The Connection Between Bailey Sharp and Justin Hilbert’s Murder: Key Details Ahead of NBC’s Dateline

Bailey Sharp was viciously stabbed multiple times on July 12, 2016, by her boyfriend, Jared Bischoff, resulting in her tragic death. This brutal method of killing is eerily similar to the murder of Justin Hilbert, who was found dead on June 21, 2016, after experiencing multiple stab wounds, gunshot injuries, and blunt force trauma.

At the time of Justin Hilbert’s murder, his fiancée was Tonya Bischoff, the ex-wife of Jared Bischoff, creating a tangled web of relationships among the victims and their partners.

The upcoming Dateline season 33, episode 2, titled “Wrong Turns,”will explore these interconnected tragedies and shed light on one unresolved homicide. The episode is set to air on October 4, 2024, at 9 pm EST on NBC and will be available for streaming on Peacock the following day. It features interviews with the victims’ loved ones, offering deeper insights into the circumstances surrounding the homicides. According to NBC’s official synopsis,

“A new father is found dead on the side of a road. Then the shocking stabbing of a young woman in broad daylight leads police on a high-speed chase. Investigators wonder: are these two chilling murders connected?”

Brutal Attack on Bailey Sharp by Jared Bischoff

Bailey Sharp was horrifically found lying in a pool of blood on July 12, 2016, having sustained six stab wounds. Although first responders rushed her to the hospital, the severity of her injuries led to her death due to significant blood loss.

Following a dramatic car chase from San Diego to Riverside, the police apprehended Jared Bischoff, who faced charges related to Bailey’s murder as well as other allegations. Initially, Jared did not plead guilty; however, a search of his residence uncovered 22 knives and shotgun shells, further implicating him in the crime.

Text messages between Bailey and Jared revealed a troubling dynamic, suggesting that their relationship was fraught with difficulties. Ultimately, Jared was sentenced to life in prison without parole for Bailey Sharp’s murder.

Justin Hilbert’s Gruesome Murder

According to CBS reports, Justin Hilbert was brutally murdered on June 21, 2016. His death was marked by multiple stab wounds, gunshot injuries, and beatings. To date, the identity of Justin’s killer remains a mystery.

Despite extensive investigations, no forensic evidence was retrieved from the scene, leaving the case unresolved. However, authorities began to scrutinize Tonya Bischoff, Justin’s fiancée, after discovering that her ex-husband, Jared Bischoff, had been arrested for Bailey Sharp’s murder shortly after Justin’s death. Previously collected evidence, including knives and shotgun shells from Jared’s home, raised suspicions.

When CBS approached Tonya with inquiries regarding Jared’s potential involvement in Justin’s murder, she remarked,

“It does raise some questions and red flags. But at this time, the police have told us that there’s no connection.”

Reports suggest that Jared had a history of violent behavior, which led to Tonya ending their relationship. Heartbroken by the impact of the murder, Tonya expressed to CBS,

“Everybody loved him (Justin). I can’t imagine who would have so much hatred to do something like that. It’s heartbreaking. He’s only six months old. He’s never going to know his father. I want answers. I want to know who could have done this…”

For further details on this alarming case, tune into Dateline season 33, episode 2, airing on October 4, 2024, and streaming on Peacock the following day.

Source