The Cost of Embracing Comic Book Continuity in Marvel’s Multiverse

Essential Highlights

The MCU is exploring the multiverse concept, enabling fresh narratives beyond a unified continuity.
Marvel is leveraging its comic book heritage, reviving deceased characters in innovative forms.
The potential return of Robert Downey Jr. as Doctor Doom raises concerns about undermining the emotional weight of Tony Stark’s ultimate sacrifice.

In the wake of Avengers: Endgame, the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) has increasingly diverged from its original consolidated storyline. This pivot toward embracing the multiverse gained momentum with the release of Loki in 2021, which introduced the Time Variance Authority and the concept of timeline variants. The trend intensified with Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness in 2022, signaling a firm commitment to exploring limitless realities as the MCU prepares for its phases five and six, and beyond.

This strategic change offers a wealth of creative freedom, allowing Marvel to navigate a landscape rich with potential storylines unbound by a single continuity. Such an approach opens the door for fresh ideas, revitalizing a franchise that has faced challenges in maintaining its past successes. Additionally, this multiverse concept facilitates the revival of characters previously thought to be lost, whether through alternate realities or time travel. However, while beneficial for future developments and actor compensation, this shift poses significant challenges for narrative depth and gravitas.

Drawing Inspiration from Comic Book Traditions

Peter Quill (Chris Pratt) and Gamora (Zoe Saldaña) in Guardians of the Galaxy vol. 3 — Image Source: Disney

This fluidity in story continuity mirrors long-standing practices in the comic book world, where creators often embark on profound transformations, rebooting franchises, and creating independent narratives. High-stakes character deaths, followed by their unexpected returns in new renditions, have been a hallmark of comic storytelling. With its multiverse strategy, Marvel aims to meld this impactful storytelling approach with beloved characters and narratives instilled in audiences over the years. While Hollywood has long pursued reboots, Marvel’s innovative approach of reintegrating character re-imaginations within an ongoing narrative sets it apart.

Marvel Studios dominated the box office landscape during its initial three phases, showcasing extravagant cinematic experiences while building a compelling shared universe. This success was not solely rooted in spectacle; the studio’s commitment to developing its characters infused the franchise with emotional depth and authenticity. Viewers returned repeatedly, drawn not just by thrilling action sequences and CGI marvels, but by their emotional investment in the characters’ journeys. Deaths of beloved characters resonated profoundly within this context, carrying significant weight and consequences.

For instance, Vision’s (Paul Bettany) demise at Thanos’s hands in Avengers: Infinity War was unique, as he could not be resurrected through time travel in Endgame. The heartfelt pain felt by Wanda Maximoff (Elizabeth Olsen) after losing him culminated in a deeply emotional narrative arc within WandaVision, which still stands as one of the MCU’s most poignant moments. Similarly, Gamora’s (Zoe Saldaña) sacrifice by Thanos in pursuit of an Infinity Stone carried monumental significance, further emphasizing her unwavering character arc.

However, the emergence of a variant Gamora in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 raises crucial questions about narrative integrity. Writer/director James Gunn skillfully navigates this new dynamic, as the alternate Gamora lacks familiarity with Peter Quill (Chris Pratt), creating an intriguing conflict. Nevertheless, introducing this variant diminishes, to some extent, the emotional devastation spawned by her original death and its implications for Peter and the Guardians.

Concerns Regarding Robert Downey Jr.’s Comeback

Even more disconcerting is the revelation that Robert Downey Jr. will reprise his role as Doctor Doom in the upcoming Avengers: Doomsday. Though details remain sparse, speculation abounds regarding whether this incarnation could be a variant of Tony Stark. If confirmed, such a narrative direction might seriously undermine the emotional impact of Stark’s death at the conclusion of Endgame.

The sacrifice of Tony Stark stands as a defining hallmark of the MCU, representing a decade-long character evolution—from a self-absorbed billionaire to a selfless hero. His decision to save the universe, at the ultimate cost of his own life, provided a heartfelt resolution that resonated through subsequent narratives. Regardless of whether Downey’s reprise as Doom stems from Stark’s legacy, the very act of his return threatens to dilute the gravity and permanence of Stark’s final moments.

Interestingly, it’s plausible that many audience members may overlook these concerns, finding excitement in witnessing their cherished characters’ returns. The multiverse concept holds promise for rejuvenating a franchise that has faced creative hurdles, enabling filmmakers to explore expansive storytelling possibilities. Innovations such as the forthcoming Fantastic Four: First Steps indicating a retro-futuristic approach point to this evolution. Nevertheless, for a franchise that has consistently excelled at conveying profound emotional experiences, the rapid dismissal of impactful moments through timeline shifts is undeniably disheartening.

Source & Images