The 10 Most Underrated Doctor Who Episodes in History

Among the numerous unforgettable episodes of Doctor Who, a number of stories remain overlooked and do not receive the appreciation they deserve. The most renowned Doctor Who narratives are characterized by their memorable adversaries, engaging storylines, and exceptional characters. Yet, there are also numerous tales from both the classic and the contemporary eras that boast these same qualities but have failed to capture the audience’s attention for a myriad of reasons.

The post-2005 reboot of Doctor Who tends to resonate more vividly with audiences today, although the classic era holds a plethora of stories ripe for exploration. Each Doctor has featured episodes or serials that didn’t quite hit the mark with fans, but that doesn’t indicate they lack merit. It’s crucial to recognize that these underrated Doctor Who tales are both charming and captivating, and many viewers may simply be unaware of their hidden gems.

10 “Invasion of the Dinosaurs”

Classic Era – Third Doctor – Season 11, Serial 2

Often criticized for its subpar visual effects, particularly concerning the dinosaurs, “Invasion of the Dinosaurs” dates back to the 1970s. While its aesthetic quality may falter by today’s standards, the narrative itself is quite compelling. This serial ranks as the most underrated adventure of the Third Doctor because it tackles the complexities of historical alteration.

With unexpected betrayals from the Doctor’s UNIT allies, the story provides a unique twist in its plot. The exploration of an Earth invasion that doesn’t revolve around an alien threat adds depth to the story. Additionally, the whimsical image of the Third Doctor maneuvering in the Whomobile adds a comical touch, while Sarah Jane showcases resilience and intellect that are crucial in overcoming the challenges they face.

9 “Paradise Towers”

Classic Era – Seventh Doctor – Season 24, Serial 2

“Paradise Towers” often faces disdain mainly due to the overall perception of Season 24 being subpar, yet it shines as a brilliant element of this era. The strange setting successfully conveys the eerie atmosphere central to its story. Beginning with Mel’s innocent desire to swim, it quickly evolves into a thrilling mystery involving the enigmatic caretakers.

The characters are well-developed, and the villain Kroagnon exemplifies the evil architect trope commonly found in science fiction. While some parts may seem overly cheesy, the darker undertones, particularly the cannibalistic elements, create an engaging contrast. Though “Paradise Towers” might not have received widespread acclaim during its original airing, it possesses qualities that would make it a standout if recreated in the modern series.

8 “Boom Town”

Modern Era – Ninth Doctor – Season 1, Episode 11

“Boom Town” stands out as an underrated triumph penned by Russell T Davies. This Season 1 episode functions seamlessly as a standalone adventure, allowing viewers to easily grasp the plot, which centers around the Ninth Doctor’s unexpected reunion with Margaret the Slitheen. This episode marks a significant moment in developing Rose’s relationship with Mickey while establishing the Cardiff Space-Time Rift.

While some might argue it lacks contribution to the broader season arc, its emotional weight is undeniable. The Ninth Doctor’s moral struggle regarding Margaret is compelling, and the cleverly crafted dialogue, along with humorous interludes, elevates the episode’s appeal. Furthermore, the events depicted are pivotal for framing Team TARDIS’s clashes with future adversaries, showcasing the enduring impact of such a seemingly simple story.

7 “Gridlock”

Modern Era – Tenth Doctor – Season 3, Episode 3

“Gridlock” revisits the earlier setting of New New York, transformed in a significant way. The Tenth Doctor’s reflections on his past actions serve as a backdrop for saving Martha amidst modern civilization’s collapse. Returning to classic foes, the redesigned Macra add a new level of tension to the narrative.

By blending elements of suspense with social commentary on traffic jams, “Gridlock” manages to challenge expectations. Additionally, it represents a notable turning point for the Tenth Doctor as he opens up about his past, marking a significant emotional development in his character journey.

6 “42”

Modern Era – Tenth Doctor – Season 3, Episode 7

In “42,” we see the Tenth Doctor at one of his most vulnerable points as the threat of a sun-based villain looms. This episode emphasizes Martha’s growth as a vital companion, forcing her to protect the Doctor in a high-stakes environment. The relentless race against time amplifies the overall intensity of the narrative.

The dynamics between crew members bring a human element to the story, enhancing the emotional stakes. This episode not only marks Martha’s official debut as a companion but also illustrates the evolving relationship between the Doctor and his companions, showcasing their interdependence in times of crisis.

5 “The Unicorn And The Wasp”

Modern Era – Tenth Doctor – Season 4, Episode 7

Featuring the legendary writer Agatha Christie as a guest character, “The Unicorn and the Wasp” is a clever blend of historical intrigue and science fiction. Unlike mere cameo appearances, Christie is deeply integrated into the plot, turning the episode into an engaging murder mystery. The alien antagonist adds an interesting sci-fi twist to the classic whodunit genre.

This episode also strengthens the bonds between the Tenth Doctor and Donna, with comedic moments, such as Donna’s attempts to save the Doctor, providing both humor and warmth. As Christie’s story unfolds, it reveals the significance of her contributions to literature, paralleling the larger themes often explored within Doctor Who.

4 “A Town Called Mercy”

Modern Era – Eleventh Doctor – Season 7, Episode 3

In “A Town Called Mercy,” the Eleventh Doctor explores an unconventional narrative style portrayed in a Western context. This episode exhibits a darker aspect of the Doctor, showcasing intense character development amidst humorous moments that lighten the otherwise grave tone of the story.

The enigmatic Gunslinger serves as a pivotal adversary, challenging the Doctor’s moral compass considering his connection to the Time War. The combination of serious themes and comedic sequences makes this episode a nuanced addition to the Doctor Who series, blending genres effectively.

3 “The Power Of Three”

Modern Era – Eleventh Doctor – Season 7, Episode 4

Following “A Town Called Mercy,” “The Power of Three” delves into the evolution of Amy and Rory’s characters. This episode sensitively portrays their everyday life while intertwining the mysterious arrival of the cubes, revealing the significant changes in their dynamic since their first appearances.

Additionally, the introduction of Kate Lethbridge-Stewart adds depth and a link between the modern and classic eras of Doctor Who. While humor and warmth enliven the story, the most poignant takeaway is the Doctor’s realization of his companions’ separate lives, emphasizing the balance between life as a Time Lord and human connections.

2 “Under The Lake”& “Before the Flood”

Modern Era – Twelfth Doctor – Season 9, Episodes 3 & 4

Constructed as one of the finest two-part stories, “Under The Lake” and “Before the Flood” provides a unique twist on the traditional ghost story. Featuring a thoughtful representation of disability through the character Cass, these episodes are noteworthy for their emotional depth and thematic richness.

The interactions exhibit a level of care and realism often absent in sci-fi narratives, while the eerie ambience adds to the suspense that permeates the storytelling. The depth of the Twelfth Doctor’s dialogue also highlights character development and conceptual depth throughout the episodes.

1 “It Takes You Away”

Modern Era – Thirteenth Doctor – Season 11, Episode 9

“It Takes You Away”often slips under the radar as viewers concentrate more on its curious elements, such as the frog, rather than its profound narrative. The episode signifies a pivotal moment in Graham and Ryan’s relationship, addressing grief and the enduring bonds of familial love.

Moreover, the enchanting visuals of the Norwegian landscape enhance the storytelling, creating a poignant atmosphere. Through its narrative and thematic complexity, “It Takes You Away” serves as a reminder of the multifaceted nature of Doctor Who, highlighting that even stories deemed underrated can hold significant emotional and narrative weight.

Source & Images