series’ revenue. Such complexities create legitimate concerns for intellectual property rights holders.
Fans, in their enthusiasm, have sometimes overstepped boundaries, leading to instances of harassment and toxicity within the community. In this climate, Schemmel could benefit from adopting a more accommodating stance, promoting a culture of respect and acceptance similar to that exemplified by his colleague Sabat. Meanwhile, industry players like Toei and Funimation should strive to engage positively with their audience rather than viewing them purely as profit sources.
The ongoing challenges facing the Dragon Ball franchise underscore the need for a collaborative relationship between fans and creators. While Dragon Ball Z Abridged remains a significant cultural artifact within the anime landscape, it is paramount to appreciate it as a genuine homage to the original series, rather than a rival interpretation. With the conclusion of Abridged, a fresh perspective could help mend divisions and foster a healthier fandom that celebrates all iterations of Dragon Ball.
Leave a Reply