The Fate of Sony’s Spider-Man Universe: Why It Was Predestined for Failure

The future of Sony’s Spider-Man Universe (SSU) appears increasingly grim as its latest offering, Kraven the Hunter, faces a wave of negative reviews and disappointing box office performance. Since the SSU’s promising inception with Venom, fans are left to question what went wrong in the evolution of this once-enthusiastic cinematic endeavor.

The Rise and Fall of the SSU

Initially, Kraven the Hunter was promoted as a significant milestone, notably being the first R-rated film within the SSU. However, while the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) enjoyed monumental success with Deadpool and Logan, which shattered records as the highest-grossing R-rated films, Kraven succumbed to a dismal opening weekend, grossing as little as $11 million. With previous titles under the SSU umbrella—including three Venom installments, Morbius, and Madame Web—there are now indications that Sony is putting a halt to any upcoming projects.

Internal Conflicts and Canonical Confusions

The SSU has encountered persistent challenges since its inception, notably highlighted by issues surrounding its canon. Following Topher Grace’s portrayal of Venom in Spider-Man 3, anticipation grew for Tom Hardy’s darker rendition of the character. Many believed that, with the MCU cautiously navigating R-rated narratives, the SSU had the opportunity to carve out its own niche. Nevertheless, only Kraven managed to secure that R rating.

Complicating matters further, confusion ensued regarding the SSU’s place in the broader Marvel landscape. Discussions between Sony’s Amy Pascal and Marvel’s Kevin Feige regarding Spider-Man’s rights led to uncertainty about Holland’s connection to the SSU. Speculation swirled in 2019 about the potential exclusion of Holland’s Spider-Man from the MCU, amid concerns over title rights. Nonetheless, with a treasure trove of Spider-Man villains contributing to a growing set of ‘Venomverse’ films, the SSU seemed poised for success.

Unfortunately, the SSU’s films have often lingered in the shadow of the hope that Holland would eventually make an appearance, a prospect that never materialized. Even prior to Venom (2018), rumors circulated about a potential cameo of Holland, with claims suggesting that a scene was filmed but ultimately cut by Marvel Studios. Each successive Venom release further dashed expectations of a crossover, leaving audiences disheartened.

Commercial Struggles and Box Office Woes

Despite a few successes, including Venom‘s global earnings of $856 million against a budget of approximately $116 million, subsequent entries struggled to replicate its box office triumphs. For instance, Madame Web only managed to rake in $100.5 million on a production budget of $80 million, reflecting a tight profit margin. More troubling is the fact that no SSU film has ever garnered a positive score on Rotten Tomatoes, leaving critics and audiences unimpressed.

Kraven the Hunter endured multiple delays and was mired in controversy, which many believe contributes to its status as a potential terminus for the SSU.

Kraven the Hunter: The Nail in the Coffin for the SSU?

As it stands, industry reports suggest the SSU may be effectively defunct following the underwhelming response to Kraven. Not only did the film lack compelling post-credit scenes or any meaningful tie-ins to the larger Marvel universe, but a Sony insider revealed:

“The biggest issue with the Sony Spider-Man spinoffs seems to be the lack of quality control. The movies just aren’t good. Sometimes that lack of quality meets a movie no one asked for, which was the case with ‘Madame Web,’ and that is a no-win scenario. It may be time for Sony to start cultivating different IP to launch new franchises.”

In response to recent setbacks, Sony appears poised to redirect focus towards several promising projects, such as Daniel Destin Cretton’s Spider-Man 4, the long-awaited Beyond the Spider-Verse, and a live-action adaptation of Spider-Man Noir, featuring Nicolas Cage.

Unresolved Narratives and the Legacy of the SSU

Meanwhile, the status of films like the Donald Glover-led Hypno-Hustler remains stagnant, particularly after Bad Bunny’s exit from El Muerto. Additionally, the much-anticipated Sinister Six project appears increasingly unlikely, intersecting with unresolved plot threads from previous films. For instance, Michael Keaton’s Vulture character from Spider-Man: Homecoming appears lost in the same narrative space as Jared Leto’s Morbius.

In stark contrast to the MCU’s meticulously crafted shared universe, which blossomed through an interconnected series of films culminating in The Avengers, the SSU struggled with coherence. Often, these franchises felt disjointed, lacking a unifying thread among them. Thus far, there have been no conclusive steps toward incorporating aspects of the SSU into Spider-Man 4, as Sony may seek to protect the integrity of Holland’s portrayal.

Tom Hardy has expressed a desire to confront Holland within the MCU, which could pave the way for Venom’s future involvement in significant events like Avengers: Secret Wars. For now, the SSU faces scrutiny for misallocation of resources and audience engagement. The failures of the SSU reflect broader challenges, mirroring the historical struggles encountered by other cinematic universes such as Universal’s Dark Universe and Warner Bros.’ DCEU. As the debate over which Spider-Man might align with the SSU lingers, it begs the question: can a Spider-Man universe truly thrive without the character himself?

Source & Images