The Bachelor: Jonathon Johnson’s Recent Remarks on Grant Ellis Suggest Producers Made the Right Choice for Lead (Is Jealousy Involved?)

Jonathan Johnson, a former contestant on The Bachelorette, has recently expressed his critical views on the casting decisions of The Bachelor. He suggests that perhaps Grant Ellis was indeed the right choice for the franchise’s next lead. Jonathan was among 25 men competing for the affection of the season’s leading lady, Jenn Tran. Despite forming a strong connection, he was eliminated in week 8 of the show. As a fan favorite, many anticipated Jonathan’s return in the role of lead for The Bachelor’s upcoming season 29. However, when Grant was announced shortly after Jonathan’s exit in week 6, audiences turned to Jonathan for his insights.

Though Jonathan faced disappointment from both Jenn and the franchise, his journey within The Bachelor is far from over. He has been invited to join the cast of Bachelor In Paradise season 10, providing him another opportunity to seek love against a picturesque backdrop. Nonetheless, Jonathan has not shied away from sharing his frustrations regarding the franchise’s casting process. His criticism suggests that the producers’ decision to bring Grant back may have been a beneficial move for the show.

Jonathan Revealed He Wasn’t Asked to Be The Bachelor

Jonathan Was Never Offered The Position

In a candid discussion with Joe Vulpis on the Lightweights podcast, Jonathan candidly addressed his discontent over the casting approach used by The Bachelor. When asked about any possible offers to take on the lead role, he stated, “No. Not a mention, not an ask, not a ‘Hey, we’d love to just like sit you down for a conversation.’ Not once.” This sentiment illustrates Jonathan’s disappointment as a well-known figure within the franchise and a third runner-up. The producers’ lack of communication regarding his exclusion is understandably frustrating, especially considering that Grant’s appointment as lead appeared to be decided prior to Jonathan’s elimination.

Notably, Grant Ellis was the first contestant in the franchise’s history to be announced as the lead immediately after his exit.

This proactive approach by the producers to announce Grant as the next lead turned out to be wise. By revealing the upcoming lead ahead of time, they mitigated significant issues associated with past casting processes, where leads were often chosen after contestants had been cast. This change has reduced unnecessary drama and streamlined the show’s production.

This casting dilemma was highlighted during Jenn Tran’s season of The Bachelorette when contestant Sam McKinney candidly expressed his surprise upon finding Jenn rather than his expected choices, Daisy Kent or Maria Georgas. He remarked, “This girl is not my type. I thought the Bachelorette was gonna be Daisy or Maria, ” drawing criticism while also illuminating ongoing casting issues.

It remains unclear whether Grant was favored due to his earlier elimination, allowing producers more time for applications, or because of his relatable demeanor. However, one thing seems clear: Jonathan’s critiques of the franchise’s casting decisions may hinder his own chances of being selected as a lead. In contrast, Grant’s charm, authenticity, and appealing looks made him an undoubtedly strong choice. With Grant now attracting an enthusiastic fanbase, the producers likely feel confident in their decision.

Jonathan Doesn’t Understand Why Grant Is The Lead

Jonathan Jokes About His Appearance

The Bachelorette's Jenn Tran and Jonathon Johnson smile at each other. — Custom image by César García

On the podcast, Vulpis posed the question of why Grant was selected as the lead instead of Jonathan. In a light-hearted manner, Jonathan quipped, “I have no idea. But I always make the joke it’s ’cause he’s over 6 foot, and I’m 5’11.” While this comment carries comedic undertones, it also reveals a hint of envy. As writer Shelby Van Pelt insightfully noted, “Humans are the only species who subvert truth for their own entertainment. They call them jokes.”

Jonathan’s humor has made him a beloved contestant, especially noted for his memorable introduction where he arrived on a stretcher, clad in a hospital gown and bandages. His quip about Grant’s height was not meant to offend but did prompt some fans to reflect on whether the franchise prioritizes physical appeal in their leads. It is worth mentioning that Grant has not publicly criticized the show.

Producers Made The Right Choice Picking Grant

Should Jonathan Be Invited Back?

There’s no doubt that Jonathan is a remarkable contestant who would have thrived as a franchise lead. There is still a possibility of his return in that capacity, as the show has a history of reusing contestants for successive seasons. Nonetheless, the decision to cast Grant may have been the most profitable for the franchise.

Grant possesses a genuine personality, expressing a heartfelt desire to find love. He consistently reassures both contestants and viewers that he is invested in the quest for true companionship and is eager to start a family. In a heartfelt Instagram post, he mentioned, “I just want to raise my family, and feel that love.” This earnest journey is likely to attract a significant audience.

While Jonathan certainly possesses the qualities to be an excellent lead, Grant has clearly emerged as the front-runner. His season of The Bachelor is poised for success. Fans remain hopeful that Jonathan will soon have the opportunity to headline a season, as his relatable charm deserves as much recognition as Grant’s.

The Bachelor airs Mondays at 8 p.m. EST on ABC.

Sources: Grant Ellis/Instagram, Lightweights/YouTube

Source&Images